Mythorelics

Taoist mythology, Lanna history, mythology, the nature of time and other considered ramblings

My Photo
Name:
Location: Chiangrai, Chiangrai, Thailand

Author of many self-published books, including several about Thailand and Chiang Rai, Joel Barlow lived in Bangkok 1964-65, attending 6th grade with the International School of Bangkok's only Thai teacher. He first visited ChiangRai in 1988, and moved there in 1998.

Friday, March 30, 2018

Has agriculture promoted addictive behavior?

It is generally accepted that the history of agriculture began more than 10,000 years ago.
Major forms of agriculture arose independently in at least seven different areas of the world. Each depended on a different mix of plants and non-human animals. Moreover, there are different mixes of horticulture, or small-scale gardening, with other activities, like gathering and hunting.
According to long-standing archaeological theory, there are eight plants that are considered the domesticate “founder crops” in the story of the origins of agriculture on our planet. All eight arose in the Fertile Crescent region (what is today southern Syria, Jordan, Israel, Palestine, Turkey and the Zagros foothills in Iran) during the Pre-Pottery Neolithic period some 11,000-10,000 years ago. The eight include three cereals (einkorn wheat, emmer wheat, and barley); four legumes (lentil, pea, chickpea and bitter vetch); and one oil and fiber crop (flax or linseed). Figs might be a ninth.
The origins of agriculture weren’t just in the western and northern Fertile Crescent (along the Euphrates), but also in the foothills of the Zagros Mountains of Iran (in the eastern Fertile Crescent). At the site of Chogha Golan there, charred plant remains (including wild barley, goat-grass and lentil) dating from 11,700 to 9,800 years ago were excavated. 9.800 years ago, domesticated emmer wheat appeared. Evidence has also been found in North Africa, Israel and Syria, of pea, chick pea, bitter vetch, and flax from 10,000+ BCE.
By 6000 BCE agriculture was developed independently in the Far East, with rice as the primary crop.
The Kebaran culture, the eastern Mediterranean area (c. 16,000 to 10,500 BCE), named after its type site, Kebara Cave south of Haifa, is associated with the use of the bow and arrow and the domestication of the dog. The Kebaran is characterized by the earliest collecting of wild cereals, known due to the uncovering of grain grinding tools. The Natufian culture which followed existed from around 12,500 to 9,500 BCE, with a sedentary or semi-sedentary population (they were the original builders of Jericho, the world’s first city) even before the introduction of agriculture. Some evidence suggests deliberate cultivation of cereals, specifically rye, by the Natufian culture, at Tell Abu Hureyra, the site of earliest evidence of agriculture in the world. Generally, though, Natufians exploited wild cereals. Animals hunted included gazelles.
Before the Natufian roaming hunter gatherers, known as the Kebaran culture, trudged the Mediterranean coast as their ancestors had for thousands upon thousands of years. What the Natufians appear to have done, and were possibly the first to have done, is to say “Enough! I’m stopping here thank you,” and build villages.

These villages are very small by modern standards, no more than forty meters across and with populations of less than a couple of hundred people. There was almost nothing like them before. The houses are crude, more like shacks, but they do show a surprising degree of care in their organization and maintenance. Also, whilst there’s no pottery there are stone bowls and grinding stones.
Perhaps most importantly these seem to have been all year round settlements. The teeth of hunted animals such as gazelle show that both summer and winter kills being brought back to the villages. Also, there’s plenty of evidence for house mice and rats in numbers appropriate to a village occupied all year.

Connections with the Neolithic:
What intrigues archaeologists most about the Natufian is that, just under three thousand years later, the Neolithic, with the first evidence in the world of agriculture, started in pretty much the same place. It’s difficult not to see the two events as connected, with one leading to the other. The question that archaeologists have asked since the discovery of these earliest villages is “Why then? Why there?” A number of factors have been suggested.
The start of the Natufian culture, 12,500 BCE, also marks the end of the last glaciation. The world’s temperatures rapidly increased at this time by several degrees. This seems to have increased rainfall in the Levant, extending woodland further inland, although at the same time a rise in sea level might have countered this effect a bit. The improvement in climate did, however, reverse around 11000 BCE, when the “Younger Dryas” event caused a return to cold weather for the next thousand or so years. It was only after the weather warmed up again that agriculture started.
Agriculture changed society in many ways: primarily through division of labor but also through limiting mobility and the variety it could bring. Exchange become more important, considered and unavoidable. Storage hadn’t been much of an issue before, now it was, as was protection of what was stored. There’s been discussion of resultant social and sexual inequality, despotism, militancy, increased disease incidence and declining health.

Proposed Centers of Origin of Some Crops:
1. Near East (Fertile Crescent)- wheat and barley, flax, lentils, chickpea, figs, dates, grapes, olives, lettuce, onions, cabbage, carrots, cucumbers, and melons; fruits and nuts.
2. Africa- Pearl millet, Guinea millet, African rice, sorghum, cowpea, Bambara groundnut, yam, oil palm, watermelon, okra.
3. China- Japanese millet, rice, buckwheat, and soybean (about 7000 BCE).
4. South-east Asia- wet- and dryland rice, pigeon pea, mung bean, citrus fruits, coconut, taro, yams, banana, breadfruit, coconut, sugarcane.
5. Mesoamerica and North America- maize, squash, common bean, lima bean, peppers, amaranth, sweet potato, sunflower.
6. South America- lowlands: cassava; mid-altitudes and uplands (Peru): potato, peanut, cotton, maize.


Adapted from “The origins of agriculture: a biological perspective and a new hypothesis” by Greg Wadley and Angus Martin, published in Australian Biologist 6: 96-105, June 1993

There’s never been agreement on the nature and significance of the rise of civilization, yet the questions posed by the problem are fundamental. How did civilization come about? What animus impelled man to forego the independence, intimacies, and invariability of tribal existence for the much larger and more impersonal political complexity we call the state? What forces fused to initiate the mutation that slowly transformed nomadic societies into populous cities with ethnic mixtures, stratified societies, diversified economies and unique cultural forms? Was the advent of civilization the inevitable result of social evolution and natural laws of progress or was man the designer of his own destiny? Have technological innovations been the motivating force or was it some intangible factor such as religion or intellectual advancement?

To a very good approximation, every civilization that came into being had cereal agriculture as its subsistence base, and wherever cereals were cultivated, civilization appeared. Some hypotheses have linked the two. For example, Wittfogel’s (1957) ‘hydraulic theory’ postulated that irrigation was needed for agriculture, and the state was in turn needed to organize irrigation. But not all civilizations used irrigation, and other possible factors (e.g. river valley placement, warfare, trade, technology, religion, and ecological and population pressure) have not led to a universally accepted model.
Prompted by a possible link between diet and mental illness, several researchers in the late 1970s began investigating the occurrence of drug-like substances in some common foodstuffs. Dohan (1966, 1984) and Dohan et al. (1973, 1983) found that symptoms of schizophrenia were relieved somewhat when patients were fed a diet free of cereals and milk. He also found that people with coeliac disease - those who are unable to eat wheat gluten because of higher than normal permeability of the gut - were statistically likely to suffer also from schizophrenia. Research in some Pacific communities showed that schizophrenia became prevalent in these populations only after they became ‘partially westernized and consumed wheat, barley beer, and rice’ (Dohan 1984).
Groups led by Zioudrou (1979) and Brantl (1979) found opioid activity in wheat, maize and barley (exorphins), and bovine and human milk (casomorphin), as well as stimulatory activity in these proteins, and in oats, rye and soy. Cereal exorphin is much stronger than bovine casomorphin, which in turn is stronger than human casomorphin. Mycroft et al. (1982, 1987) found an analogue of MIF-1, a naturally occurring dopaminergic peptide, in wheat and milk. It occurs in no other exogenous protein. (In subsequent sections we use the term exorphin to cover exorphins, casomorphin, and the MIF-1 analogue. Though opioid and dopaminergic substances work in different ways, they are both ‘rewarding’, and thus more or less equivalent for our purposes.)
Since then, researchers have measured the potency of exorphins, showing them to be comparable to morphine and enkephalin (Heubner et al. 1984), determined their amino acid sequences (Fukudome &Yoshikawa 1992), and shown that they are absorbed from the intestine (Svedburg et al.1985) and can produce effects such as analgesia and reduction of anxiety which are usually associated with poppy-derived opioids (Greksch et al.1981, Panksepp et al.1984). Mycroft et al. estimated that 150 mg of the MIF-1 analogue could be produced by normal daily intake of cereals and milk, noting that such quantities are orally active, and half this amount 'has induced mood alterations in clinically depressed subjects' (Mycroft et al. 1982:895). (For detailed reviews see Gardner 1985 and Paroli 1988.)

Most common drugs of addiction are either opioid (e.g heroin and morphine) or dopaminergic (e.g. cocaine and amphetamine), and work by activating reward centers in the brain. Hence we may ask, do these findings mean that cereals and milk are chemically rewarding? Are humans somehow 'addicted' to these foods?

Problems in interpreting these findings:
Discussion of the possible behavioral effects of exorphins, in normal dietary amounts, has been cautious. Interpretations of their significance have been of two types:
where a pathological effect is proposed (usually by cereal researchers, and related to Dohan’s findings, though see also Ramabadran & Bansinath 1988), and
where a natural function is proposed (by milk researchers, who suggest that casomorphin may help in mother-infant bonding or otherwise regulate infant development).

