Mythorelics

Taoist mythology, Lanna history, mythology, the nature of time and other considered ramblings

My Photo
Name:
Location: Chiangrai, Chiangrai, Thailand

Author of many self-published books, including several about Thailand and Chiang Rai, Joel Barlow lived in Bangkok 1964-65, attending 6th grade with the International School of Bangkok's only Thai teacher. He first visited ChiangRai in 1988, and moved there in 1998.

Sunday, April 14, 2019

North vs South, mountain vs beach - a historical theory

Somehow- we don’t know how - humans separated into coastal and mountain peoples. Smaller, darker and more curly-haired ones took up residence along the coasts of south Asia and into Micronesia and Australia, while others gravitated to mountains around the Caspian Sea and on into Afghanistan and Xinjiang, becoming larger and, apparently, more war-like. The Achaemenids who developed the earliest Persian Empire were originally of these, maybe from the Caucasus Mountains. I submit that eventually they extended their rule over most of coastal South and Southeast Asia, utilizing a set of magical formulations (pageantry mostly, maybe) distinct from older animistic rituals, observations and beliefs. With greater fanfare, spectacular ritual and brutally enforced social hierarchy that wasn’t simply militaristic (in guise of protectionist), that influence wass the basis of the Hindu caste system and much of Asian royalty.
Misdirection and even forms of sleight-of-hand might be part of this, but inexplicable behavior designated only as 'beyond common understanding' (if that) is a greater part. Special, ill-defined terminology also helps (you know, like 'redacted' instead of 'censored, deleted' 'hidden' or 'blocked out'; neither my dictionary nor my thesaurus includes it, but an internet search gave me "edit" and also, and I love this, sanitized). Act superior and many will accept it as so. Which helps explain the specialized terminology of so many specializations - workers in every occupation being superior to the rest of us, as it were).
We all indulge in some magical thinking, if only about sex and death; some are far more pretentious about it than others. Perhaps it is just more necessary for them, for war and dynastic power politics, political cohesion, power-structure delineation, influencing emotional weather when necessary, ego maintenance and perhaps other things I'm not able to know about.
Many are well familiar with the “Out of Africa” hypothesis that modern humans evolved in Africa and dispersed across Asia, reaching Australia in a single wave about 60,000 years ago. However, technological advances in DNA analysis and other fossil identification techniques, as well as an emphasis on multidisciplinary research, are revising this story. Recent discoveries show that humans left Africa multiple times prior to 60,000 years ago, that they interbred with other hominids in many locations across Eurasia, and that humans may well have been in Australia even 75,000 years ago. Recent evidence shows that early humans were already present in Eurasia before the split that gave rise to Neanderthals, Denisovans and Homo sapiens sapiens, and that humans almost identical to those of living populations had emerged in East Asia long before they appeared in the African fossil record.
Surely well before egress from Africa humanity had experienced much differentiation: some were better flint-knappers, others good trackers or clothing makers. Some excelled at story-telling, a few learned and retained more than others about roots, barks, mushrooms, poisons, plant or insect secretions useful on wounds… Once in a while someone would excel at ritual, singing, imitating animal noises or whistling. Some could run faster than others, some could carry more. Seems likely to me that someone would be delegated responsibility for fire-starting and tending, while others served more as trackers, scouts and/or guards. Some tended to spread joy, others animosity. And as individuals diverged, so also did groups, and not only in adjustments to varied terrain. We know that some became tall, others short, with tribes remaining that way today. We also know that people that vary extensively from one another often don’t much like each other.
Fossils of seemingly modern humans have been announced by archaeologists working at several Chinese digs, mostly in central and southern China, with associated dates ranging from 80,000 to 178,000 years in age. A site with evidence of very early symbolic behavior (prior to 40,000 BCE) is Kara Bom (discovered 1981), is located, like Denisova Cave of the extremely robust Denisovans, in the Russian Altai Mountains (near where Kazakhstan and Mongolia almost meet, and Russia and China do).
A single dispersal of anatomically modern humans out of Africa around 60,000 years ago can’t be the full story. Homo sapiens reached distant parts of the Asian continent, as well as Oceania, earlier than previously thought. Additionally, evidence that modern humans interbred with other hominids already present in Asia, including Neanderthals and Denisovans, complicates the evolutionary picture. Humans, well, hominids anyway, apparently started leaving Africa as early as 200,000 years ago, at about the time of the advent of modern humans. Maybe some hominids left much, much earlier, unless somehow some parallel evolution occurred or scientists just have the wrong end of the stick. Finds show that modern humans reached Southeast Asia and Australia well before 60,000 years ago, quite likely before 70,000 BCE.
However, other recent studies do confirm that all present-day non-African populations branched off from a single ancestral population in Africa approximately 60,000 years ago. This could indicate that there were multiple, smaller dispersals of humans out of Africa beginning perhaps 120,000 years ago, perhaps earlier, but followed by a major exodus about 60,000 years ago. While the recent dispersal contributed the bulk of the genetic make-up of present-day non-Africans, much earlier journeys contributed significantly to our genetic and physical variety. Migrations out of Africa prior to 60,000 years ago surely were of small groups of foragers; some of them eventually left genetic traces that have come down to modern human populations. A later, major 'Out of Africa' event most likely occurred around 60,000 years ago or thereafter.
Recent genetic research has shown that modern humans interbred with other ancient hominids - not only with Neanderthals, but also with recently-discovered relatives the Denisovans (as well as with a currently unidentified population of pre-modern hominids). One estimate is that all present-day non-Africans have 1-4% Neanderthal heritage. Another estimation gives modern Melanesians an average of 5% Denisovan heritage. It’s clear that modern humans, Neanderthals, Denisovans and perhaps other hominid groups overlapped in time and space in Asia, and had many instances of interaction.
The increasing evidence of these interactions suggests that the spread of material culture is also more complicated than previously thought. The spread of modern human behaviors didn’t occur in a simple progress starting from Africa and going east. Ecological variation needs to be considered in concert with behavioral variation between the different hominid populations present in Asia during the Late Pleistocene – with study of the interplay between genetics and environment.
Northward-traveling human foragers carried tool-kits including blades and composite tools, and also symbolic objects (beads and colorants). Their successful establishment in higher latitudes and altitudes was accompanied by straightened hair, lightened skin and increased stature. The southern route includes probable movement pathways through or perhaps around the Indian subcontinent, to mainland Southeast Asia (well, first to the now submerged Sunda Shelf, where towns may have been built over 10,000 years ago, with remains now being discovered), as far north as central China and southward into the Southeast Asian islands and on to Australasia. Questions remain as to why modern human foragers arriving in Southeast Asia left no blade or stone tools – at least few have been found. Rust, weathering, earthquakes, water damage or unwillingness to part with seriously important utensils may well have contributed. Evidence shows ground stone technologies, among other adaptations to new environments. There are also many questions concerning what happened when different foraging groups, originating in areas to the north and south, met in central China. We refer to modern Han Chinese as a single, almost monolithic culture, but it isn’t. Northerners are larger wheat eaters, Southerners eat rice and many left in a huge diaspora that produced many, many powerful business people. Mongol and Japanese influence also varied greatly, but this seems only tangential to the subject here.
Much as the Great Rift Valley of Tanzania was a cradle of humanity, there may have been another – the Caucasus. Not of the sand and beach people certainly, but of those who eventually conquered and controlled them. Not Caucasians, per se, nor even light-eyed, light-skinned people, but hardy people who’s hardiness developed in mountains. As humans moved across the Asian and European continents about 50,000 years ago, moving away from the equator and facing diminished threat from ultraviolet exposure, natural selection would have favored lightening mutations, and it’s entirely possible that light skin evolved unconnectedly in many places.
Wikipedia tells us: “The nation states that comprise the area today are the post-Soviet states Georgia (including Adjara and Abkhazia), Azerbaijan (including Nakhchivan), Armenia, and the Russian Federation, with divisions including Dagestan, Chechnya, Ingushetia, North Ossetia–Alania, Kabardino–Balkaria, Karachay–Cherkessia, Adygea, Krasnodar Krai and Stavropol Krai (in clockwise order). Three territories in the region claim independence but are recognized as such by only a handful of entities: Artsakh, Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Abkhazia and South Ossetia are recognized by the world community as part of Georgia, and Artsakh as part of Azerbaijan.”
The Caucasus, one of the most linguistically and culturally diverse of regions, has over 50 ethnic groups and at least three indigenous language families. This indicates lengthy habitation – without which so much differentiation is unlikely to have occurred.
Caucasus languages are sometimes mistakenly referred to as a family of languages, but aren’t. Three of the distinct families have no native members outside the Caucasus. In addition, Indo-European languages, such as Armenian and Ossetian, and Turkic languages, such as Azerbaijani, Kumyk language and Karachay–Balkar, are spoken. Kartvelian, formerly known as the South Caucasian or Iberian language family, includes Georgian, the official language of Georgia, Svan, Zan, Mingrelian and Laz. Northeast Caucasian languages (Avar–Andic, Nakh-Daghestanian or Caspian family) include Andic, Akhvakh, Karanta, Botlikh, Godoberi, Chamalal, Bagvalal, Tindis and also the Chechen language (1.5 million speakers).
Also in the region are Tsezic peoples (Tsez, Hinukh, Bezhta, Hunzib and Khwarshi), Lezgic peoples (Aguls, Lezgians, Ingush, Rutuls, Tabasarans, Tsakhurs, Kryts, Buducks, Udins, Archins, Dargins, Laks and the Khinalug), plus Nakh peoples: Bats, Chechens, Kists, and the Ingush. And Circassians: Adyghe, Kabarday, Cherkess, and Ubykh.
Northwest Caucasian, also called the Abkhazo-Adyghean, Circassian, or Pontic family, includes the Kabardian, Abkhaz and Abaza languages.
The predominant Indo-European language in the Caucasus is Armenian, spoken by the Armenians (maybe 7 million speakers). The Ossetians, speaking the Ossetian language, form another group of the Indo-European language family – with about 700,000 speakers. Ossetic has preserved many features inherited from the language of the Alani and Scythians. Other Indo-European languages spoken in the Caucasus include Greek (Pontic Greek), Persian (including Tat Persian), Kurdish, Talysh, Judeo-Tat, and Slavic languages like Russian and Ukrainian, whose speakers number over a third of the total population of the Caucasus.
Two dialects of Neo-Aramaic are spoken in the Caucasus: Assyrian Neo-Aramaic, with around 30,000 speakers, and Bohtan Neo-Aramaic, with around 1,000 speakers. Both of these were brought to the Caucasus by ethnic Assyrians fleeing Assyrian Genocide during WWI.
A dialect of Arabic known as Shirvani Arabic was spoken natively in parts of Azerbaijan and Dagestan throughout medieval times until the early 20th century. In the 19th century, it was considered that the best literary Arabic was spoken in the mountains of Dagestan.
Several Turkic languages are spoken in the Caucasus, with Azerbaijani is predominant. Other Turkic languages spoken include Karachay-Balkar, Kumyk, Nogai, Turkish, and Turkmen.
And the Kalmyk language, spoken by descendants of Oirat-speakers from East Asia, is a Mongolic language.