We believe that there can be no natural function for ingestion of exorphins by adult humans. It may be that a desire to find a natural function has impeded interpretation (as well as causing attention to focus on milk, where a natural function is more plausible). It’s unlikely that humans are adapted to a large intake of cereal exorphin, because the modern dominance of cereals in the diet is simply too new. If exorphin is found in cow’s milk, then it may have a natural function for cows; similarly, exorphins in human milk may have a function for infants. But whether or no, adult humans don’t naturally drink milk of any kind, so any natural function can’t apply.
Our sympathies therefore lie with the pathological interpretation of exorphins, whereby substances found in cereals and milk are seen as modern dietary abnormalities which may cause schizophrenia, coeliac disease or whatever. But these are serious diseases found in a minority. Can exorphins be having an effect on humankind at large?
Other evidence for 'drug-like' effects of these foods”:
Research into food allergy has shown that normal quantities of some foods can have pharmacological, including behavioral, effects. Many people develop intolerances to particular foods. Various foods are implicated, and a variety of symptoms is produced. (The term ‘intolerance’ rather than allergy is often used, as in many cases the immune system may not be involved (Egger 1988:159). Some intolerance symptoms, such as anxiety, depression, epilepsy, hyperactivity, and schizophrenic episodes involve brain function (Egger 1988, Scadding & Brostoff 1988).
Radcliffe (1982, quoted in 1987:808) listed the foods at fault, in descending order of frequency, in a trial involving 50 people: wheat (more than 70% of subjects reacted in some way to it), milk (60%), egg (35%), corn, cheese, potato, coffee, rice, yeast, chocolate, tea, citrus, oats, pork, plaice, cane, and beef (10%). This is virtually a list of foods that have become common in the diet following the adoption of agriculture, in order of prevalence. The symptoms most commonly alleviated by treatment were mood change (>50%) followed by headache, musculoskeletal and respiratory ailments.
One of the most striking phenomena in these studies is that patients often exhibit cravings, addiction and withdrawal symptoms with regard to these foods (Egger 1988:170, citing Randolph 1978; see also Radcliffe 1987:808-10, 814, Kroker 1987:856, 864, Sprague & Milam 1987:949, 953, Wraith 1987:489, 491). Brostoff and Gamlin (1989:103) estimated that 50% of intolerance patients crave the foods that cause them problems, and experience withdrawal symptoms when excluding those foods from their diet. Withdrawal symptoms are similar to those associated with drug addictions (Radcliffe 1987:808). The possibility that exorphins are involved has been noted (Bell 1987:715), and Brostoff and Gamlin conclude (1989:230):
“... the results so far suggest that they might influence our mood. There is certainly no question of anyone getting ‘high’ on a glass of milk or a slice of bread - the amounts involved are too small for that - but these foods might induce a sense of comfort and wellbeing, as food-intolerant patients often say they do. There are also other hormone-like peptides in partial digests of food, which might have other effects on the body.”
There’s no possibility that craving these foods has anything to do with the popular notion of the body telling the brain what it needs for nutritional purposes. These foods weren’t significant in the human diet before agriculture; large quantities of them cannot be necessary for nutrition. In fact, the standard way to treat food intolerance is to remove the offending items from the patient’s diet.

A suggested interpretation of exorphin research:
But what are the effects of these foods on normal people? Though exorphins cannot have a naturally selected physiological function in humans, this does not mean that they have no effect. Food intolerance research suggests that cereals and milk, in normal dietary quantities, are capable of affecting behavior in many people. And if severe behavioral effects in schizophrenics and coeliacs can be caused by higher than normal absorption of peptides, then more subtle effects, which may not even be regarded as abnormal, could be produced in people generally.

The evidence presented so far suggests the following interpretation:
The ingestion of cereals and milk, in normal modern dietary amounts by normal humans, activates reward centers in the brain. Foods that were common in the diet before agriculture (fruits and so on) do not have this pharmacological property. The effects of exorphins are qualitatively the same as those produced by other opioid and / or dopaminergic drugs, that is, reward, motivation, reduction of anxiety, a sense of wellbeing, and perhaps even addiction. Though the effects of a typical meal are quantitatively less than those of doses of those drugs, most modern humans experience them several times a day, every day of their adult lives.

Hypothesis: exorphins and the origin of agriculture and civilization:
When this scenario of human dietary practices is viewed in light of the problem of the origin of agriculture, it suggests an hypothesis that combines the results of these lines of enquiry. Exorphin researchers, perhaps lacking a long-term historical perspective, have generally not investigated the possibility that these foods really are drug-like, and have instead searched without success for exorphin’s natural function. The adoption of cereal agriculture and the subsequent rise of civilization haven’t been satisfactorily explained, because the behavioral changes underlying them have no obvious adaptive basis.
These unsolved and until-now unrelated problems may in fact solve each other. The answer, we suggest, is this: cereals and dairy foods are not natural human foods, but rather are preferred because they contain exorphins. This chemical reward was the incentive for the adoption of cereal agriculture in the Neolithic. Regular self-administration of these substances facilitated the behavioral changes that led to the subsequent appearance of civilization.

This is the sequence of events that we envisage:
Climatic change at the end of the last glacial period led to an increase in the size and concentration of patches of wild cereals in certain areas (Wright 1977). The large quantities of cereals newly available provided an incentive to try to make a meal of them. People who succeeded in eating sizeable amounts of cereal seeds discovered the rewarding properties of the exorphins contained in them. Processing methods such as grinding and cooking were developed to make cereals more edible. The more palatable they could be made, the more they were consumed, and the more important the exorphin reward became for more people.
At first, patches of wild cereals were protected and harvested. Later, land was cleared and seeds were planted and tended, to increase quantity and reliability of supply. Exorphins attracted people to settle around cereal patches, abandoning their nomadic lifestyle, and allowed them to display tolerance instead of aggression as population densities rose in these new conditions.
Though it was, we suggest, the presence of exorphins that caused cereals (and not an alternative already prevalent in the diet) to be the major early cultigens, this does not mean that cereals are ‘just drugs’ They have been staples for thousands of years, and clearly have nutritional value. However, treating cereals as ‘just food’ leads to difficulties in explaining why anyone bothered to cultivate them. The fact that overall health declined when they were incorporated into the diet suggests that their rapid, almost total replacement of other foods was more due to chemical reward than to nutrition.
It’s noteworthy that the extent to which early groups became civilized correlates with the type of agriculture they practiced. That is, major civilizations (in south-west Asia, Europe, India, and east and parts of South-East Asia; central and parts of north and south America; Egypt, Ethiopia and parts of tropical and west Africa) stemmed from groups which practiced cereal, particularly wheat, agriculture (Bender 1975:12, Adams 1987:201, Thatcher 1987:212). (The rarer nomadic civilizations were based on dairy farming.) Groups which practiced vege-culture (of fruits, tubers etc.), or no agriculture (in tropical and south Africa, north and central Asia, Australia, New Guinea and the Pacific, and much of north and south America) did not become civilized to the same extent.
Thus major civilizations have in common that their populations were frequent ingesters of exorphins. We propose that large, hierarchical states were a natural consequence among such populations. Civilization arose because reliable, on-demand availability of dietary opioids to individuals changed their behavior, reducing aggression, and allowed them to become tolerant of sedentary life in crowded groups, to perform regular work, and to be more easily subjugated by rulers. Two socioeconomic classes emerged where before there had been only one (Johnson & Earle 1987:270), thus establishing a pattern which has been prevalent since that time.

The natural diet and genetic change:
Some nutritionists deny the notion of a pre-agricultural natural human diet on the basis that humans are omnivorous, or have adapted to agricultural foods (e.g. Garn & Leonard 1989; for the contrary view see for example Eaton & Konner 1985). An omnivore, however, is simply an animal that eats both meat and plants: it can still be quite specialized in its preferences (chimpanzees are an appropriate example). A degree of omnivory in early humans might have pre-adapted them to some of the nutrients contained in cereals, but not to exorphins, which are unique to cereals.
The differential rates of lactase deficiency, coeliac disease and favism (the inability to metabolize fava beans) among modern racial groups are usually explained as the result of varying genetic adaptation to post-agricultural diets (Simopoulos 1990:27-9), and this could be thought of as implying some adaptation to exorphins as well. We argue that little or no such adaptation has occurred, for two reasons: first, allergy research indicates that these foods still cause abnormal reactions in many people, and that susceptibility is variable within as well as between populations, indicating that differential adaptation is not the only factor involved. Second, the function of the adaptations mentioned is to enable humans to digest those foods, and if they are adaptations, they arose because they conferred a survival advantage. But would susceptibility to the rewarding effects of exorphins lead to lower, or higher, reproductive success? One would expect in general that an animal with a supply of drugs would behave less adaptively and so lower its chances of survival. But our model shows how the widespread exorphin ingestion in humans has led to increased population. And once civilization was the norm, non-susceptibility to exorphins would have meant not fitting in with society. Thus, though there may be adaptation to the nutritional content of cereals, there will be little or none to exorphins. In any case, while contemporary humans may enjoy the benefits of some adaptation to agricultural diets, those who actually made the change ten thousand years ago did not.

Other 'non-nutritional' origins of agriculture models:
We are not the first to suggest a non-nutritional motive for early agriculture. Hayden (1990) argued that early cultigens and trade items had more prestige value than utility, and suggested that agriculture began because the powerful used its products for competitive feasting and accrual of wealth. Braidwood et al. (1953) and later Katz and Voigt (1986) suggested that the incentive for cereal cultivation was the production of alcoholic beer:
“Under what conditions would the consumption of a wild plant resource be sufficiently important to lead to a change in behavior (experiments with cultivation) in order to ensure an adequate supply of this resource? If wild cereals were in fact a minor part of the diet, any argument based on caloric need is weakened. It is our contention that the desire for alcohol would constitute a perceived psychological and social need that might easily prompt changes in subsistence behavior” (Katz & Voigt 1986:33).
This view is clearly compatible with ours. However there may be problems with an alcohol hypothesis: beer may have appeared after bread and other cereal products, and been consumed less widely or less frequently (Braidwood et al. 1953). Unlike alcohol, exorphins are present in all these products. This makes the case for chemical reward as the motive for agriculture much stronger. Opium poppies, too, were an early cultigen (Zohari 1986). Exorphin, alcohol, and opium are primarily rewarding (as opposed to the typically hallucinogenic drugs used by some hunter-gatherers) and it is the artificial reward which is necessary, we claim, for civilization. Perhaps all three were instrumental in causing civilized behavior to emerge.
Cereals have important qualities that differentiate them from most other drugs. They are a food source as well as a drug, and can be stored and transported easily. They are ingested in frequent small doses (not occasional large ones), and do not impede work performance in most people. A desire for the drug, even cravings or withdrawal, can be confused with hunger. These features make cereals the ideal facilitator of civilization (and may also have contributed to the long delay in recognizing their pharmacological properties).
Our hypothesis is not a refutation of existing accounts of the origins of agriculture, but rather fits alongside them, explaining why cereal agriculture was adopted despite its apparent disadvantages and how it led to civilization.
Gaps in our knowledge of exorphins limit the generality and strength of our claims. We do not know whether rice, millet and sorghum, nor grass species which were harvested by African and Australian hunter-gatherers, contain exorphins. We need to be sure that pre-agricultural staples do not contain exorphins in amounts similar to those in cereals. We do not know whether domestication has affected exorphin content or-potency. A test of our hypothesis by correlation of diet and degree of civilization in different populations will require quantitative knowledge of the behavioral effects of all these foods.
We do not comment on the origin of non-cereal agriculture, nor why some groups used a combination of foraging and farming, reverted from farming to foraging, or did not farm at all. Cereal agriculture and civilization have, during the past ten thousand years, become virtually universal. The question, then, is not why they happened here and not there, but why they took longer to become established in some places than in others. At all times and places, chemical reward and the influence of civilizations already using cereals weighed in favor of adopting this lifestyle, the disadvantages of agriculture weighed against it, and factors such as climate, geography, soil quality, and availability of cultigens influenced the outcome. There is a recent trend to multi-causal models of the origins of agriculture (e.g. Redding 1988, Henry 1989), and exorphins can be thought of as simply another factor in the list. Analysis of the relative importance of all the factors involved, at all times and places, is beyond the scope of this paper.
“An animal is a survival machine for the genes that built it. We too are animals, and we too are survival machines for our genes. That is the theory. In practice it makes a lot of sense when we look at wild animals.... It is very different when we look at ourselves. We appear to be a serious exception to the Darwinian law.... It obviously just isn't true that most of us spend our time working energetically for the preservation of our genes” (Dawkins 1989:138).
Many ethologists have acknowledged difficulties in explaining civilized human behavior on evolutionary grounds, in some cases suggesting that modern humans do not always behave adaptively. Yet since agriculture began, the human population has risen by a factor of 1000: Irons (1990) notes that ‘population growth is not the expected effect of maladaptive behavior’.
We have reviewed evidence from several areas of research which shows that cereals and dairy foods have drug-like properties, and shown how these properties may have been the incentive for the initial adoption of agriculture. We suggested further that constant exorphin intake facilitated the behavioral changes and subsequent population growth of civilization, by increasing people's tolerance of (a) living in crowded sedentary conditions, (b) devoting effort to the benefit of non-kin, and (c) playing a subservient role in a vast hierarchical social structure.
Cereals are still staples, and methods of artificial reward have diversified since that time, including today a wide range of pharmacological and non-pharmacological cultural artifacts whose function, ethologically speaking, is to provide reward without adaptive benefit. It seems reasonable then, to suggest that civilization not only arose out of self-administration of artificial reward, but is maintained in this way among contemporary humans. Hence a step towards resolution of the problem of explaining civilized human behavior may be to incorporate into ethological models this widespread distortion of behavior by artificial reward.


Wanting to further explore this idea, I gathered from internet sources:
One model for the evolution of alcohol consumption suggests that ethanol only entered the human diet after people began to store extra food, potentially after the advent of agriculture, and that humans subsequently developed ways to intentionally direct the fermentation of food about 7000BCE. As almost any cereal containing certain sugars can undergo spontaneous fermentation due to wild yeasts in the air, beer-like beverages developed independently throughout the world when people domesticated cereals. Chemical tests of ancient pottery jars reveal beer produced about 5000BCE in today’s Iran. In Mesopotamia, the oldest evidence of beer we have so far is a 6,000-year-old Sumerian tablet depicting people drinking through reed straws from a communal bowl. In China, residue on pottery dating from between 5400 and 4900 years ago shows beer was brewed using barley and other grains.
Discovery of late Stone Age jugs suggest that intentionally fermented beverages existed at least as early as the Neolithic period (c. 10000 BCE). Chemical analysis of jars from the neolithic village Jiahu in the Henan province of northern China revealed traces of alcohol that were absorbed and preserved. According to a study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, chemical analysis of the residue confirmed that a fermented drink made of grapes, hawthorn berries, honey, and rice was being produced in 7000–6650BCE. The results of this analysis were published in December 2004. This is approximately the time when barley beer and grape wine were beginning to be made in the Middle East. The earliest firm evidence of wine production dates back to 6000BCE in Georgia. Medicinal use of alcohol was mentioned in Sumerian and Egyptian texts dating from about 2100BCE. Evidence of alcoholic beverages has also been found dating from 3150BCE in ancient Egypt, 3000BCE in Babylon, 2000BCE in pre-Hispanic Mexico, and 1500BCE in Sudan.
There may have been a single genetic mutation 10 million years ago that endowed humans with an enhanced ability to break down ethanol. Scientists note that the timing of this mutation coincides with a shift to a terrestrial lifestyle. The ability to consume ethanol may have helped human ancestors dine on rotting, fermenting fruit that fell on the forest floor when other food was scarce.
The Mediterranean region contains the earliest archeological evidence of human opium use; the oldest known seeds date back to more than 5000BCE in the Neolithic age with purposes such as food, anesthetics, and ritual. The earliest recorded use of narcotics dates back to 4,000 BCE. Evidence from ancient Greece indicates that opium was consumed in several ways, including inhalation of vapors, suppositories, medical poultices, and as a combination with hemlock for suicide. Indian scholars maintain that ancient verses and the history shown in them were orally transmitted thousands of years before even 4000BCE.
Tea drinking likely began in Yunnan province during the Shang Dynasty (1500–1046 BCE) - legend has the Yellow Emperor, inventor of agriculture and Chinese medicine, drinking a bowl of just boiled water due to a decree that his subjects must boil water before drinking it, in about 2737 BCE, when some tea leaves fell in and he enjoyed the taste. In 1978, Archeologists found tea relics in the Tianluo mountains and estimated them at 7,000 years old. Another promising find in the same mountains was old roots of the Camellia Sinenses plant with broken pottery. These roots were determined to be about 6,000 years old 9from 4000BCE). It wasn’t until the Tang dynasty (618-907), that consumption become widespread.
This goes a bit beyond my ken, and I expect that of most readers too:
Addiction is a disorder of the brain’s reward system which arises through transcriptional and epigenetic mechanisms and occurs over time from chronically high levels of exposure to an addictive stimulus (e.g., eating food, the use of cocaine, engagement in sexual intercourse, participation in high-thrill cultural activities such as gambling, etc.). ΔFosB, a gene transcription factor, is a critical component and common factor in the development of virtually all forms of behavioral and drug addictions. Research into ΔFosB’s role in addiction has demonstrated that addiction arises, and the associated compulsive behavior intensifies or attenuates, along with the over-expression of ΔFosB in the D1-type medium spiny neurons of the nucleus accumbens. Due to the causal relationship between ΔFosB expression and addictions, it is used pre-clinically as an addiction biomarker. ΔFosB expression in these neurons directly and positively regulates drug self-administration and reward sensitization through positive reinforcement, while decreasing sensitivity to aversion. I expect that it mostly means that correlation has been found between brain chemistry and the compulsions we call addiction.