The territory of the Caucasus region was inhabited by Homo erectus since the Paleolithic Era. In 1991, early human (that is, hominin) fossils dating back 1.8 million years were found at the Dmanisi archaeological site in Georgia. Scientists now classify the assemblage of fossil skeletons as the subspecies Homo erectus georgicus. The site provided the earliest unequivocal evidence of early human presence outside Africa (the Dmanisi skulls are the five oldest hominins ever found outside Africa).
Chechens are one of the Nakh peoples, who have lived in the highlands of the North Caucasus region since prehistory. There is archeological evidence of historical continuity dating back since 3000 BCE as well as evidence proving their migration from the Fertile Crescent c. 10,000–8,000 BCE. In the Middle Ages, the lowland of Chechnya was dominated by the Khazars and then the Alans. Khazar, Alan and Armenian genetics seem to account for much of non-Semetic Jewry.
Traces of human settlement dating back to 40,000 BCE found near Lake Kezanoi, with cave paintings, artifacts, and other archaeological evidence, indicate continuous habitation for some 8,000 years by people who’d mastered fire, used animal skins for warmth and had a variety of tools. Just to the south, agriculture seems to have arisen in at least two separate, discrete areas, at least 10,000 years BP.

For an area of only about 500x400 kilometers, the ethnic and linguistic diversity of the Caucasus is extraordinary. Continental France covers about 1000 km from north to south and from east to west. Texas, at 696,241 km2, is 10% larger than that. Afghanistan is 652,000 square kilometers, Myanmar 678,500, and Thailand at 513,120 is still over twice as large.
Myanmar, with beaches, lowlands and high mountains, is said to be one of the most diverse of places, with about 60 ethnic groups and four major language families (Sino-Tibetan, Tai–Kadai, Austro-Asiatic, and Indo-European). Thailand has less diversity, with Siamese, T’ai (Tai Khoen, Tai Lue, Tai Luang); Thai Lao (Thai Loei, Lao Lom, Lao Khrang, Lao Wiang/Klang, Lao Ngaew, and Lao Ti); the related Khon Muang (Northern Thais); Phu Thai; the much less related 'Khon Pak Tai’ Southern Thais; Khmer and Khmer Leu (Northern Khmer); Malays; Ngaw; Kuy/Kuay (aka Suay); Moken; Karen; various Chinese (Teh Chiew, Hokkian, Hainanese, Hakka, Yunnanese); and the “hill tribes” Lisu, Lahu, Akha, Hmong, Yao/Mien, Palong, Padong, Pa-O, Paluang, Bisu, Khmu, and Htin. France, Afghanistan and Texas hardly compete.
The Caspian Sea, to the east of Caucasia, is the world’s largest inland body of water, with no outflow and salinity of approximately 1.2% - about a third that of most seawater. Surface water in the Black Sea, to the west, has salinity of 17 psu (practical salinity unit) - but reaches the Mediterranean with a salinity of 34 psu, similar to ocean water. It’s said to not mix with lower levels of water, but still, neither sea would have been all that much of a draw for early habitation! Apparently though, the mountains somehow were, at least until lowland civilizations became a draw for some (much as seems to have been the case for peoples from Altai and Tibet - also the Mughals of Babur came down out of the mountains of Afghanistan to northern, and later central, India).
Cattle, goats, sheep, and pigs all have their origins as farmed animals in the Fertile Crescent of eastern Turkey, Iraq, and southwestern Iran. Their domestication began the Neolithic Revolution, between 13,000 to 10,000 years ago. Taking root around 12,000 years ago, agriculture triggered changes in society and the way people lived. Gatherer/hunter traditions gave way to permanent settlements with better food storage. Out of agriculture, cities and civilizations grew, and because crops and animals could now be farmed to meet demand, the global population rocketed - from some five million people 10,000 years ago to over seven billion today.
In Crete, Greece, there existed one of the oldest and most powerful civilizations on earth: the Minoan civilization, which arose about 3000 BCE (perhaps before Phoenicia or Egypt although that is not clear, and the Sphinx is clearly much older). They received the name from the legendary King Minos, though some suggest that Minos was not his name but his title, like ‘Governor’ in the ancient Cretan language. The Minoan Empire was a Bronze Age civilization that arose in Crete and flourished almost 5000 years ago, until it was destroyed by volcano and tsunami in 1450BCE. The Minoans were educated, with artists, warriors and merchants, and many accomplished sailors. Their maritime empire was vast; the first large civilization of Europe. Perhaps with the arrival of new people with new technology, by 2000 BCE the Minoan Neolithic community had developed a hierarchical society with centralized administration. They were building palaces, conducting extensive trade, and producing wonderful pottery, jewelry, statues, carvings, frescoes and other artifacts. The first in Europe to use a written language, now called Linear A (finally deciphered only just recently), they dominated the Mediterranean Sea, but became something like a prototype for the Atlantis legend, leaving little but tokens of its grandeur. According to Homer, the kingdom had 90 cities, the main city being Knossos, and was governed for 9 years by King Minos, in close relationship with his father, the god Zeus. The legend of Talo—the giant metallic, robot-like being gifted to Minos by Zeus—took place during the period of the Minoan civilization. Daedalus, the man who built a ‘flying machine’ for his son Icarus, lived in Crete at this time, and designed great structures for Minos, including the famous labyrinth where the Minotaur was held captive. Theseus, son of the god Poseidon, killed the Minotaur with the help of Minos’ daughter, Ariadne. The labyrinth was considered mere legend until Sir Arthur Evans discovered the city of Knossos in Crete.
We’ve long heard of ‘barbarians’ from Altai, Mongolia, Tibet and the Caucasus invading more ‘civilized’ (agricultural) areas and dominating them for generations; one thing that we haven’t been able to do is analyze the methods of control that rulers developed and handed down, as they have, quite naturally, been much inclined to keep those matters to themselves. By the 7th century BCE, the Persians had settled in the south-western portion of the Iranian Plateau in the region of Persis, which came to be their heartland. From this region, Cyrus the Great, descendant of barbarians from we know not what mountains, advanced to defeat the Medes, Lydia, and the Neo-Babylonian Empire, but Iranian elites of the central plateau reclaimed power by the second century BCE. Cyrus’s Achaemenid Empire c. 550–330 BCE), a.k.a. the First Persian Empire, was larger than any previous empire in history, spanning a million square kilometers. At its greatest extent it stretched from the Balkans in the west to the Indus Valley in the east. Incorporating various peoples of different origins and faiths, it is notable for its successful model of a centralized, bureaucratic administration (through satraps under the King of Kings), for building infrastructure including roads and a postal system, an official language in use across its territories, and the development of civil services and a large professional army. Its successes inspired similar systems in later empires.
In another blog I discuss Persian influence into SE Asia (https://mythorelics.blogspot.com/2017/08/a-historical-theory-about-god-kings.html); but here is a quick synopsis (from a 2013 post included in the just referenced one, a post I deleted):

About 3000 years ago, a mountain people from either the Georgian Caucasus or the Badakshan area of Central Asia (northeastern Afghanistan and southeastern Tajikistan), an important trading center through which the “Silk Road” passed, became tempted by thoughts of wealth in lowlands to their west, which they were becoming strong enough to consider appropriating. These people of Kamboja, or Kambujiya, had strong belief in hierarchy, divine will and the right of might. To them, to be able to take was a mandate to do so, within the natural, moral compass and order of things. How could it be else-wise?
In the 9th century BCE they took Persis (now Fars Province of Iran, where Shiraz is), then Anshan (in the Zagros mountains of southwestern Iran), a quite ancient civilization, and soon the whole Iranian plateau.
The empire at around 500 BCE stretched from the Indus Valley in the east to Thrace and Macedonia; it eventually controlled Egypt and encompassed approximately 8 million square kilometers; in 480 BCE it is estimated to have had 50 million people. At its greatest extent, it had absorbed the modern territories of Iraq, Syria, Armenia, Jordan, Israel, Palestine, Lebanon, most of Turkey, parts of Libya, Georgia and Azerbaijan, much of the Black Sea coastal regions and extensive parts of Central Asia, Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Oman. They may well have been the root of the Ksyatriya caste, India’s ruling and military elite who were in charge of protecting society by fighting in wartime and governing in peacetime, and Gautama Buddha was most likely one of them (see the work of Ranajit Pal, who faces much disparagement but seems to me spot on).
Some of these Persian Ksyatriyas created the Srivijaya maritime empire, a splinter group from which met other Kambojas who had come overland (eventually following the path of the Mekong) to the Tonle Sap in what was then the kingdom of Chenla (Zhenla) and what is now Cambodia. These two groups, united by racial background and world-view, would have had trouble communicating verbally after a millennium and a half of differing influences on their language, but they saw the locals in quite the same way. Together they enslaved the local aboriginals, built the extensive Angkor Wat complexes, became known as the Khom and eventually formed the core of Siamese royalty and what became Thailand. As less than 1% has great difficulty holding in slavery over 99%, when drought and the Black Plague hit about 1300 CE, the Angkor Empire started to crumble, its edifices, by the time of the rise of Ayudhaya, left as a bad memory to become over-run by jungle, and the Khom were almost forgotten. Jit Phoumisak, called by some the only Thai intellectual, wrote about this, and seems as a result to have been executed. David K. Wyatt of Cornell University, the foremost historian on Thailand, might well have wanted to write on it, too, but wanted even more to be able to return to Thailand for visits, and so did not, although some of his later writings show interest in the surrounding controversies.
Srivijaya, like the Dutch and British East India Companies, merely expropriated ports, with “Factory” warehouses, and did not attempt administration of colonies (Ligor, now Nakorn Sri Thammarat a possible exception), but the Khom rulers of the Khmer (pronounced “kha-may, the first syllable just like the Thai word for slave) raised rule to an art form, beguiling a gullible public with magical incantations and other bewitchery for half a millennium.