A common belief is that psychotropic plant chemicals evolved recurrently throughout evolutionary history. Archaeological records indicate the presence of psychotropic plants and drug use in ancient civilizations as far back as early hominid species about 200 million years ago. Roughly 13,000 years ago, the inhabitants of Timor commonly used betel nut (Areca catechu), as did those in Thailand around 88,700BCE. At the beginning of European colonialism, and perhaps for 40,000 years before that, Australian aborigines used nicotine from two different indigenous sources: pituri plant (Duboisia hopwoodii) and Nicotiana gossel. North and South Americans also used nicotine from their indigenous plants N. tabacum and N. rustica. Ethiopians and northern Africans were documented as having used an ephedrine-analog, khat (Catha edulis), before European colonization. Cocaine (Erythroxylum coca) was taken by Ecuadorians about 3000BCE and by the indigenous people of the western Andes almost 7,000 years ago (5000BCE). The substances were popularly administered through the buccal cavity within the cheek. Nicotine, cocaine, and ephedrine sources were first mixed with an alkali substance, most often wood or lime ash, creating a free base to facilitate diffusion of the drug into the blood stream. Alkali paraphernalia have been found throughout these regions and documented within the archaeological record. Although the buccal method is believed to be most standard method of drug administration, inhabitants of the Americas may have also administered substances nasally, rectally, and by smoking.
Sex addiction as a term first emerged in the mid-1970s when various members of Alcoholics Anonymous sought to apply the principles of 12-steps toward sexual recovery from serial infidelity and other unmanageable compulsive sex behaviors that were similar to the powerlessness and un-manageability they experienced with alcoholism. Certainly compulsive sexual behavior, as with “Jack the Ripper” (!), existed long before 1970.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Sunday, December 24, 2017

Vasco da Gama trades Christianity for spice

Vasco da Gama (1460–1524), a peevish, paranoid trader who refused to go ashore for the first Portuguese contact at an Indian port, shores thus missed hearing a pair of multi-lingual Tunisian merchants ask in both Castilian and Genoese, “The Devil take you! What brought you here?” Replied his chosen representative, a convict, “We came to seek Christians and spices.”
The vicious commander of the first ships to sail directly from Europe to India, he tried to do business in India from a small 50 ton caravel and even smaller supply ship, with a crew of about 160 (including gunners, musicians and three Arabic interpreters), using trade goods common to West Africa but of virtually no interest in Asia—coarse cloth, bells, beads . . . “Business” is a fairly euphemistic term for what he did, though; he pretended to offer protection. His guns, for the time, were state-of-the-art and more powerful than anything those encountered on his voyages had experienced before. Through force, he opened the way to Portugal’s success in appropriating, or more politely, colonizing. He, or anyway his crew, introduced syphilis to Asia. Inflicting casual violence almost everywhere he went, he abused and slaughtered people he meant to glean advantage through, setting a tone for distrust that has remained.
The Portuguese saw excursions to Asia as more than business: they were a continuation of six centuries of war (with an average of a battle or two a day) between Christians and Islamic Moors, mainly in the Iberian Peninsula. The Republic of Venice, by trading with Muslims who’d had a trade monopoly with India and the Far East, had controled most trade between Europe and Asia. Da Gama out-flanked Venice by going around Africa (this was 5 years after Columbus “discovered” the Americas, and the route went far across the Atlantic, almost to Brazil, yet unknown).
Muslims invaded Portugal in 711 and again in 1191; they gained control of almost the whole Iberian Peninsula. Total re-conquest wasn’t made until the 1270s. In 1340 a Portuguese army joined Alfonso XI of Castile won victory over Muslims in Andalusia. Portuguese attacked Morocco in 1458, 1463, and 1471. Turks took Constantinople in 1453, while other Muslims were being pushed from Iberia. In 1578, when at the height of their power in Asia (power gained through da Gama’s efforts), Portuguese knights fought a spirited, essentially chauvinistic campaign at Alcazar, Morocco, and were soundly defeated; at least one member of nearly every noble Portuguese family died there, for abstract reasons almost purely cultural and religious.
Da Gama may have learned astronomy under renowned Abraham Zacuto; Genoese sailors, jealous of Venice’s monopoly on Arabic (Persian) trade, were willing to share secrets with the Portuguese. Da Gama’s decisive expedition sailed from Lisbon on July 8, 1497, with three interpreters: two Arabic speakers and one with several Bantu dialects, as Arab-controlled territory on the East African coast was an integral part of the Indian Ocean trade network. Upon reaching Mozambique, March 2, 1498, da Gama and crew impersonated Muslims to gain audience with the Sultan. They offered unsuitable trade goods and gifts, and were told that Prester John, the long-sought Christian ruler from whom a Pope once received a missive, lived to the interior (but controlled many coastal cities). The Sultan supplied the unconvinced da Gama with two pilots, but hostile crowds threatened. On discovering the Portuguese to be Christian, a pilot deserted. Upon departure, they fired cannons into the city.
Moving up Africa’s east coast, to Mombasa and Malindi (in present-day Kenya), da Gama found much more sophisticated economic life than in West Africa. Coastal towns had merchants—Arabs, Indians from Gujarat and Malabar and Persians—who imported silk and cotton textiles, spices and Chinese porcelain, while exporting cotton, timber and gold. Looting Arab (or more likely, Persian) merchant ships, which lacked the heavy cannon da Gama carried, he took gold, silver, jewels and spices, but was somehow able to get a competent Gujarati pilot from the ruler of Malindi, and so on to Calicut (in Kerala). Da Gama was welcomed by the Hindu ruler (Zamorin) of Calicut, but failed to achieve a treaty, partly due to hostility from Muslim merchants, but more due to the low quality of his trade goods.
The Portuguese remained in Calicut for three months, discovering much about prices and conditions in the spice market, but failed to establish amicable relations with the local ruler (or sell anything). Muslim merchants made allegations against da Gama and he was arrested; the mayor told him to leave without cargo, and detained seven men as hostages. So, upon setting sail, da Gama seized 20 fishermen. A hostage-trade was arranged, but only superior gunnery saved da Gama from Islamic wrath. He destroyed a Calicut fleet of 29 ships, and so finally got favorable trading concessions from the Zamorin. He reached Lisbon in 1499, after two years in which he’d lost half his crew and ships. Nevertheless Manuel I granted Vasco the title of dom (equivalent to the English “sir”), estates and an annual pension. Made admiral January 1502, da Gama sailed again in February, now with 20 ships. He stopped briefly at Mozambique, then sailed to Kilwa (Tanzania), and threatened the Islamic ruler with destruction if he didn’t submit and swear loyalty. He did, and also agreed to an annual tribute of pearls and gold.
After coasting southern Arabia, da Gama went to Goa, then on to Cannanore, north of Calicut, to lay in wait for Arab and Persian shipping. After several days an Arab ship returning from Mecca with valuable merchandise and hundreds of passengers, including many women and children, arrived; da Gama seized the cargo, locked passengers aboard and then set all ablaze. Headed to Cochin, he stopped opposite Calicut and demanded that the ruler expel the whole Muslim merchant community (4000 households). The Samudri, the local Hindu ruler, refused, so da Gama bombarded the city. At Cochin, he bought spices with silver, copper and textiles he’d taken from the ship he burned. After setting up a permanent factory (warehouse) in Cochin, he left five ships there to protect Portuguese interests.
Da Gama returned to Lisbon again October 1503, with 13 of his ships and nearly 1700 tons of spices, i.e. about the same as annual Venetian imports of the time. Portuguese King Manuel I “the Fortunate” (ruled 1495 to 1521), then assumed the title of “lord of the conquest, navigation, and commerce of India, Ethiopia, Arabia, and Persia”! Defeat of an Islamic navy in 1509 gave him control of sea trade, which became the chief source of Portuguese wealth. From Portuguese dominion, the British East Indian Company was able to grow; and then a century and a half of Protestant-led world domination by Europeans – a misled supremacy we can only hope we’re on the verge of recovering from, now.
Alexander of Greece had invaded the Punjab in 327 BCE; before that, Indian teak and cedar was used in Babylon (in the 7th and 6th centuries BCE, as mentioned in Buddhist Jataka texts). Arab merchants brought Indian goods to Egypt and the eastern Mediterranean, and in the 2nd century BCE, Greeks from Bactria founded kingdoms, which lasted over a century, in the Punjab and bordering Afghan hills. Then European commercial involvement with India died with the decline of the Roman Empire in the 4th century CE. Trade passed completely into Arab hands. In the 1400s, land routes to India—via Egypt and the Red Sea, across Turkey and Persia, or through Syria and Iraq to the Persian Gulf—were blocked, mainly by Ottoman action. An Egyptian route was subject to increasing exploitation by a line of middlemen ending with the Venetian monopoly; in 1517 that too passed to Ottoman control. The motive for finding a new route was strong.
For Europe in 1498, India was a land of spices and wonderful marvels; for Muslims, Europe was the land of Rūm and Greek Constantinople (Turkish after 1453). For Hindus, Europe was the home of warlike Yavanas (from the Greek word Ionian). The Portuguese were the first to renew direct contact, being among the few nations to possess both the navigational know-how (including navigational techniques learned from disgruntled Genoese, as mentioned earlier) and the necessary motivation (both revenge on Islam, and supplementing the sparse economy of home).
Portuguese first tried to get a port in northwest India in 1507; by 1534 they had other important trading centers on the western coast (Panjim, Daman, and Diu), but seized from Muslims the port which became Bombay and now Mumbai, India’s principal Arabian Sea port, financial and commercial centre and one of the world’s largest and most densely populated cities. The name Bombay is an Anglicization from “Bom Baia” – Portuguese for good port. In 1661 it came under British control from King Charles II marrying Catherine of Braganza, sister of Portugal’s king; in 1668 it was ceded to the East India Company. In the early 1700s the Portuguese started exporting opium from India to sell in China (at a considerable profit), and by 1773 the British were also involved in that trade – psycho-actives replacing spice, as tea gained popularity in Europe and especially England – tea that there was little other way to pay for.
Da Gama had hoped to find Christians separated from the West by Muslims, and to be able to deal a blow at Muslim power from their maritime rear. He found some in the Syrians of Cochin and Travancore, but mostly only further alienated Muslims. His successors established a Portuguese empire in the East – Goa, Timor and Macao were Portuguese until late in the 20th century. For over 100 years, Portugal had strategic command over the Indian Ocean, and controlled the maritime spice trade, much to the detriment of trade by the Ottoman-controlled Middle Eastern Muslim world. The Portuguese relied on naval power and fortified posts backed by settlements; their ships, sturdy enough to survive Atlantic gales and mounted with cannon, easily disrupted Arab and Malay shipping. But Portugal had fewer than a million people and was involved in Africa and South America as well. It was desperately short of manpower. Fortresses had to become settlements and provide a resident population for defense; intermarriage was encouraged and a new mixed population provided stubborn resistance to attacks.
Despite their small numbers, Portuguese mercenaries operated through much of Asia. Vijayanagar, the first South Indian state to encompass the three major linguistic and cultural traditions of India—Indo-Aryan (Sanskrit), Dravidian (Tamil), and Sunni Muslim Arabs and Turks (mostly of Bahmani state) briefly retook Goa from Muslims, just before the Portuguese made it their first territorial possession in Asia, in 1510. Krishna Deva Raya (reigned 1509–29), the greatest Vijayanagar king, garrisoned forts with Portuguese and Muslim mercenary gunners (and foot soldiers from local forest tribes). Using Portuguese gunners in successful campaigns made for vivid impressions on Muslim rulers, of danger posed by Vijayanagar, resulting in more concerted action against that kingdom. Krishna Deva mostly maintained a mutually advantageous relationship with the increasingly powerful Portuguese, retaining access to trade goods, especially superior horses. In 1546 Portugal made a treaty to expand settlements, but, due to harm to locals, the treaty was broken in 1558; tribute was exacted in compensation for Portuguese damage to temples.
Portugal’s control of the Indian Ocean lasted through the 16th century. Three marks of Portuguese empire were trade, Roman Catholic Christianity, and anti-Islamism. The Portuguese felt that no faith need be kept with infidels, and were happily cruel to Muslims—well beyond the normal limits in a very rough age. This, missionary fervor and intolerance deprived them of potential Indian sympathy.
In 1580 Spain annexed Portugal; until 1640, Portuguese interests were made secondary to those of Spain. The Spanish failed to quell a Dutch uprising, and after the defeat of the Spanish Armada in 1588, sea-ways opened to the English and Dutch. Portuguese ascendancy crumbled.
The English East India Company gained monopoly rights to trade as of 1600, with an initial capital of under a tenth of the similar Dutch company’s. Its object was also to trade in spice, primarily from the East Indies (Indonesia); it used India for a secondary purpose—securing cotton for sale to spice growers. The British East Indian venture was troubled by determined Dutch opposition, and by Portuguese who enjoyed Mugal recognition (especially at the western Indian port of Surat). A 1612 English victory over the Portuguese, whose control of the sea route to Mecca was resented by the Mughals, especially pilgrims, provided the English with the right to trade and establish “factories”—in return for becoming naval auxiliaries for the Mughal Empire. Merchants lived in the “factories” or in collegiate-type settlements where life was confined, colorful, and often short, but a century of peaceful trading through factories operating under Mughal grants followed. An exception to this arrangement was the long independent island port of Bombay. Its inhabitants, the Maratha, Hindus often of the Kshatriya warrior class, whose antecedents may have been founders of the 7th to 13th century Srivijaya maritime empire, were locked in vicious combat with the Mughals. The Marathi-speaking region extends from Bombay to Goa, and inland about 100 miles.
In the long run, English trade, in bulk instead of highly priced luxury goods preferred by the Dutch, became the more profitable—as smaller areas to cover and less need for armed forces reduced overhead. But India would take little other than silver in exchange for goods, and loss of too much bullion wasn’t acceptable in England’s mercantilist political economy. So the English developed a system similar to that of the Dutch, with Madras and Gujarat supplying cotton goods (Gujarat also supplied indigo); and Bengal silk, sugar, and saltpeter (for gunpowder). There was spice trade along the Malabar coast, in competition with the Portuguese and Dutch. But it was opium shipped to China that laid a basis for continued English trade; English tea imports increased from 54,000 pounds in 1706 to over 2,300,000 pounds in 1750, paid for mostly through sale to China of Indian opium.
Goa, with a coastline of 65 miles, was finally annexed by India in 1962, after Indian troops supported by naval and air forces invaded and occupied Goa, Daman, and Diu. Portuguese India was then incorporated into the Indian Union, and what da Vaca had wrought was brought to naught. Increased trade he had facilitated reduced no cultural divides.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, November 26, 2009

More on Lanna

The British and the Teak Trade

Traditionally, Lanna forests belonged to the ruler of the nearest city. Anyone harvesting logs needed the ruler’s permission first. Initially the Royal Court in Bangkok wasn’t concerned, but as logging business increased problems arose. There were few if any fixed regulations; concessions overlapped, taxes weren’t clearly delineated and little could be clarified through local courts. Rapid growth in the logging industry resulted in increasing timber value; the amounts concerned became substantial. Struggles related to overlapping concessions became frequent, demanding much legal attention. Strife, banditry and murder in border areas increased significantly. The British Government asked for help from the Bangkok central administration, which feared the British might attempt to take control of the area and hadn’t the power to repel them.
In 1855, King Mongut approved a Treaty of Friendship and Commerce with Sir John Bowring, representative of Queen Victoria (and the British Foreign Office, rather than of one of its Asian colonies or trading companies). Trade with Europeans had been closely restricted for the first half of the 1800s, but as Mongut both wanted and needed friendship with Britain, they got more concessions than had ever been given foreigners before. Siamese royal trading monopolies, except in opium, were abolished (it was Chinese businessmen bore the brunt of this loss, after less than 2 years). British subjects gained rights to buy land and import opium, and were put under an extraterritorial legal system. British subjects became answerable only to the British Consul in Bangkok (in the event, this proved to be just for British nationals, instead of for all British subjects, as claimed). This was in accord with Southeast Asian maritime tradition, in which each community of foreign merchants, including Chinese, was under supervision of a top representative, with whom local leaders would deal exclusively. Within seven years, similar treaties were made with France, the USA, Denmark, Portugal, Holland and Prussia, but Britain, because of Burma, remained most significant. In 1868, Bowring helped make similar treaties giving Siam direct relations with Belgium, Italy, Norway and Sweden (instead of with colonial officers). But Britain was the big winner - Singapore and Hong Kong sent regular ships, and the British Bombay-Burmah Corporation got the lion’s share of teak.
Lanna’s thick teak forests had interested the British since the late 1820s. British subjects came to ChiangMai to purchase elephants, oxen and buffalo in 1829, when, for three decades, they had been establishing themselves in Burma - by 1826 they were well settled in (as part of British India) and harvesting teak along the Salween River. Rama III granted British commercial logging access to the then economically listless Chiang Mai area, but as forests were under the control of competing local leaders, problems and misunderstandings arose and some British subjects were murdered. Northern rulers could do little to deflect British military advances into their area, and a rift between Bangkok and ChiangMai grew. The British demanded compensation from Chiang Mai princes for losses due to lawlessness in the heavily forested frontier areas, but power brokers in Bangkok merely tried to use delaying tactics to balance British and Lanna needs. As Siam modernized under Mongut, ChiangMai become less isolated; for half a century, Lanna had enjoyed much autonomy, but with the arrival of a postal service (1883) and of international business, Chiang Mai found itself drawn more closely into Siamese politics.
Taxes from the principle cities of Lanna (ChiangMai, Phrae, Nan, Lampang and Lamphun) included teakwood of an amount dependant on the size of the city. In addition to the annual tributes and taxes levied, Bangkok had the right to materials, especially teak, required for important ceremonies and construction. For this, the central government usually sent gifts in return, but in event of war, Lanna was required to send conscripts, without compensation.
Phra Chao Kawila (1781-1816) was followed by his brother Phraya Thammalangka (Chao Chang Phuak, ruled 1816-1821), who, from givingb King Rama II a white elephant was promoted to become Phraya Chiang Mai Chang Phuak (Chao Chang Phuak). A third ‘Jet Ton’ ruler, Phraya Kham Fan (Chao Luang Sethi), ruled 1821-1825. Phraya Phutthawong (Chao Luang Phaen Din Yen, ‘King of the Peaceful Land’ from 1825-1846), administered the city longer, with intellect rather than strength. The city enjoyed peace in large part because of Burmese fighting with the British, but also because rivals in Lamphun and Lampang were also terrified of the British, already starting to log teak along the border. When Phraya Mahawong (Phra Chao Mahotara Prathet, fifth of the Jet Ton lineage), ruled (1847-1854), there was warfare with the Burmese again. Money from logging allowed Chiang Mai to expand territory and regional authority.
Rama V, to avoid military conflict with British Burma, established a system of bi-national courts and a Chiang Mai Royal Commissioner. In 1883, a second “Treaty of Chiang Mai” specified that British subjects could be heard only in international courts, or Consular Courts when appropriate, and the British opened a Chiang Mai Consulate. From 1890 to World War II, about 20,000 logs were produced per year in Lanna, cut to maximum possible length. After the war, until 1955, this resumed, but then there was partial nationalization, which became total in 1960 (under the Royal Forestry Department).