What interests me is not a question of genetic superiority or relative mystical power, but how the divergence occurred: many taking an easier route east mostly along coastal areas with fewer large beasts (well, as I imagine it), while others went north, to mountains and greater difficulties. Could it be just that some folk are more ornery than others?

With thinking about all this, I find myself needing to question who, precisely, the Chinese are, or quite how they became that. It’s a quite a lot less clear than one might easily expect. So much presented strikes me as less than suspect: that Chinese are albino San bushmen, that the ‘Mongoloid’ type dominant in the area of China appeared only relatively recently, that DNA research without more recent epigenetic understandings tells as much as has been claimed...

In 1965 fossils were found in Yuanmou County, Yunnan, that show early Homo erectus living within today’s China as early as 1.7 million years ago. Two fossil teeth from the inside upper jaw of a young male were unearthed in the same layer as stone chips and stone tools with traces of the work of early man along a three-meter-thick layer of earth containing carbon, indicating that Yuanmou Man both made simple tools and knew how to use fire. But a site at Xihoudu (西侯渡) in Shanxi Province is said to be the earliest recorded use of fire by Homo erectus - and is dated to 1.27 million years ago. I have no explanation for the discrepancy other than the bitter ego rivalries that regularly occur within the realms of academia (and elsewhere).
Lantian man of the Chenjiawo area lived between 700,000 to 1,150,000 BP. That’s much older than the more famous Peking Man (220,000 - 580,000 years ago) found at Zhoukoudian near Beijing. Lantian Man lived in the early Pleistocene, as did distant cousins in Java and East Africa. The skull fossil of Peking Man, found in 1929 at Zhoukoudian, Fangshan, in suburban Beijing, shows a brain capacity of 1,059 ml., smaller than that of modern man (1,400 ml.). But Peking Man could speak, walk upright and engage in productive labor. Fossils of bones and teeth belonging to over 40 men and women of different ages were later dug up at the same site, as also were over 100,000 pieces of roughly processed stone tools – tools for cutting, smashing, chopping and trimming. A layer of ash six meters thick, with burned animal bones, shows that Peking Man used fire to cook food.
Homo erectus remains from Longtandong, Hexian, Anhui date from 190,000 to 300,000 years ago. Homo sapiens bones have been found and identified as from 180,000 to 280,000 years old, at Jinniushan, Yingkou, Liaoning and Tianshuigou, Dali, Shaanxi. The Liujiang hominid (of Liujiang County) has been controversially dated at 139,000–111,000 old. Dating results of Lunadong (Bubing Basin, Guangxi, southern China) teeth indicate age of 126,000 years. These were pre-modern people; modern Homo sapiens found around Salawusu, Inner Mongolia date to around 28,000 to 65,000 years ago (Laishui, Hebei), and show similar appearance to today’s people. Hetao people of the Paleolithic Salawusu Culture of Inner Mongolia left remains by Dagouwan and Dishaoguwan villages in Wushen Banner, Ordos City of Inner Mongolia; they left 35,000 year old fossilized animals and stoneware that show beginnings of modern existence.

Modern humans not distantly descended from Africans apparently first arrived at southern China about 100,000 years ago (Zhiren Cave, Zhirendong, Chongzuo City). Scientists generally accept that the origin of modern man was an African woman who lived 200,000 years ago, that some of her descendants arrived in the Middle East some 100,000 years ago, that a group of humans arrived in East Asia and Europe about 60,000 years ago, and that wherever they stopped, they wiped out earlier hominids - but often only after first mating with them. Neanderthal Man in Europe and the Peking Man in China were hominid branches that went extinct, but left genetic traces.
Homo-sapien-sapiens may have first left Africa about 60,000 BCE; but clearly other hominids left before. Early modern Africans are thought to have had two great migrations East: the ‘first’ migration, purportedly of Blacks with straight hair, took a route along the coast of Asia, then island hopped from the Sunda Shelf to Oceania and Australia, and somehow on to South America - leaving remains called ‘Luzia’ in Brazil. By reaching Australia, H. sapiens expanded its habitat beyond that of H. erectus; it’s now suggested that this happened before 70,000 BCE.
The 2nd migration event is also claimed to have been of Blacks with straight hair, but with Mongol features like those of the ‘San’ people of the Kalahari Desert. They took an ‘inland route’ through southern Asia then up to China, about 50-45,000BCE. Included within this group, somehow, were straight haired Blacks without Mongol features - called Dravidians - who settled in India and other areas of southern Asia, and also Albinos (Blacks without pigmentation), somehow motivated to seek relief from the heat and burning sunshine of southern Africa - and relief from the torment heaped upon them by more normal, yet superstitious, Africans. To me, though, accepting that high cheek-bones show connection between the San and Mongolians, half a world apart and with not much clear connectivity between, seems more than just a bit of a stretch.

The gap of about 50,000 years between homo sapiens settling Australia and then North America indicates a strong popular preference for serene southern sea-sides over rugged, snowy northern mountains. But it was northern mountaineers who conquered. Maybe mountains are genetically uplifting, making from mere homo-sapiens 'homo-sapiens-sapiens' with pragmatic understanding of the value of those just there to be used (like lowly sand lovers, totally expendable as shown by their tendency to over-populate!). The physically onerous background experience of the mountaineers allows that they hardly even need harden their hearts: natural ethical progress, God’s Plan, survival of the fittest. And how nicely convenient, those Great Teachers that helped make the low-landers so easy to, as necessary, control (and dispose of, or redact, as it were). By which I hardly mean to imply that power-mad killings by locals of hot, low-lying areas have been rare; many forms of adversity &/or misfortune might tend to inspire callous cynicism. Nor do I know of Innuit or Lapp/Sami mass-murderers (although I suspect there to have been at least a case or two). Still, the most avaricious raiders might well have had cold mountain backgrounds or at least ancestry. Tricky to take a survey.

The Tung-tien-yen cave, Liu-chiang County, Kwangsi was discovered in 1958 to contain human remains from the late Pleistocene (Ice Age) geological epoch (about 2.5 million to 11,700 years ago). A skull from there was described as ‘Evolving Mongoloid’, but also as Melanesian or Negrito.
Modern Chinese are seen by some as a mix of Mongol-featured Blacks like the San, their Albinos, Albinos of Central Asians (who later became Europeans), and Blacks like the Jomon in Japan. But understanding just when these admixtures took place requires we know exactly what was meant by ‘Primitive Mongoloid’ or ‘Evolving Mongoloid’ and how that differs from Eskimos… When the dark, kinky-haired Asians of southern coastal areas arrived is no more clear than who the ‘Blacks with straight hair’ were, or why differing hair-types separated, either. Ethnocentrism hasn’t helped the investigations.

Tianyuan Man, who lived in China 40,000 years ago, showed substantial Neanderthal admixture. A 2017 study of the ancient DNA of Tianyuan Man found him closely related to modern East Asian populations, but not a direct ancestor. A 2013 study found “Neanderthal introgression of 18 genes within the chromosome 3p21.31 region (HYAL region) of East Asians” (sorry, but that’s beyond the scope of my understanding). Migrations eventually turned northeast to China and finally reached Japan before turning inland, as is said to be evidenced by a pattern of mitochondrial haplogroups descended from haplogroup M, and in Y-chromosome haplogroup C. Findings suggest Neanderthal ‘introgression’ occurred within ancestral populations shared by East Asians and Native Americans. One reason I wanted to put this together was to avoid terminology like ‘introgression’ and ‘dispersed out of Africa’ – which I hardly think help with clarity. I suspect ‘haplogroup’ to be an essential term, but lots of professional people simply admire terms unused outside of their profession!

Until the Neolithic era (10,000 BCE) Homo erectus and Homo sapiens lived in loosely organized packs. Fossils unearthed by scientists were likely covered accidentally. Landslides and volcanic activity are good for preservation! Only when our ancestors settled in cooperative villages and began to bury their dead did lots of remains become preserved.

Southeast Asia (Java) was first reached by hominids about 1.7 million years ago (Meganthropus); Western Europe around 1.2 million years ago (Atapuerca). Denisovan ancestry shared by Melanesians, Australian Aborigines, and smaller scattered groups of people in Southeast Asia (like the Mamanwa, a Negrito people in the Philippines) suggests interbreeding took place in Eastern Asia. Denisovans, an ancient humanlike population previously identified via nuclear DNA taken from a finger bone excavated in Siberia’s Denisova Cave, contributed some genes to living New Guineans, Australian aborigines, two aboriginal groups in the Philippines and populations on several nearby islands; they seem to have ranged from Siberia to Southeast Asia. Some in China claim them as the first modern people. It’s considered possible that they interbred with an unknown archaic human. Another enigmatic species is Homo floresiensis; exactly how and when did they get to the island of Flores (and did they somehow use boats at this very early point in time)? Who were their ancestors?
Homo erectus reached Flores, but not Australia. The species Homo floresiensis (nicknamed ‘hobbit’), found at Liang Bua in Indonesia, may have descended from a very early (before or not long after Erectus) and still unknown migration from Africa.
Clues to migrations of people predating Homo erectus keep appearing; by now, five or six sites in Eurasia span a suggested timeframe of roughly 2.6-2 million years. Recent finds at Shangchen in the southern Chinese Loess Plateau indicate hominid occupation there from 2.1 million years ago. There may have been not only dispersals from Africa, but also back into Africa, starting much earlier than 2 million years ago. The main current model, of Erectus being the first hominid to spread from Africa across Eurasia, fails to account for many recent finds.
During early hominid days, the sea level was much lower and most of Maritime Southeast Asia formed one land mass known as Sunda. Migrations seem to have gone along the coastal route to the straits between Sunda and Sahul, the continental land mass of present-day Australia and New Guinea. Still, gaps (on the ‘Weber Line’) were of 90 km wide, so the migration to Australia and New Guinea seems to have required seafaring skill. A recent study has shown that early travelers made it to Sumatra in western Indonesia between 73,000 and 63,000 years ago; this ties in well with other evidence that hints at humans reaching inner Southeast Asia some time before 60,000 years ago, (and then following the retreating glaciers north). New evidence, though, suggests humans in north Australia even 75,000 years ago – something I believe, but which remains in dispute.

Internet sources (Wikipedia especially) say: Sequencing of one Aboriginal genome from an old hair sample in Western Australia revealed that the individual was descended from people who migrated into East Asia between 62,000 and 75,000 years ago, which supports a theory of a single migration into Australia and New Guinea before the arrival of Modern Asians (between 25,000 and 38,000 years ago) and their later migration into North America. Mitochondrial haplogroups A, B and G originated about 50,000 years ago, and bearers subsequently colonized Siberia, Korea and Japan, by about 35,000 years ago. Parts of these populations migrated to North America during the Last Glacial Maximum. This migration is believed to have happened around 50,000 years ago, before Australia and New Guinea were separated by rising sea levels (approximately 8,000 years ago). This is supported by a date of 50,000–60,000 years ago for the oldest evidence of settlement in Australia, around 40,000 years ago for the oldest human remains, the earliest humans artifacts which are at least 65,000 years old and the extinction of the Australian mega-fauna by humans between 46,000 and 15,000 years ago (as happened in the Americas). Details of stone age tool use in Australia has been much debated.

Genetics of the Ainu people of northern Japan might be a key to the reconstruction of the early peopling of East Asia, as they show a phenotypical trait associated with northeast Siberians and Mongolians through a single mutation of the EDAR gene, dated to c. 35,000 years ago, but once again I sense a serious stretch of imagination.
Maybe ‘dispersals’ occurred from people fleeing the society of, and control by, others. Maybe that desire for independence was accompanied by related tendencies and idiosyncrasies. Maybe changes didn’t come one by one, but came rather, in packages, as it were, as seems to me strongly implied by epigenetics. And maybe desire to not be controlled hardly precludes desire to control. And maybe magic and/or space aliens were involved. At any rate, it seems clear to me, at least, that desire for increased sense of self-importance has limited our ability to understand ourselves.
Maybe some people are more social and friendly, and others more ornery and inclined to attempt assertion of control over others.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, August 17, 2017

A Pantheon of god-kings

There is often huge linguistic, cultural and even genetic difference between rulers and ruled, much, much more so after the advent of ‘civilization’. Most significant is the rather ubiquitous presentation of ‘superiority’ – of right to rule, of need of the ruled to BE ruled, and of a great gap, between those who can rule and those who cannot.

To start with my exposition, a ‘true’ story (as true as any history, anyway):
When Philip II was born, about 382 BCE, Macedonians were “wandering about without resources, many of them clothed in sheepskins and pasturing small flocks in the mountains, defending them with difficulty against the Illyrians, Triballians and neighboring Thracians” (according to Arrian of Nicomedia). This is exaggerated, but Philip’s father Amyntas III had difficulty defending his country, a client state of Illyria.
As a young man, Phillip spent 3 years as a hostage to Thebes, which had the most powerful army in Greece. Phillip studied the tactics of its renowned commanders, and the then-famous ‘Theban wedge’ which could be used in a mass attack over open ground by a phalanx at pace, to drive an enemy from the battlefield. Deeply impressed by the Theban elite force the ‘Sacred Band’, he later modeled his own elite forces on it. The earlier Macedonian army had had a capable, aristocratic cavalry alongside a light infantry of peasants, but after becoming regent, Philip quickly re-molded it into a superb fighting unit, with expert heavy infantry. He increased the size of the army from 10,000 to 24,000, greatly expanded the cavalry (from 600 to 3,500) and trained troops in the latest Theban tactics. He supervised drills and discipline, made sure that the army was paid regularly and received other benefits, including uniforms. Soldiers were no longer loyal to a particular town or province but faithful only to the king. They weren't citizen-soldiers but professionals. Philip soon made the phalanx more flexible, with a better system for communications. He introduced a very long spear, 14 to 20 feet in length, so that the phalanx could reach the enemy before themselves coming within reach of enemy spears. He equipped every soldier with a short sword, ideal for close combat, a new helmet, and a redesigned shield. He also established a corps of engineers which soon proved adept at siege warfare, using towers and catapults.
Forced by Athens to cooperate in attempt to conquer the city of Amphipolis, once it was captured, he kept it for himself, breaking off collaboration. Amphipolis controlled the Strymon River, which passed along strategically important forests with high trees ideal for building ships; it controlled the road from Macedonia to Thrace, and most importantly, had gold mines, at Mount Pangeon. As long as Macedonia had Amphipolis, it had resources to build up its army, and could also blackmail neighboring sea powers.
At Chaeronea in 338, Philip’s army feigned a retreat that created openings for his cavalry, and thus won a great victory over the Greeks. 18-year-old Alexander led heavy cavalry against the Athenian Sacred Band, an extraordinarily responsible position which delivered the knock-out blow. The Sacred Band was wiped out. As a result, Phillip was able to form the League of Corinth (337), bringing almost all Greek city-states into alliance. Once appointed as leader of the Greeks, confident in his superior military, he inaugurated war against Persia by sending an army to 'free' the Greek cities of Asia (Anatolia, today Turkey). Already hoping to establish a cult of divinity for himself and his family, he built a circular edifice he named the Philippeum, with gold and ivory statues of him, his wife, his parents and Alexander. Alexander was appointed an ambassador extraordinary to Athens, which went well, until suddenly father and son were at odds. As leaving on his Asiatic campaign involved risk of a plot back home for a usurping coup, Phillip had initiated precautions.
Alexander felt destined from birth to, like Achilles, win glory and renown fighting barbarians in Asia, and resented being deprived of glory from the victory at Chaeronea, and felt that his virtue and accomplishments mandated quick elevation. Philip had made the tool (his army), but it seemed to his son his right to prove what it could do, as he had, after all, been raised to that task. Phillip, having problems feeling secure in his position while away (and unable to be two places at once), exiled the haughty prince and his mother. Preparations for the invasion went ahead with 10,000 men, including 1000 cavalry, sent over to ‘liberate the Greek cities’.
During his conquest of Greece, Philip had married seven times, despite becoming much less handsome through many scars of war. After two decades of fighting, he'd a fractured collar and mutilated hand, was missing an eye, and walked with a limp thanks to a lance wound to his leg. His 7th wife, Cleopatra, first had a daughter, but then a son, who, unlike Alexander, was fully Macedonian. Phillip performed magnificent sacrifices to the gods to celebrate the birth and also the wedding of a daughter to the king of the Epirots, invited friends from all over Greece, and instructed his friends to bring as many of their acquaintances as they could. Provided were music contests, public games and rich, sumptuous feasts for those bound to him by ties of guest friendship.
When people flocked to the festival, not only was Philip awarded crowns of gold but among processional statues of the twelve Olympian gods (including Dionysus) extravagantly fashioned with the most magnificent workmanship and wondrously adorned with the gleam of precious metal, a thirteenth was carried, a statue fit for a god, of Philip himself, enthroned with the twelve Olympians. It wasn't just Alexander who was haughty.

Years earlier, a Macedonian named Pausanias became a bodyguard of Philip, who loved him for his good looks. On observing another man of the same name becoming the object of the king’s affections, he made a great jealous scene, abusing the second Pausanias by calling him a hermaphrodite and promiscuous little tart willing to submit to the erotic advances of anyone who desired to initiate them. The humiliated replacement killed himself for shame (in battle, it’s told, protecting Phillip). A friend then invited the first to dinner, plied him with unwatered wine until he was dead drunk, and with his other guests raped the youth by turns, then, when done, gave him over to the grooms and muleteers from his stable, to further sexually abuse. On sobering up from his intoxication, Pausanias was extremely bitter about the physical abuse he’d suffered and complained to Phillip, who did nothing but offer some gifts and a higher place among his bodyguards. Pausanias nursed wrath against one who had demeaned him by failing to extract vengeance, until opportunity came to kill him. That the victim was also one who had accomplished much and so would be remembered, as then also would be his slayer, mattered also, bu he was unlikely to have done it without encouragement and help from others.
As part of the celebrations, Philip ordered his bodyguards to leave him for a time (as a leader, not a tyrant, it would send the wrong signal for him to attend a public celebration, in the royal theater, surrounded by armed men). Pausanias disobeyed the orders, lingered behind, and when no-one was watching, stabbed a Celtic dagger into Philip’s heart.
This happened at a crucial moment for Alexander, who quickly took over. Some hold that the murder was instigated by Olympias, Alexander’s mother, and that Alexander himself knew his father was to be killed. Olympias was resentful at having been divorced, and feared the new son would supplant her own. Both are thought to have encouraged Pausanias; Olympias had horses prepared for the escape of the assassin. A few days later, she burnt his body upon the remains of her ex-husband, made him a tomb in the same place, and provided that yearly sacrifices should be performed for him. She tortured Cleopatra, even killing her daughter in her lap, then she forced her to hang herself. She publicly consecrated the Celtic knife with which the king had been killed, to Apollo, under the name of Myrtale, which was Olympias’s own name when a child. None dared voice criticism.
At the age of only twenty, Alexander, through a virtual paracide, became king of Macedonia. To throw into disarray any potential accuser, he directed towards Persians suspicion of having arranged the plot. A letter from him to Persian King Darius purportedly states that: “My father was killed by conspirators whom you instigated as you have yourself boasted to all in your letters.”
Philip, in the course of a reign of 24 years, had been the greatest of the kings of Europe of his day. Found in his tomb were the remains of his last wife, and of the son born a few days before his assassination, also killed soon after Philip’s murder.