The first Governor of Mae Hong Son, Chankalea, appointed in 1874, a Tai Yai, was given the title Phraya Singhanartraja. In Mae Hong Son, the unique “Pan Soi” Shan architectural style, roofs built with multi-tiered cascades and embellished with fretwork, almost gives the appearance of gables upturned a bit at corners and ends (all really quite square), still remains common.
Burma became a British colony in 1886; this included the Shan States. Before the French took Indochina (including Lan Sang), T’ais lost control of Chiang Rung; only the Siamese part of Lanna still had control of its own economic, political, social and cultural affairs – but it had to pay tribute, including gold and silver trees, teakwood and military conscripts, to the Siamese Royal Court, and accept increased commerce, influence and interchange with Bangkok.
As the teak-logging industry grew in the mid-19th century, officials from Bangkok became more and more important; records indicate much resentment to abuse of power. Increases in Siamese hegemony were fiercely resisted until the death of Prince Kavilorot (Phra Jao Kawiloros Suriyavong; Kawilorotsuriyawong or Chao Chiwit Ao, ruled 1856-1870). In his reign, insufficient regulation of logging caused a backlog of lawsuits. Kawilorot was a harsh ruler; subjects suffered much corporal punishment, including many beheadings, but he refused to attend ceremonies for visiting Siamese princes, exchanged embassies with Burma, and honored spirit ceremonies. After his death, annual ceremonies to ancestor spirits, at city pillars, ended; Bangkok imposed direct control, and Jao Intanon (IndraWichayanon, Chao Luang Ta Khao, 1871-1897) reigned. He set up a school for girls (and another for boys). The last independent ruler, he had little power, but his wife, Chao Thep Kraison (Princess Tipkesawn), a daughter of Kawilorot, was highly skilled in bureaucratic affairs, and assisted him with much success for 13 years. Despite no formal learning, she and her sister Princess Ubonwanna were great traders, among the biggest in Siam. Women traditionally handled local trade, but only in the 1880s did they start learning letters – first taught by American female Presbyterian missionaries. Intanon and Tipkeson’s daughter Chao Dara Rasami (or Rassama), at 13 in 1886, became a consort of King Chulalongkorn (Rama V). Rama V accomplished many wonders for Siam, but his regent Somdet Chaophraya Si Suriawong (Chuang Bunnag, 1868 to 1873, with continuing strong influence until 1883) systematically usurped Lanna power. When he became the fully empowered king, Chulalongkorn incorporated Lanna into Siam (1892), and in 1908 made Dara Rassama Queen. Jet Ton ruler #8, Chao Noi Suriwongmekha, became Jao Inthaworot Suriwong (1901-09), and through Queen Dara Rassami developed closer ties with Bangkok, often bringing up musical and performing arts from there.
In 1884 mail service became regular: every two weeks. Before, international mail came through Moulmein, and for years after, private contractors carried much of the mail. The telegraph reached Chiang Mai sometime between 1885 and 1888. By 1905 there were (unreliable) telephones.
British subjects involved with logging in Lanna continued initiating many lawsuits, more were murdered; these problems had to be dealt with in Bangkok, as local commissioners lacked significant power. Administrative reform was unavoidable, and the ‘monthon’ (circle of administration) was produced, combining most Lanna city/states. Chiang Mai, Lamphun, Lampang, Phrae, Nan and Thoeng became Monthon Lao Chiang. Then later, Chiang Rai and Mae Hong Son (established 1831) were put with Chiang Mai and Lamphun as Monthon Phayap; this became a ‘monton thesaphiban’ with royal resident commissioner in 1899. Nan, Phrae and Lampang were changed into Monton Maharat, and Lanna schools became required to use only the central Thai alphabet and dialect.
When Lanna was annexed to Siam (1892), there were powerful British Consulates in Lampang, Chiang Mai, Chiang Rai and Nan. A forestry service was set up to reduce international legal complications, but the British remained rather more exploitative than co-operative. The Chao Muang hereditary rulers became but honorary figures, and the last of the Chiang Mai nobility, Chao Kaew Nawarat, though called Chief of State, never had any administrative authority. His main function was to preside at certain spirit ceremonies. He died in 1939. The last prince of Lampang, Chao Boonyawat Wongmanit, died in 1922. Prince Maha Promsurathada of Nan died in 1931. The 9th and last Chiang Mai Prince (“Ruler”), Major General Jao Kaeo Nawarat, was granted the surname suffix “na Chiang Mai” by Rama VI, for all Jao Jet Ton descendents. When Kaeo Nawarat died, his post was dissolved. The last prince of Lamphun, Chao Chakrakam Kajornsakdi, died in 1943.

At the beginning of the 20th century, tigers were still sometimes seen, even inside the major cities of Chiang Rai. The population of the area which became the present province had been reduced to about 5000, with perhaps 500 in the city at Doi Jom Tong. Chiang Saen City had about 70 residents; some of whom were wanted criminals. King Rama V ordered further resettlement, but malaria, hepatitis, and other swams and jungle diseases made for grave difficulties. Roads were poorly maintained: journeys from Bangkok to Chiang Mai took over three weeks, occasionally even three months. From Chiang Mai to Chiang Rai took about two weeks. The lengthy period of warfare had taken a toll still obvious a hundred years later, the Golden Age all but forgotten.

From Dark Times to Modern Times

Lanna had been a vibrant, bright, important center of civilization for about 250 years, then entered almost 500 years of decline, stagnation and insignificance. China no longer expanding, and Europe waking from a millennia of post-Roman fighting for spoils to take interest in the East and thus the Americas, many coastal areas were rapidly and dramatically changing, but Lanna experienced doldrums with little change aside from the introduction of tobacco (which quickly became a wildly popular habit). Many things were undergoing rapid change elsewhere, and from the Americas came chili peppers, tomatoes and corn, markedly altering, and improving, Thai diet. But modern, manufactured things, including shoes and money, as we know it, only started to become familiar in Chiang Mai and north Thailand about 100 years ago. People in the countryside encountered little of the modern until the time of the War of Japanese Aggression (WWII). Rama V, though, determined to modernize his kingdom, began a century of progress, and the north was formally integrated into Siam a year before France took Laos (1893). Societies of loose confederations were over. Resistance to cultural standardization, though, remains, here as in Burma and Laos (Burma gained independence right after WWII, Laos in 1954).
Christian missionaries and clergymen began helping plan educational, medical and health matters, construction and town mapping. The most important person in planning the modern Chiang Rai city was an American, Dr. William A. Briggs, founder of Overbrook Hospital. He mapped out official building areas for business, residences, recreation, hospitals, a prison, and a military camp, with a drainage ditch around the town (1900-1918), while also bringing medicines to fight the diseases which killed so many.
Early on, officials from Bangkok, come to implement the new administrative structures, didn’t help much. They imposed harshly excessive taxes, supposedly meant to replace corvée labor – but traditional demands for unpaid labor didn’t end. In July 1902 Shan ruby miners, teak workers and road builders, nominally British subjects in an area economically dominated by the British, rebelled, seizing Chiang Mai and killing over 20 officials there. Others rebels beheaded the Siamese governor at Phrae, sacked the town and murdered all Siamese they could find. They marched on Lampang with Phrae’s hereditary ruler, revolted in Nan and attacked Chiang Rai, but were defeated by Dr Briggs and companions, barricaded in their hospital with a canon. A good shot as the rebels crossed a moat-bridge caused them to flee.
Those rebels had fantasized establishing their own independent state. Whether this was to be a revival of Lanna is unclear; there is a Shan belief in a King Surakhanfa the Great (1291 – 1364) who ruled Ahom, Dali, Keng Tung, Chiang Saen, Luang Prabang, Lampun, Sukhotai, Chiang Mai, Pegu, Ava and even Mergui (way to the south). Shans claim to have ruled the Ava Kingdom (including Assam and Lampun) until 1555. This rendition excludes any idea of Lanna, except as other Shan principalities. At the time of the rebellion, Indian and Chinese money was at least as common as Siamese (similarly as Thai and Chinese money is used in Shan State now). The Siamese and the few remaining Khon Muang (Lanna people), quite equally, saw themselves as distinct. Perhaps the Shan workers expected not only local, but also British support. They didn’t get it, and vengeance by Siamese troops under Field Marshall Surasak was ruthless. The rebellion lasted barely 14 months; many innocents were punished for it. In December 1905, Prince Vajiravudh, who became Rama VI, visited Chiang Rai. Royal authority from Bangkok was becoming solidified. As King, Rama VI required surnames for all – sometimes whole villages were given the same last name!
When the northern rail route reached the Lanna area (Pitsanulok in 1907, Lampang in 1916 and Chiang Mai variously reported as 1919 or 1922), control from Bangkok became quite fully, and firmly, set. King Rama VII came to visit in January 1926. Rice was now produced for sale (cash was necessary for taxes). With expansion of rice cultivation, a new problem of landlessness appeared: in 1930, 27% of northern farming families had no land. Only the area around Chiang Mai had significant commercial economy; the rest of the north remained subsistence oriented. Unfortunately, the government didn’t help, but only induced local leaders to act as its agents. Cash capitalism came parasitically, imposed from without. In the first Thai economics text, published 1911, Phraya Surinuwat wrote that farmers were “really laboring as if for the benefit of another group of people.” Things have improved, but the wide-spread use of credit now has a majority of farmers are paying heavy interest.