About 3000 years ago, a mountain people from the Badakshan area of Central Asia (northeastern Afghanistan and southeastern Tajikistan), an important trading center through which a “Silk Road” passed, became tempted by thoughts of wealth in lowlands to their west, which they were becoming strong enough to consider appropriating. These people of Kamboja, or Kambujiya, had strong belief in hierarchy, divine will and the right of might. To them, to be able to take was a mandate to do so, within the natural, moral compass and order of things. How could it be else-wise?
In the 9th century BCE they took Persis (now Fars Province of Iran, where Shiraz is), then Anshan (in the Zagros mountains of southwestern Iran), a quite ancient civilization, and soon the whole Iranian plateau.
The empire at around 500 BCE stretched from the Indus Valley in the east to Thrace and Macedonia; it eventually controlled Egypt and encompassed approximately 8 million square kilometers; in 480 BCE it is estimated to have had 50 million people. At its greatest extent, it had absorbed the modern territories of Iraq, Syria, Armenia, Jordan, Israel, Palestine, Lebanon, most of Turkey, parts of Libya, Georgia and Azerbaijan, much of the Black Sea coastal regions and extensive parts of Central Asia, Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Oman. They may well have been the root of the Ksyatriya caste, India’s ruling and military elite who were in charge of protecting society by fighting in wartime and governing in peacetime, and Gautama Buddha was most likely one of them (see the work of Ranajit Pal, who faces much disparagement but seems to me spot on, at least about some things).
Some of these Persian Kshatriyas created the Srivijaya maritime empire, a splinter group from which met other Kambojas who had come overland (through Afghanistan, south of the Himalayas to Bengal and eventually following the path of the Mekong) to the Tonle Sap in what was then the kingdom of Chenla (Zhenla) and what is now Cambodia. These two groups, united by racial background, world-view and Indo-European language, would have had trouble communicating verbally after a millennia of differing influences on their language, but they saw the locals (who mostly spoke Austronesian language) in quite the same way. Together they enslaved the local aboriginals, built the extensive Angkor Wat complexes, became known as the Khom and eventually formed the core of Siamese royalty and what became Thailand. As less than 1% has great difficulty holding in slavery over 99%, when drought and the Black Plague hit about 1300 CE, the Angkor Empire started to crumble, its edifices, by the time of the rise of Ayudhaya, left as a bad memory to become over-run by jungle, and the Khom were almost forgotten.
The term ‘Khom’ gets used for the Ancient Khmer lettering used in Thailand's Buddhist temples to inscribe sacred Buddhist mantras and prayers, with its own script, one sometimes used with some minority languages of southern Laos. A century ago there was an independence movement there (as well as in parts of far southeast Issan, Thailand). Led by Ong Keo (องค์แก้ว) then Ong Kommadam (both were assassinated), the plan was to throw out all foreigners and bring back holy rule. The Kom, Kam or Kamboj are also a tribe in Afghanistan and Pakistan, in the lower part of the Bashgul Valley, also known as Kam Kamboj. Pre-Angkorian Khmer (used 600 – 800 CE) is only known from words and phrases in Sanskrit texts; Angkorian Khmer (Old Khmer) was subsequently used (until the 13th c. CE) as a language of government, but that does NOT mean it’s what rulers spoke at home. Other, accredited scholars have connected the names Kom and Kata with ancient Kamboja, but discussion of this seems to be frowned upon by Thailand’s ruling elite in Bangkok.
Jit Phoumisak, called by some the only Thai intellectual, wrote about Khom rulers of Angkor, and seems as a result to have been executed. David K. Wyatt of Cornell University, the foremost historian on Thailand, might well have wanted to write on it, too, but wanted even more to be able to return to Thailand for visits, and so did not, although some of his later writings show interest in the surrounding controversies.
Srivijaya, like the Dutch and British East India Companies, merely expropriated ports, with “factory” warehouses, and didn't attempt administration of colonies (Ligor, now Nakorn Sri Thammarat, Thailand, a possible exception), but the Khom rulers of the Khmer (pronounced “kha-may”, the first syllable just like the Thai word for slave) raised rule to an art form, beguiling a gullible public with magical incantations and other bewitchery for half a millennium.

This is fascinating: in his “A history of Cambodia” David Chandler says, “In the 17th century, according to Dutch sources, foreign traders were required to live in specific areas of the new capitol, Udong, reserved for them and to deal with the Cambodian government only through appointed representatives, or shabandar.”
Wikipedia says, “Shāhbandar (Persian: شه‌بندر‎‎, lit. “harbourmaster”), was an official of the ports in Safavid Persia and one also known on other shores of the Indian Ocean. The Shahbandar (Port Master) was in charge of the traders and the collection of taxes. The office of shahbandar first appeared in Persia, and from there spread throughout the Indian Ocean basin.” Chandler doesn’t mention Persians though.
Yup, Persian influence in SE Asia goes WAY back. As Dr. Ranajit Pal put it, “evidence has revealed the presence of Siddhartha Gautama, the man who became Buddha, as far west as Persia. Family seals and records found at Persepolis, the ancient capital of the fourth Persian Emperor, Darius the Great, have been identified and associated with the names of Siddhartha Gautama and his father, Suddhodana Gautama. … Even the Indus Culture (India) is a colony of the Sumerian Empire, ...”
I was researching to write about Vasco de Gama for one of my novels, and ended up parroting others who had him meeting (and battling with) Arab traders in the Arabian Sea area, as if Persians would not have come down from the Persian Gulf… I’ve corrected that now. Clearly, Persians did travel and interact to the east and south of their home area, and why not? I’ve yet to have solid evidence for my speculations about their possible influence on Angkor, yet, though.
Seems likely to me that well before Persians became bureaucrats for Cambodian and Thai kings, they traded through a large coastal area extending until Chinese influence and control became too strong to deal with. Over centuries, they became knowledgeable in methods of control, lost interest in colonization or active political control in preference to manipulations through trade (for the most part), doing what Portuguese, Dutch and British later did with their “East India” companies. A break-away group forged Angkor, though, and kept an empire until Han population explosion and conquest of Han people by Mongols changed the socio-political situation enough that an alliance with T’ai peoples, emigrating for safety’s sake from their Southern Chinese homelands, seemed an appropriate recourse. Pressures from Vietnamese peoples may have contributed.
Anyway, mangroves clogging the northern shores of the Gulf of Siam were reduced in extent sufficiently that a new port city on the ChaoPraya River could be built, and a descendant of Shan/Lanna royalty invited to come rule. The rulers of Angkor and their hangers-on, Chinese merchants from Kwantung and others formed a new elite for this new city, which they called Ayudhaya, after a mythological city from the Ramayana tale. Eventually integration of their descendants with locals created the distinction from Malays that has become much more noticeable over the last century. Cambodia was left with neither a strong elite nor much of a trading community (except for Cham Vietnamese who took control of the ports that had exported their forest products), lost population and area and became a kind of satellite state controlled by Siamese and Vietnamese rivals.
This explains more to me than any other scenario I have encountered, and leaves fewer holes, less confusion, and so, utilizing Occam’s Razor, I accept it without the kind of proofs Western academicians prefer.
But I do have this: Tibet and Altai are high-altitude places a series of conquerors descended from. Tajikistan might be another. People from there, or other mountains nearby, conquered Persia and almost Ancient Greece. Their Achaemenid Empire was huge but historians have underestimated it, I think. They didn’t only go West, but also East, along the Old Silk Road and to the headwaters of the Mekong, down that river and finally to Cambodia, the name of which comes from them. Marco Polo’s ludicrous account of descending steadily downhill for three months, into what is now Myanmar, may well be a reflection of this, taken from stories Turk traders heard from Tajiks. After Cambyses II, (a Tajik descendant, I am suggesting), son of Cyrus the Great and uncle of Xerxes, died in a Libyan sandstorm (or something close enough), some of his people turned back and tried India instead, forming the Kshatriyan caste of India and then the Srivijayan maritime empire based in Ligor and Java. One of their explorers, finding descendants of Tajik traders near Tonle Sap, decided to go for real empire instead of just trading, and with the help of a “5th column” of distant relatives, was able to found the Angkor Empire. In 1431, secrets of kingship gleaned over two millennium were used to found Ayudhaya, a trading partner for Southern Chinese loathe to remain subjects of Beijing (or Xanadu, X’ian, of Mongols, Ming or Qing). To accomplish this, when they were overthrown by a successful slave revolt, they allied themselves with T’ai princes pushed south not only by Mongol conquests but by Han Chinese population expansion. Later, others from Persia formed the backbone of Thailand’s Chakri Dynasty’s bureaucracy… Mountain people who ate fresh meat and forest products tended to be much hardier than lowland grain-eating agriculturists, and sometimes found opportunity to enrich themselves through their strength and simultaneously gain revenge on the “civilized” folk who despised them. To maintain supremacy, they found elaborate, formal high-church-like ceremony endowed with purported accouterments of power and embellished with semblances of magic importantly helpful. The pageantry, as it often does, worked, but they had to continually work at it, becoming, in a way, increasingly slaves to their slaves. Thus the switch to “maritime empire,” which was often equally rewarding but less demanding. Ports in India, Indonesia and at Ligor became havens of luxury. Then some, as happens, sociopathically aspired to God-hood. Wealth and power weren’t enough; adulation and sycophancy were desired also. And so, Babylon, Constantinople, Angkor, Xanadu (X’ian) and perhaps Ayudhaya, although in its case, the mountain people must have been at greater remove from their ancestral mountains. I suspect it was similar with the Aztecs. Incas, however, stayed in their mountains (and I know little of their pageantry, except that they had plenty). I suspect that secrets of mass-manipulation have been handed down. This theory might help explain mafia influence in some current governments… Capishe?

To solidify and clarify this concept of a magical importance to god-kings, I made a short history of early ‘civilization’:
The emergence of humanity into what we call civilization is shrouded in mystery; recent archaeology has given us more than myth and legend, and science may soon offer us even more. Today the earliest settlements with several thousand inhabitants known are from the 31st century BCE - cities which housed tens of thousands, at Memphis in Egypt and Uruk of Sumur (Iraq). A 7,000-year-old town by the Nile, across from Luxor, held homes of some important people of Egypt’s First Dynasty - Abydos, a “lost city” believed to date from 5,316 BCE, could have been part of the first capital of one of the earliest Egyptian empires.
The origin of Mesopotamia dates further back; there’s no known evidence of any other civilized society before them. Somewhere around 8000 BCE people there began agriculture, and slowly started to domesticate animals for food as well as to assist in farming. Mesopotamia is credited with being the first place where truly ‘civilized’ societies took shape, about 3300 BCE. It’s unclear to me how Abydos and the early First Dynasty of Egypt weren’t civilized, but nevermind.
People had been creating art beforehand, but that considered culture, not civilization. As Mesopotamia arose, it refined and formalized systems, combining them to form civilization. This began in the highlands (freer from insects and germs and with hardier animals), then moved to where there was better soil, plus ease of irrigation and travel for trade, in lowland Iraq (Babylonia, Sumer and Assyria).
The origins of agriculture in the Near East can be attributed to multiple centers rather than a single core area and that the eastern Fertile Crescent played a key role in the process of domestication. Early cultivation was of wild barley, goat-grass and lentil, all wild ancestors of modern crops. 9800 years ago, domesticated emmer wheat appears. Plants including multiple forms of wheat, barley and lentils together with domestic animals later accompanied farmers as they spread across western Eurasia, gradually replacing the indigenous hunter-gather societies. This didn’t improve living standards, just eliminated need to be nomadic, and allowed for some rapid population growth. People became somewhat smaller with the nutritional changes, but also found strength in numbers.
Around 10,200 BCE Fertile Crescent cultures with pottery (7600 to 6000 BCE) and from there spread eastwards and westwards. Notable was Jericho, the world’s first town (settled around 8500 BCE and fortified around 6800 BCE). The convergence of the Tigris and Euphrates rivers produced rich fertile soil with water for irrigation. The civilizations that emerged around the rivers are the earliest known non-nomadic agrarian societies. From about 6500 to 3800 BCE urbanization began. Agriculture and animal husbandry were practiced in sedentary communities in Northern Mesopotamia, and intensively irrigated agriculture began in the south.
About 3200 BCE, as the two earliest civilizations developed in the area where southwest Asia joins northeast Africa, great rivers are a crucial part of the story. The Sumerians settled between the mouths of the Euphrates and the Tigris. Egypt developed in the long narrow strip of the Nile valley. Ancient Egypt, one of the oldest and culturally richest civilizations, is known for its prodigious culture, with a majestic civilization that resided by the banks of the Nile. It coalesced around 3150 BCE (according to conventional Egyptian chronology) with the political unification of Upper and Lower Egypt under the first Pharaoh. This wouldn’t have been possible had there not been settlers around the Nile valley as early as 3500 BCE - people who fished in the river… but could hardly do very successful hunting and gathering away from the river, in Egypt’s desert lands.