Opium was used in early Siam, not only medicinally, but to calm war elephants and make them more handle-able in battle. In the same year that the British started cutting teak (1826), a British merchant tried to sell opium imported to Bangkok illegally (from India, via Singapore), but wasn’t successful.
Chinese working in Southeast Asia are documented smoking opium in Java as early as the 1620s; in 1702 Siam got laws rewarding help confiscating opium. Rama I prohibited both consumption and trade in it. But in 1855, emboldened by success in China and advances into Burma and the Malay peninsula, Britain forced the Bowring Treaty on Siam; as mentioned above; this gave British subjects exemption from Thai legal and made opium a legal commodity (supposedly, anyway), with no import duty. In reality opium was made legal only for un-naturalized ethnic Chinese. An opium tax soon brought in over 15% of tax revenues. In 1906 an Opium Department was established, so the government could distribute, sell and supervise opium dens. In the dens, not only opium, but tea, was served. Thais preferred betel (which Rama VI began to discourage about 1930, while also encouraging a change to more modern clothing).
In 1824 tea plants in India had first been noticed by Westerners, growing in frontier hills between Burma and Assam state; but in the 1830s, tea still came only from China. Indian (or Ceylon) tea has come to dominate the world market, but back then tea was still a Chinese thing; the British still needed to learn the process by which it’s cured, to produce it for themselves and their trading partners. After many botched attempts, they succeeded in the 1860s, and began to produce tea in Assam and Darjeeling, northeastern India. But to finance their taste for tea, the British long found only opium, to provide them with a trade balance. Homegrown opium, eaten rather than smoked, had long supplied most Chinese needs; the British changed this by introducing tobacco, soon often smoked with opium. Britain accounted for over 80% of the opium smuggling trade – ‘necessary’ to meet its demand for tea; eventually they resorted to force to continue bringing opium from India to China (the “Opium Wars”).
In 1793, British ambassador Lord Macartney collected shoots of tea plants and took them Bengal, with samples of soil where they’d grown; Macartney achieved little towards friendly relations, or trust, between China and Britain – and subsequent embassies weren’t as well treated. Opium smuggling became totally out of control, and relations between Britain and China became unstable (when not openly hostile).
By the mid-1830s opium had become the most traded single commodity in the world. In early 1800s Siam, its popularity was largely due to Chinese laborers come to work constructing canals across the central plains. Soon there were many working on boats and docks, as laborers, craftsmen, rice millers, tobacco growers and shop-workers. Siam’s Chinese population became the largest in Southeast Asia, reaching 440,000 in 1821 (and constituting half of Bangkok by 1880), and with the Chinese came opium. In 1811 King Rama II banned its sale and consumption; in 1839 Rama III ordered the death penalty for major traffickers. But legislative efforts failed, especially as British merchant captains, even before Bowring, were largely immune to prosecution; if a British captain was arrested, the British embassy pressed for his release, and soon the captain could smuggle in another cargo. In 1852, King Mongkut bowed to British pressure and established a royal opium franchise, leased to a wealthy Chinese.
Pressed for revenues to finance public works, European colonial governments in Asia established opium farms, then leased them to Chinese merchants. By 1900, each Southeast Asian state, from Burma to the Philippines, had either an opium monopoly or an officially licensed franchise. In 1905-1906, opium sales provided 16% of taxes for French Indochina, 16% for the Netherlands Indies, 20% for Siam, and a whopping 53% for British Malaya. In 1930, Southeast Asia had 6,441 government opium dens, serving tons of opium to 542,100 registered smokers, but it didn’t become a significant opium producer until the 1950s. Poppy cultivation spread in the highlands during the decades before World War II, but the region remained a minor producer – mostly due to state monopoly fears of lowered prices.
In 1892, the Thai government for 16% of its revenues from opium taxes; that rose to over 20% in 1908, and from 1912 to 1919, then dropped back. In 1927, opium shops were made state owned. A 1938 Opium Act ordered severe penalties for smuggling or illicit dealing, but in 1939 permits were given to hill-tribe people in Chiang Mai, Chiang Rai and Nan provinces, to grow opium for the government. After WWII, imports from India and Turkey resumed; in 1959 opium was again made completely illegal.
That under 1% of the population (57,500 opium smokers were counted in 1939, 71,200 in 1941… realistically, there may have been 2 or 3 times that) supplied 15 to even 24% of revenues, especially as many of those taxed were rickshaw pullers and very low-wage laborers, may defy credulity, but one must note that cash, and tax, were then of smaller general significance. Corveé labor, import duties, the benefits of land control, spoils of war and perhaps other matters (including bribes) may have had greater significance.
When Britain finally abandoned the Asian drug trade in 1907, opium was as entrenched as coffee, tea and alcohol. China's harvest of over 35,000 tons supplied 13.5 million addicts, 27% of its adult males, and represented about 85% of world production. A League of Nations eradication campaign in 1925 got governments to restrict imports and close opium dens, but smugglers serviced the continued demand. Thailand and Indochina couldn’t close their mountainous borders to caravan trade from Yunnan; with 50 % of the region's smokers and 70% of its dens, Bangkok and Saigon were premier markets.

In 1932, largely in response to the worldwide Great Depression, Siamese absolute monarchy came to an end. For 25 years there was little royal influence in affairs of state. It was a time of difficulties, coups, quickly changing international affiliations, and three and a half years of Japanese occupation. In 1933 Chiang Mai, Chiang Rai and Phayao became regular provinces of Siam, which in 1939 (and again in 1949) changed its name to Thailand. Most foreigners in north Thailand escaped to Burma and on home when Japanese occupation came; the Japanese built hard-top roads, several small airports, and a modern one in Chiang Mai. Airplanes and trucks soon became integral to the economy, important to all.
In May 1942 the Thai took control of the Shan region around Keng Tung. These “United Shan States” or “Original Thai States” were recognized by treaty with Japan in August 1943. Sayaburi (Xaignabouri, or Muang Ngoen until taken from Siam in 1903) and Champasak, Laos, and Siem Riep and Battambang provinces, Cambodia, were reattached. Japan surrendered on August 15, 1945, and the Thai government began to restore prewar boundaries. Peace was established with Britain at the end of December, but only in January 1947 did Thailand return French colonial provinces.
Resumption of monarchy’s importance in Thai politics came in 1957. King Bumipon had snubbed Field Marshall Phibun Songkram, the wartime leader who’d welcomed the Japanese and returned to power in 1947, by avoiding all celebrations of the 2,500th anniversary of Buddhism. Then, on Sept 13, 1957, Field Marshal Sarit Thanarat and other army officers demanded that the government resign, and Major-General Phao Siyanon, Director of Police (the “Butcher of Bangkok”), be dismissed from office. During a public rally in support of this, a huge crowd marched to Sarit’s house. Phibun and Phao wanted to arrest Sarit, but couldn’t. In an inspired coup involving no deaths, Sarit’s supporters elevated him to the highest bureaucratic office, while forcing Phibun and Phao to flee. They took asylum in France (Sept. 17, 1957).
Since then, the king has had a quite visible public role. Re-securing the monarch’s position at the top of the social hierarchy, Sarit justified his regime with an original ideology based on paternalistic, traditional social and political hierarchy. Instead of emphasizing abstract loyalties to country or constitution, Sarit focused on respect for the monarch, with citizen loyalty as the source of legitimacy for government, the worldly part of a sacred monarchy. Social hierarchy, built up from the masses through the lower bureaucracy to higher officials and monarch, was reinforced. The king, restored to the top of moral, social and political orders, resumed service as the highest supporter of the country’s dominant religion, Buddhism, while also offering support to Islam.
Sarit tried to redefine democracy, calling it, for Thais, a system of government, bureaucracy and king, responsive to people’s needs and aspirations. Leaders were to act toward members of society as fathers toward children, concerned for their well being, but stern in discipline. A consequent attitude that those in authority needn’t explain difficult matters to others brought problems with accountability, consistency and transparency – problems which still hamper Thai efforts to successfully compete in the modern global economy. A long series of new constitutions seems to somehow fail to generate adequate checks and balances, local self-determination is too limited, and the educational system really not up to snuff. Powers battling in Bangkok are seldom of much real help to the countryside, where only strong cultural roots, hard work and co-operation enable a decent quality of life, for many, to survive.
Although the Japanese conscripted people of the northern Muang and built roads which penetrate the rough, mountainous Lanna area (roads still used today), and insisted on shoe wearing (as well as hats), they also encouraged opium production; a result was that the Northern area, outside of Chiang Mai, wasn’t safe to really open up until the 80s.
Military governments of the 50s, 60s and 70s alienated many free-thinkers, and after student uprisings of 1973 were brutally put down and dictatorship resumed in 1976, many radicals took to the hills of Northern Thailand to join in communist insurgency. When Mao Tse Dung’s victory put Mainland China under Communist government, an influx of anti-Communist Chinese had entered the Lanna area, mostly soldiers of Chiang Kai-shek’s Koumintang (KMT) army. In 1961 the Nationalist Chinese KMT’s “Lost Army” moved into Thailand, many to take up residence at Doi MaeSalong in Chiangrai, where Muslims of Chinese descent already lived. The KMT planted round pears (‘sali’), plums and tea.