The first god-kings may have been Pharaohs, 5000 years ago. There’s not a lot to go on about that, beyond myths told in hieroglyphs, but we know that magic was resorted to in endeavor to influence Nile floods. Everything depended on the Nile for the people there, but the Nile well resisted puny human efforts to exert any control at all. Record-keeping facilitated anticipation and prediction. Useful flood-gates and canals could be constructed given sufficient central guidance, as also could be grain storage. Central Command was also helpful with crop rotation, but a heavy responsibility, failures at which could easily provoke dangerously disruptive wrath. For social stability anger needed to be controlled, contained and deflected, better than the river could be. To install awe for those in charge could minimize social instability and maximize benefits the river continually brought. So the charade of deification hardly seems strange. It worked well for 3000 years.
The Chinese had two great rivers; when the first god-king somewhat less legendary than the “Yellow Emperor” first occurred isn’t clear; earlier, to be sure, than the first great emperor we’ve records of. From Mesopotamia we know of Cyrus becoming god-king soon after 550 BCE; maybe he initiated the idea there, maybe he’d heard tales from Egypt &/or China.
Rivers offer two main advantages to a developing civilization. They provide water to irrigate the fields, and they offer the easiest method of transport for a society without paved roads. Rivers also played an important role in the civilizations of the Indus, and later, many other places (particularly in Cambodia and Thailand, and along the Mississippi).
King Hammurabi, who ruled from Babylon around 2000 BCE, drew up the first recorded set of laws. His “Code of Hammurabi” set down harsh penalties for those who broke the laws—“an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth.” Punishment fit the crime. These early laws provided everyone, regardless of their class or rank, at least some protection from their neighbors, but punishments differed between the ‘superior’, normal and slave classes.
It’s not known whether contact with Mesopotamia inspired the first civilization of India, but by about 2500 BCE the neolithic villages along the banks of the Indus combined into a unified and sophisticated culture. The Indus civilization, with large cities at Harappa and Mohenjo-daro, expanded over a larger region than Egypt and Mesopotamia combined. It survived, in remarkably consistent form, for about 1000 years. Over 4,000 years ago in the valley of the Indus River (which flows through Pakistan), people enjoyed an ever-improving standard of living, learning to use bronze and copper to make cooking utensils as well as weapons. Mohenjo-Daro had streets paved with bricks and lined with shops.
The Harappan, or Indus Valley Civilization, planned cities in advance, but apparently a massive, centuries-long drought brought the culture into a slow decline, from which it never arose. This is nothing more than a theory, but it helps explain other cultural declines in the area. Beginning sometime in the 25th century BCE, the Harappans developed their language with a script of nearly 500 characters (which have still to be completely deciphered). Noteworthy artifacts include seals made of soapstone depicting animals and mythical creatures. The peak phase of this civilization lasted from 2600 BCE to around 1900 BCE - a sophisticated and technologically advanced urban culture, the first in the region. Its people achieved great accuracy in measuring length, mass, and time. Based on artifacts excavated, it’s evident the culture was rich in arts and crafts. After collapse, the ruins of the Harappan civilization provided a template for the various other cultures which sprang up after it.
Europe’s biggest prehistoric civilization, the Vinca, existed for nearly 1,500 years. Beginning in the 55th century BCE, it occupied land throughout Serbia and Romania. Named after a present-day village near the Danube River, where the first discoveries were made in the 20th century, the Vinca worked metal, were perhaps the world’s first civilization to use copper (they excavated the first mine in Europe). Though the Vinca had no officially recognized form of writing, examples of proto-writing, symbols which don’t actually express language, have been found on stone tablets dating from 4000 BCE. Archaeologists unearthed toys (animals and rattles) from among other artifacts. The Vinca had organized specific locations for trash, with their dead all buried in a central location.
The next region to develop a distinctive civilization centers on the Aegean Sea, about 2000 BCE. The bays and inlets of the rugged coastal regions of Greece, and the many small islands strung like pearls across this relatively sheltered sea, made this an ideal area for trade (and piracy). The Aegean civilization, which began on Crete, stands at the start of the very lively tradition of Mediterranean culture. Surely the reader knows some about that!

Around 3000 BCE the wheel made transportation of good easier and quicker. Mesopotamia was known for metalwork, wool textiles, pottery and foods (dried fish, barley, wheat). Copper, tin and timber were imported. The oldest known wheel found in an archaeological excavation is from Mesopotamia, and dates to around 3500 BCE. By this time, humans were planting crops, herding domesticated animals, engaging in semi-organized fighting and paying for social hierarchy.
Wheels might have been thought of, as they were in Mexico and made for toys but for nothing else, but didn’t obtain utility until metal tools became available to chisel fine-fitted holes and axles. The wheel isn’t just a cylinder as in a Flintstone cartoon; connecting it to a stable, stationary platform presented a serious challenge. The ends of the axle, as well as the holes in the centre of the wheels, had to be nearly perfectly smooth and round, or too much friction between components would hinder and even prevent turning. The axle had to fit snugly in its holes, but with enough room to allow them to rotate freely.
Wheels were first used by potters. A 5,500-year-old wheel from Mesopotamia (Sumeria) was a potters’ wheel; use of wheels for pottery-making likely dates even further back. Wheels for transportation may have first been invented either in Mesopotamia or the Eurasian steppes. An early image of a wheeled cart was found in Poland, and others elsewhere in the Eurasian steppes. The earliest well-dated depiction is on the Bronocice pot (c. 3500 – 3350 BCE) found in southern Poland, and depicts a vehicle with a shaft for a draught animal, four wheels and lines connecting them probably representing axles. The ‘Ljubljana Marshes Wheel’ was found in the capital of Slovenia and dated to 3150 BCE. Linguistic evidence is used to support the claim that the wheel originated in the Eurasian steppes.

The development of proto-writing in Harappa around 3300 BCE was followed by Chinese oracle bone script and Mesoamerican writing from about 2000 BCE. Chinese civilization may have begun about 1900 BCE, although ancient Chinese historical records like the Bamboo Annals mention the Xia Dynasty, for which there is no archeological evidence. The earliest Chinese dynasty for which there is both archeological and written evidence is the Shang Dynasty (1600 to 1046 BCE), sites from which revealed the earliest known Chinese writing, the oracle bone script. The longest consistent civilization is that of China. Its vast empire seems set apart from the rest of the world, fiercely proud of its own traditions, resisting foreign influences. Its history begins in a characteristically independent manner, with no identifiable precedents. Shang texts use characters recognizably related to Chinese writing today.
At Ban Chiang, in Udon Thani, Thailand, graves from about 2100 BCE were uncovered. Bronze making there may have begun c. 2000 BCE, as evidenced by crucibles and bronze fragments. Bracelets, rings, anklets, wires and rods, spearheads, axes and adzes, hooks, blades, and little bells were found. The date of 2100 BCE was obtained from rice phytoliths from inside a grave vessel of the lowest grave. Later analysis suggests that the initial settlement of Ban Chiang took place by about 1500 BCE, with the transition to the Bronze Age about 1000 BCE. Politics seems to have hindered progress with this.

Rice cultivation may have begun quite early along the now submerged Sundaland (the Sunda Shelf), possibly even earlier than barley and lentils in Iraq. Savanna vegetation from the last glacial period, in now submerged areas of Sundaland, suggests a continuous savanna corridor connecting modern mainland Asia to Java and Borneo. Vegetation there may have been dominated by tropical rainforest, with only small, discontinuous patches of savanna vegetation, but a savanna corridor would have allowed for savanna-dwelling fauna and early humans to go from the modern Malaysian Peninsula to Borneo. A 50-150 kilometer wide savanna corridor down the Malaysian Peninsula, through Sumatra and Java, and across to Borneo, is strongly suggested by the composition of bat guano deposits in Sundaland. Life in coastal areas may have been safer from large predators than further inland, but changing sea levels would have caused humans to move away from their coastal homes and culture, farther inland and upland, throughout Southeast Asia. This forced migration would have caused these humans to adapt to the new forest and mountainous environments, fostering development.
A 2009 genetic study published by the 2009 Human Genome Organization Pan-Asian SNP Consortium found that Asia was originally settled by humans via a single southern route from Africa via India, into Southeast Asia and what are now islands in the Pacific, then later up to the eastern and northern Asian mainland. Similarities were found between populations throughout Asia with an increase in genetic diversity from northern to southern latitudes. Although the Chinese population is very large, it has less variation than the smaller number of individuals living in Southeast Asia, because the Chinese expansion occurred recently, within the last 3,000 years, following the development of rice farming. Genetic research from 2008 indicates that islands which remain from Sundaland were likely populated as early as 50,000 years ago, contrary to the hypothesis that they were populated as late as 10,000 years ago from Taiwan. Historical linguistics supports the theory that the home of the Austronesian languages is the main island of Taiwan. Australian Aborigines have been proven resident in that continent from 31,000 BCE. Aboriginal Australians diverged from Papuans some 37,000 years ago, well before the Australian land mass separated from New Guinea roughly 10,000 years ago. It’s widely accepted that Aborigines have been in Australia well over 40,000 years.

Early accounting dates to ancient Mesopotamia. Related to developments in writing, math and money, early auditing systems of ancient Egyptians and Babylonians go back more than 7,000 years. Documents from ancient Mesopotamia show lists of expenditures, and of goods received and traded. The development of accounting, along with that of money and numbers, were related to the taxation and religious trading activities. All emerged in the context of controlling goods, stocks and transactions in the temple economy. People relied on primitive accounting methods to record the growth of crops and herds. Because there was a natural season to farming and herding, it was easy to count and determine if a surplus had been gained after harvests or the weaning of young animals.
Between the 4th and 3rd millenniums BCE, the ruling leaders and priests in ancient Persia had people oversee financial matters. In Godin Tepe (گدین تپه) and Tepe Yahya (تپه يحيی), cylindrical tokens used for bookkeeping on clay scripts were found in buildings that had large rooms for storage of crops. Godin Tepe scripts had only tables with figures, while in Tepe Yahya, they also contained graphical representations. The invention of a form of bookkeeping using clay tokens was a huge leap. During the 1st millennium BCE, commerce and business expanded, as did the role of the accountant. Phoenicians invented a phonetic alphabet for bookkeeping purposes. An individual in ancient Egypt held the title “comptroller of the scribes”.

After 550 BCE, the Achaemenians Cyrus, Darius, Cambysus and Xerxes perfected a new form of semiotic narrative to excuse (whitewash) extension of class and power differentiation and separation, and enhance the empowerment of a predatory, grasping elite. Ritual forms to placate the deprived masses, allow empire building and lavish entitlement for a hereditary few were perfected. This required intermediary levels of managers, overseers, officers and bureaucrats who of necessity had to believe in and support the system exploiting them and the serfs and slaves they direct, shepherd and lead to slaughter. Emblems of rank and privilege became icons: crowns, robes, scepters, diadems, signet seals, thrones and flags joined images and effigies as not only representations but actual implements of power (well, purportedly, anyway), the real object being the total differentiation of rulers and ruled. Eventually lawyers, doctors, journalists, and business executives became priests in this caste differentiation, with bankers as the real power behind figurehead royalty.
An army needs a command center, tents, footwear, reserve weapons, a commissary and kitchens, quartermasters, and in ancient times livestock (to pull wagons, for food, and to ride into battle). All the organization involved demanded relatively sophisticated trade: stockpiles of weapons and gear, tools, bandages, salt, flags and other insignia… things which would be purchased rather than foraged for. So there must have been bursers, pursers, treasurers, coffers, rudimentary bankers with some expertise in exchange rates, accounting, securities and watch-guards. These might act in an intermediary way between political and military rulers (generals like Pompey, Crassus and Caesar had no reliance on treasurer-bursers, and so things easily got out of hand).
At any rate, there was always someone who did accounts, arranged for purchasing, storing and disbursing according to need, and it wasn’t just supply sergeants. Tabulated planning is a responsibility generals and heads of state delegate to appropriately trained and connected functionaries, who find themselves in positions of considerable power and influence, especially when making arrangements outside of the power structure, as often required. Experience suggests that much of their work involved discretion, secrecy and cunning.
Perhaps the first people to fill these positions came from the ranks of those who first gained expertise in animal breeding (and selling). Also, just perhaps, the first really good animal breeders might have been mountain people who couldn’t as easily replace stock as those on the steppe, savanna or prairie. This is just to imagine why folk from Armenia or Tajikistan might have been able to take Persia from the Assyrians and Babylonians (before 500 BCE). I think descendants of those folk were prominent in the Srivijaya maritime empire, organized the building of Angkor Wat, and contributed to history in other, interesting but seldom acknowledged ways.
In 387 BCE, a Gallic war band of Brennus, king of the Senones (from the SE of what is now France then NE Italy) took Rome and held it for several months. The Romans hadn’t yet perfected the fighting style that later made their legions famous; many scattered at the first charge of wild-haired, bare-chested Galls, who only wanted a bit of fun and removable wealth, quite a lot of which they took away. Had they had something to offer, they might well have gained a lot more.
Suppose various refugees from the new agriculturally-supported cities of the Tigris-Euphrates wandered to mountainous areas – criminals, escaped slaves, young adventurers, elders turned recluses, the unfortunate, deformed, humiliated or angered – where they met livestock breeding nomads of much less limited social and intellectual horizons… These horsemen, shepherds, dog breeders and fighting men might have progressed in ways those in the flood-plain had not, due to their mobility, to necessity, to observation of greater variety, and maybe even through ideas brought by the refugees.
Their stronger livestock, better fed, might well have produced a lot more shit, shit useful as fertilizer, for hotter firing of pottery, for warmth where there was little else to burn. A new pottery glaze was once of quite a lot of value. Not only their livestock would have been bigger than that in the flood-plain; they themselves would have been, and practice in warfare might well have taught them useful techniques. But what they really needed, and apparently got, was a “fifth column” – refugees to reinsert into the farming and urban society they came to lust to conquer.
To do better than Brennus’ band, though, they needed to stay, and to manage that they needed to offer something. Too offer more, offer improvements, hope, variety and confidence. These cannot be forced. But better ideas for defense, savvy policing, successful trade, entertainments and pageantry, even clothing, might well have been (at least somewhat, sometimes) possible. Advancement opportunities through new occupations (smithing, marketing, performing, sewing, building and maintenance, rodent killing, tax accounting, overseeing, bucket and wheel manufacture…) could have been suggested by returnees even before military victory, making for more permanent conquest. But instead of the ‘more’ anticipated, they got another kind of more.
With the new “narrative” (as modern academics like to call it) and anticipation of more opportunity, they got more taxes, more mandatory military service, more training to subservience, homogeneity and acquiescence, more regimentation under and even more lavishly pampered elite, more worries, sorrows and headaches, more law, more fear.
With more promise, more mirage and then disillusion – eventually leading to a new invasion by a new order of barbarians promoting then establishing new ideals, greater glories, a better future. With resultant further distancing from that horrible, animalistic, uncivilized hunter-gatherer Garden of Eden. But hey, one now had shiny tokens of somewhat more durability than unprocessed, unpackaged food…

For as long as we’ve had records of social interactions, we’ve had evidence of petty despots, petty tyrannies, injustices and excesses. These might be within small family units in unimportant villages, by unusually strong and skilled warriors or by petty bureaucrats. Once it was most often royalty, now it is perhaps more often elite bankers, members of uniformed services or even elected officials.

Cyrus the Great, or Cyrus II of Persia (in Old Perisan Kourosh or Khorvash; ~576 – July 529 BCE), was the founder of the Achaemenid Persian Empire, first ruled in Anshan, then conquered the Medes and then the Babylonian Empire. His “Cyrus Cylinder” is considered to be the first declaration of human rights. He was the first ruler whose name was suffixed with the words the Great (Vazraka in Old Persian), a title adopted by many others after him. Alexander the Great overthrew the Achaemenid dynasty two centuries after the death of Cyrus.
Cyrus’s notions of human rights influenced Thomas Jefferson and the US Constitution. The “Cyrus Cylinder” decreed religious tolerance, and end to slavery, freedom of choice of profession, and expansion of the empire. The cylinder, along with Biblical and other historical statements, substantiates the idea that Cyrus allowed the nations he conquered to practice their various religious beliefs - an unprecedented tolerance. He assisted captive peoples, including Jews, to return to their lands of origin, giving grants both from the Imperial treasury and also from his own personal fortune. In the Bible, he is known as Koresh - mentioned twenty-two times in the Old Testament Book of Isaiah, where he is unconditionally praised.
Promising religious freedom and human rights, as Cyrus did, was just part of a Big Lie. For government to ‘return’ something it took away is hardly largesse, especially when it makes things easier for government, instead of more difficult. “Freedom” given to bolster power is hardly that, just a bad image or caricature of it.

When Cyrus defeated the Babylonians, he became “king of Babylon, king of Sumer and Akkad, king of the four sides of the world.” He incorporated sub-kingdoms, including Syria and Palestine, into his empire, the largest the world had seen. At the end of his rule, the Achaemenid Empire stretched from Asia Minor and Judah to the Indus River. A large super-state of many dozens of countries, races, and languages, under him it ruled by the single administration of a central government. Centuries later, the administrative techniques created by Cyrus and his successors were adopted by the Greeks and Romans. Modernized versions of his administrative divisions remain in use.
After Cyrus’ death, his son eldest son, Cambyses II, succeeded him as king of Persia. Cambyses continued his father's policy of expansion, capturing Egypt, but then died in a sandstorm, marching on Libya, after only seven years of rule. An impostor named Gaumata became the sole ruler of Persia for seven months, until killed by Darius, a grandson of Arsames, who ruled Persia before Cyrus’ rise.