Northern Thailand was still sparsely populated and undeveloped into the early 1970s, by which time drug money had become the dominant force and the area called the “Golden Triangle”. Communist activity kept the United States interested even after the Vietnam War; such interest increased proportional to American consumption of drugs produced in Tai Yai hills. Communist insurgency in the north wasn’t strong, in part due to drug-producing KMT army remnants, but in the early 60s, Thailand’s northern border had “unknown areas” and Opium Warlords even issued their own paper currency (until as late as 1984, in Huai Krai, 15 km south of Mae Sai on Highway1)! The various groups (Communists, drug armies and KMT) gave up their weapons during amnesty programs of the 1980s, and the area became amenable for tourism. The King’s mother, Princess Mother Sangwan Sri Nakarin, or colloquially, Mae Fa Luang &/or Somdet Ya, took great interest in the north, and did much to help end illicit drug production in Thailand.
In 1982 powerful drug-lord Khun Sa was pushed out, and by 1990, a Royal Foundation directed by the King’s Mother was successfully containing drug production. So drug lords in Shan State (including Khun Sa) increased output. Chiang Rai was still a small town and in many ways decades out of date (though not so much as Keng Tung, capital of Myanmar’s Shan State, remains today); the wife of a USA Drug Enforcement Agency agent’s was murdered in an attempt at intimidation &/or retribution, in town in the late 80s.
At that time, tea cultivation began to offer an alternative source of income to opium. Two principal varieties of tea have become common: the small-leaved China plant (C. sinensis sinensis) and the large-leaved Assam plant (C. sinensis assamica). Science indicates that tea production originated in Southeast Asia, in the mountains where China, Burma and Laos meet. Tea seems to have been first used in Yunnan, especially in its southern districts (Pu’er Prefecture and Xishuangbanna Dai Autonomous Prefecture – to Thais, Sipsongpanna). Its natural habitat is in the fan-shaped area between the Naga, Manipur and Lushai hills of the Assam–Burma frontier (to the west), through China and the Himalayan foothills of upper Burma and Thailand east to Chekiang Province and south into Vietnam and mountains of upper Cambodia. The three main varieties of the tea plant - Chinese, Assam and Cambodian - occur in their most distinct forms at the extremes of this fan-shaped area. Teas are classified by region of origin, by size of processed leaf, and, most importantly, by manufacturing processes, which produce fermented (black), unfermented (green), and semi-fermented (oolong or pouchong). Many hybrids between varieties are commonly found in most tea fields.
In the late 1980s, experts from Taiwan helped the ex-KMT upgrade to high-quality hybrids of Camellia sinesis, from which they produced the much more expensive Oolong (‘black dragon’) teas valued by connoisseurs. Oolong refers to a processing technique by which tea leaves are only slightly oxidized (green tea isn’t oxidized; black tea is fully oxidized). Live top leaves are collected on clear mornings, along with buds yet to blossom. These are steamed, "withering" the leaves, oxidizing them slightly. After the brief withering stage, the leaves are lightly rolled by hand, until red and fragrant. Machines are increasingly used, to roll the leaves into small balls, and dry them completely.
Research in the early 1990s found polyphenol antioxidants, beneficial to human health, in tea; they help lower blood cholesterol and reduce blood pressure. Tea also contains antibacterial agents, can relieve cold and flu symptoms, stimulate the cardio-vascular system, and even help fight cancer.
Thai ice-tea, cha-yen, made from strongly-brewed red tea, anise, coloring, sugar and milk, is much less traditional than nam bai-toei – usually drunken cool, without ice. While in China hot tea is drunk to cool one, in hotter climes this isn’t much done, and tea, except for weak Chinese tea for breakfast on cold days and in Chinese restaurants, didn’t become popular in Thailand until betel was actively discouraged and ice became commonly available.

At the turn to the 21st Century, the Wa attained a new significance in the local picture. Many relocated to areas just north of the Myanmar border, where they produce mass quantities of amphetamines for export to Thailand and elsewhere. Perhaps as many as 200,000 of these Wa are currently in the limbo of displaced people; tens of thousands of these were born in China. Many Lahu people have been evicted to make way for them, but as the government in Yangoon is interested in becoming less isolated, this may not result in a new refugee crisis.

Within the lifetime of some still living, fashions and styles here have changed from going barefoot, chewing betel or smoking cigars, bartering trade and wearing homemade cloth. A few countrywomen still smoke large, hand-made cigars, and skillful weaving remains common. In their youth, the elderly of the common folk had few manufactured things, didn’t use sinks, drawers or electricity, and had their maladies treated herbally. Modern changes began mostly at the time of the War of Japanese Aggression (WW II). The Japanese ion, and insisted on more modern apparel, but changes weren’t extreme until the late-60s. The first modern department store opened in the late 1950s (Tantrapanh). U.S. anti-communistic imperialism supplemented changes the Japanese introduced, and a growing availability of money produced ever more significant changes.
Even recently a household with a car or pick-up, and maybe even a computer, for better or for worse, may not have a western-style toilet (and the old-style ones are creditably called healthier). Closets, drawers and kitchen sinks and even shovels remain significantly new additions to the culture of the Lanna area, but self-sufficiency is now mostly limited to hill people, while the value of such self-reliance seems largely forgotten. The people who retain capacity for it seem generally regarded as backward. Some of those ‘backward’ self-sufficient repositories of knowledge, Bangkok power-brokers have proposed to exile to hopelessness in Myanmar (Burma). An insufficient number of people with influence may recognize the importance of local wisdom (or perhaps they’re only unable to eloquently express how this wisdom can rival the importance of contributing to the cash economy and government revenues), but few have been forced back, while more continue to come.

Yonok, Lanna and the Shan States couldn’t be precisely mapped because clearly delineated geographical boundaries weren’t an essential part of the old feudal system, not only in Asia but elsewhere too. A person had allegiance and loyalty to a protector, as did a village; princes were under kings who were subservient to emperors. The lines of modern patronage hierarchy may not be mapped, but in T’ai society position and rights are determined more by social factors than by geography. Mapping, surveying and private ownership of land were, after all, introduced only fairly recently. 500 years ago the world had very few well demarcated land boundaries; 150 years ago Thailand but little of Thailand’s border was well defined, and even today there remain areas with imprecise delineation. The rulers and decision-makers of the various Lanna tribes and cities formed their own sub-set, a society of its own but without a name. The wealthy and powerful could and did travel; but tended (as is commonly the case) to marry people of their own station. There was, of course, intermarriage between poorer individuals of abutting groups. Tribal realities tend to change after only a few generations; certainly this has been the case during the limited time of which we have documentation. Some local Lanna realities remain hard to express clearly in Western context.
The Thai in the late 19th century picked up notions of race and nationality from encroaching Europeans, and appropriated them in order to facilitate resistance to further encroachments. The “multi-ethnic” ethos had to bend, in order to accommodate, or counter, European dogma. The French excuse for annexing Laos, that it was part of Vietnam for having paid tribute, was, and remains, shockingly irrelevant to anything but bulldog diplomacy. From 1900, tribal groups were discouraged from maintaining separate identities; amalgamation became part of the serious business of national security and sovereignty, imperative even if not entirely successful. When the tourism boom reached the north in the 1980s, colorful hill-tribes became a more obviously valuable (and marketable!) asset, and that changed somewhat, while forces of globalization stepped in to maintain the trend towards homogenization. But there’s a lot of local pride, and some things have begun to change back from the recent tendency to material myopia.
Northern homes traditionally were built of teak, with beautiful Galae horns at the peak, and walls sloping gently outward, but cement has replaced wood as the preferred construction material. Fifty years ago, building materials here were mostly natural. Then cement became an increasingly powerful force in Thai politics and industry, taking a dominant place in construction until the country was overbuilt. Many a never-occupied row of shop-houses remains empty, and many projected housing projects remain noticeable because of their abandoned gateways. Quite recently, however, a renewed reverence for aesthetics and grace seems to be becoming increasingly more in evidence. Tribal homes are still often of bamboo, with grass roofs, but more and more use cement, tile and corrugated manganese. Some traditional style raised houses combining modern convenience with old minimalist technologies alleviate need for air conditioning – in these mosquito netting usually remains fairly imperative!

A decade-plus of economic boom (until 1997, then reviving after 2002, while looking as if now headed for another bust) brought a flood of development to the Chiangrai area. Many pleasant vacation homes were built for people who live and work in the Bangkok area. Hotels went up, the city expanded, communication services and other infrastructure were improved, and traffic jams began to appear. The Asian Economic Downturn of the late ‘90s mostly affected projects perhaps not so well considered anyway. The politics of cement contributed significantly to the economic downturn: politicians with business ties in construction, materials supply and banking encouraged issuance of myriad construction loans which produced some temporary employment but also a lot of wasted effort. In the Lanna/Golden Triangle area there are still drugs, warlords, subversives and corrupt elements, but the biggest of such problems reside across the Burmese and Lao borders. Un-collectable debt may now be the biggest local problem, although in the face of the same problem internationally, it’s been said that Thai banks and financial institutions learned from the 1997 “Thaitanic” (lending) fiasco, and are sufficiently well underwritten to withstand the global economic crisis of 2009 (at any rate, the worst risk takers went out of business back then). There remains danger from too much credit use, especially for the purchase of vanity status symbols (like oversized pick-ups). Still, development is certainly on-going, and most people are happy with better housing, communication and transportation, despite the petulant protests of some (who may have a good point about the Bangkok power structure, but haven’t presented a viable alternative).
Turmoil in Bangkok has repercussions in the north, but is a really big deal only in ChiangMai. For the rest, local community is more important, and although there is impact from globalization, it is limited. People know their neighbors, share in worship with them, and buy local products from people whose names they know. Children play freely with other kids from nearby, without adult supervision or danger, or, at least, very little danger, and people are often seen smiling. Quality of life is as good as anywhere, cost of living low, the weather rather more than tolerable, and life generally relaxed. There are problems, but maybe fewer of them than anywhere else.

Labels: , , , ,