Chakravartin (Sanskrit cakravartin, Pali cakkavattin) refers to an ideal universal ruler who rules ethically and benevolently over the entire world, it’s chariot “rolling everywhere without obstruction”. The devarāja cult grew from it, or at any rate is closely related. It taught of monarchs as divine universal rulers, manifestations of Shiva or Vishnu. Possessed of transcendental qualities, the king is the living god on earth. The concept gained its elaborate manifestations in ancient Java and Cambodia. Monuments like Prambanan, Borobudur and Angkor Thom and Angkor Wat were erected to celebrate the king’s divine rule on earth. The devaraja cult of Jayavarman II associated the king with Shiva, whose divine essence was represented by a phallic idol housed in a mountain temple. The king was deified in an elaborate and mystical ceremony, in which the divine essence of kingship was conferred on the ruler through the agency of that linga. The safeguarding of the linga became bound up with the security of the kingdom, and the great temple architecture of the Khmer period attests to the importance attached to the belief.
The devaraja concept enables a monarch to claim divine authority, ensuring political legitimacy to manage the social order and its economic and religious aspects. It also exalts the king as a living god, thus demanding the utmost service and devotion of his people. It also enabled the king to embark on large scale public works and grand projects, by mobilizing their people to create and maintain elaborate irrigation systems for agriculture, and to construct grand monuments and temples.
Jayavarman II is widely regarded as the king that set the foundations of Angkor, beginning with a consecration ritual in 802 on sacred Mount Mahendraparvata, now known as Phnom Kulen, to celebrate the independence of Kambuja from Javanese dominion (that of the “neighboring Chams”, or chvea – or perhaps of their Srivijarian rulers). At that ceremony Prince Jayavarman II was proclaimed a universal monarch (Kamraten jagad ta Raja in Cambodian), or chakravartin, Lord of the Universe.
No inscriptions authored by Jayavarman have been found, but he is mentioned in some written long after his death. He appears to have been of aristocratic birth. “For the prosperity of the people in this perfectly pure royal race, great lotus which no longer has a stalk, he rose like a new flower,” declares one inscription.
At Angkor Wat, built under Suryavarman II in the early 1100s CE, one finds bas-relief depictions of the Ramayana/Ramakein/Reamker epic from northeast India, about a perfect king, Rama of Ayodhaya. Maybe this was depicted in Ayutthaya, but still is at Wat Po (Wat Phra Jerubon, 152 depictions in stone) and Wat Pra Kaeo (178 scenes painted in vivid color), both in the City of Angels, Bangkok.
The Ramayana is a marvelous exhibition of elitist propaganda which clarifies what lisping, bejeweled Aristotle taught Alexander son of Phillip: that a ruler must be better in all ways than everyone else. One shudders at thinking how things might have been for leadership, and for the rest of us without these glorious educational exemplars. Rama knew that all who seek asylum must be given protection, that victory without honor isn’t victory at all, and learned that honors, especially kingship, must not be accepted lightly. He exemplifies strength, humility, reverence, loyalty, duty, charity, discipline, generosity, honesty, honor and fortitude, he was valorous and magnanimous, prudent and merciful. He surely inspired many, perhaps even more than Aristotle inspired Alexander. How Sita felt as she jumped to immolate herself… well, surely she understood that Caesar’s wife must be above suspicion, that sacrifices must be made and that the state comes first. Anyway, the flames turned to flowers at her proximity. And anyway, that was just an illusion of the perfect wife, that so many animals sacrificed their lives for (according to the Kurma Purana)…

In the 350 years between the rise of Cyrus II and that of Jayavarman II, “universal rule” centered in Persia, Rome and Constantinople. Egypt had been great until then, but after Cleopatra VII (60-30 BCE) was for almost two millennia a colony. India had empire, as did China, but they were racially hidebound, except in terms, sometimes, of trade. Srivijaya, which seems to have somehow gained from Phoenician experience, didn’t conquer or administrate outsiders. But Jayavarman did – he seized an opening, a rare opportunity to assert divinity. Nothing like the Islamic leadership which for the most part dropped that pretense, but involving a hereditary caste of entirely superior beings (socially, anyway, if not biologically) responsible for all that was good (purportedly). It worked for a while: about four centuries. Then the devaraja god-king, overthrown by Thais, moved to Phnom Penh (1434) while much of the court was forced to Ayutthaya, which adopted much of that convention, tradition and observance. About 1500 CE Ayutthaya became a great trading center and the biggest city in the world, a reality now for the most part forgotten, although that its size and wealth compared favorably to that of the Paris of Louis XIV under King Narai (1656–88) has not.
Pressures from other ‘universal rulers’ – Javanese, Mongols, Burmese, maybe Mughals (though I think not directly) and eventually the Dutch VOC in Indonesia, Catholics of various stripe, the British East India Company, “Western” drug merchants, “overseas” Chinese, and French colonialists all constrained Ayudhaya and its successor capitol KrungThepMahanakorn (Bangkok), limiting horizons. But Jayavarman and his successors made a good stab at empire (“universal” or not) with influence remaining today.

Early Roman Emperors used the title princeps (first citizen), and were leaders of a Republic. After Diocletian took power in 284, senate ratification was but a useless formality. But in 285 Diocletian took on a co-emperor, Maximian. In 286 Maximian took the title of Augustus (after the first emperor, who’d resolutely refused recognition as a monarch, despite changing his name from Octavian to one meaning “sacred” or “revered”). In inscriptions, Diocletian and his cohorts are referred to as “restorers of the whole world” who succeeded in “defeating the nations of the barbarians, and confirming the tranquility of their world”. A new style of ceremony was developed, emphasizing the distinction of the emperor from all other persons. The quasi-republican ideals of Augustus’ were abandoned; Diocletian wore a gold crown and forbade the use of purple cloth to any but emperors. His subjects had to prostrate themselves in his presence (adoratio); the more fortunate were allowed to kiss the hem of his robe. Circuses and basilicas were designed to keep the face of the emperor perpetually in view. The emperor, a figure of transcendent authority, beyond all but power and glory, had his every appearance stage-managed. This adoration led to eventual deification or apotheosis. This type of honor, or Imperial Cult, dated back to Alexander of Macedon, who considered himself not the son of Phillip II but of Zeus. Emperor Augustus was treated as a deity during his reign; altars and temples were built to honor him, although none in Rome itself (at least while he lived). Although he may have considered himself the son of a god, he never permitted himself to be called a god. Upon his death, the Senate would deify him - as would happen to many who followed after. Caligula and Nero deemed themselves gods while still alive, but were considered too odious to maintain the honor after death.
The Western Roman Empire collapsed in the late 5th century, but in the east, emperors continued to rule from Constantinople (‘New Rome’); these are called “Byzantine emperors” but didn’t use that title, calling themselves “Emperor (or King) of the Romans” (βασιλεύς) until their city fell to Ottoman Muslims in 1453. Basileus and megas basileus had been used by Alexander and successors in Ptolemaic Egypt, in Asia (e.g. the Seleucid Empire, the Pergamon and by non-Greek, but Greek-influenced states like the Pontus) and Macedon. The feminine counterpart is basilissa (queen), meaning both queen regent (like Cleopatra VII) and queen consort. By the 4th century basileus was used officially only for the two rulers considered equals to the Roman Emperor: the Sassanid Persian Shahanshah (‘king of kings’), and to a lesser degree the King of Axum, who was rather peripheral. Consequently, the title acquired the connotation of “emperor”; barbarian kings of the “Dark Ages” were but rēx or rēgas, hellenized forms of the Latin title rex, king.

Islam had caliphates with caliphs, persons considered a successors to the Islamic Prophet Muhammad (Muhammad ibn ‘Abdullah). They were purportedly leaders of the entire Islamic community, but the Shi’a/Sunni split limited that reality. The caliphates developed into multi-ethnic trans-national empires including the Rashidun Caliphate (632–661), the Umayyad Caliphate (centered in Damascus, 661–750), the Abbasid Caliphate (Shi’i tolerant, Baghdad, 750 to the Mongol sacking of 1258 but continuing in Egypt to 1520), and the Ottoman Caliphate (which established the Ottoman Empire in 1517). Other hereditary caliphates existed with much lesser importance. The term caliph derives from the Arabic word khalīfah (خَليفة), which means “successor”, “steward”, or “deputy” and was long considered a shortening of Khalifat Rasul Allah (“successor of the messenger of God”) until studies of pre-Islamic texts showed that the original meaning of the phrase was “successor selected by God.” The first caliphate, the Rashidun Caliphate, was established right after Muhammad’s death in 632; four Rashidun caliphs, chosen through shura, a process of community consultation that some consider to be an early form of Islamic democracy, directly succeeded Muhammad. The fourth caliph, Ali, who, unlike the prior three, was from the same clan as Muhammad, is considered by Shias to be the first rightful caliph and Iman, after Muhammad. A civil war between supporters of Ali and supporters of the assassinated previous caliph led to the establishment of the Umayyad Caliphate, in 661. The Abbasid Caliphate was established in 750.
Sunnis hold that a caliph should be elected by Muslims or their representatives; Shiites that a caliph should be an Imam chosen by God from Muhammad’s direct descendants. In simpler terms, the Sunni majority favor election while the Shia minority favor bloodline. Ayatollahs are another thing, Iranian religious leaders, from a term for “reflection of God” “sign of God” and not heads of state – at least until the overthrow of the Shah and initiation of the Iranian Islamic republic, the political head of which is a non-religious leader, the president. Most Shi’is await the 12th Imam while ‘temporarily’ relying on Mujtahid scholars who might become marja-e taqlid mullahs, hojjat-ol Islam, ayatollah and even ayatollah al-uzma – an elaborate hierarchy not matched within Sunni Islam.
These divine rulers have never been just kings of us (as in ‘us vs them’), but of all, (in a conditional, optimistic kind of way) - kinda like the USA being the “world’s policeman” – no?

The Normans, Aztecs and Mughals were also invaders who told the conquered what to believe. Might didn’t just make right, but proved, or better yet, was an aspect of, divine guidance. They were doing God’s will. Many still accept this attitude. Others have learned to see it differently.

“I’ll let you worship freely as long as you recognize that that is a privilege that comes from ME, the God-King Universal Ruler from whom all good things come (including your privilege to be silly).
Less expensive force needed to be exerted, chances for rebellion were lessened, need for duplicity by many folk eliminated while potential threats to public order became less hidden. It’s win-win! But the Big Guy wins the most, mostly for seeming to have done something he didn’t really do (as he has NOT really relinquished control).
Control is only given up, or lost, after it is asserted too much, as controllers are only human (assertions to the contrary notwithstanding) and when cracks begin to show sharks begin to tear flesh. It is ALWAYS the way.
Given that humans go power-mad, abuse authority and forget so much so easily, it’s naieve at best to think that strength brings happiness. Nothing is as dangerous as unfulfilled demigods who can’t even remember how all that they’ve gotten was supposed to be fulfilling, and no longer have any idea of what they want.

Early empire seems to have led to trade without empire (promulgated by the Phoenicians) and then to empire with mass slavery and inevitable power-collapse such as seems to be happening now. Our notional investment communities with their ‘limited liability’ seem to do something I call “money farming” wherein which earnings of the many can be harvested by the few through manipulation of gullibility (aka fashion, materialistic competitiveness, or short-sighted greed: the kind of thing that leads to lack of co-operation and sharing and indulgence in cosmetic surgery, over-priced printer ink, pools and hot-tubs, ‘play-stations’, pleasure boats, private airplanes, world travel, hired friends, security systems, expensive perfumes, exercise equipment, diet fads and fancy hats and sunglasses – feelings of need for which far too many of us slavishly adhere to).
Money having become firmly god-king, or at least the empowering tokens of god-kings, we now seem to be finding it suddenly less accessible or rewarding, more distant and confusing. But take comfort in this: Pharaohs notwithstanding, separation between a class of the deified and the class of the slaving produces gross instability. Social collapse would cause much agony and death, but a phoenix arising from ashes might not take many generations.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,