Mythorelics

Taoist mythology, Lanna history, mythology, the nature of time and other considered ramblings

My Photo
Name:
Location: Chiangrai, Chiangrai, Thailand

Author of many self-published books, including several about Thailand and Chiang Rai, Joel Barlow lived in Bangkok 1964-65, attending 6th grade with the International School of Bangkok's only Thai teacher. He first visited ChiangRai in 1988, and moved there in 1998.

Wednesday, April 28, 2021

Various Noble Savages

Maybe there are actual places which support only limited variation among resident humans: gambling cities (Macao, Vegas, Monaco), DC, LA, Guantanamo, Diego Garcia, Vatican, Mecca… maybe. Maybe personality doesn’t parallel among Inuit and Maasai. Maybe. There’s reason to believe the character of northern, wheat-eating Han Chinese differs from that of southern, rice- eating Han Chinese, but I don’t expect one could measure the difference.
Once “dementia praecox” was considered a known condition, covering catatonia, hebephrenia, and paranoid schizophrenia. Then understandings evolved. Perceptions of national, or regional, character have made for many jokes. Blondes were stereotyped, as were professors.
The impact of the circumstances of observation on observations became misunderstood. It was widely accepted that observation changed that which was observed - as if widely viewed lunar-eclipses leave us with a changed moon. Lots of nonsense was, and is, presented as true and even important, regularly, in the hallowed halls of academia. Poseurs in anthropology, psychology, economics, history, physics and literature remain abundant, and at Yale they still sing, “We're poor little lambs who have lost our way. Baa, baa, baa.” The BS is so rampant and pervasive as to undermine confidence even in test-verifiable sciences, like biology – after all, our understanding of genetics was recently turned on its head through epigenetics. Everything changes.
Given choice between Space Aliens and Noble Savages I’ll go with the noble savage myth and hope that proximity to nature might provide the kind of revitalization we’re going to need to survive. Plus, I’ve found the literature invigorating.
Just a few years after it came out my mother started reading to me from Margaret Mead’s book for kids, “People and Places” (1959). I enjoyed it, and “Trappers and Traders of the Old West” (out of print and mostly forgotten). Mead’s 1928 “Coming of Age in Samoa” – wrong but considered right – was the most widely read anthropology book until Napoleon Chagnon’s “Yanamamo: The Fierce People” (1967 – like with Mead’s first book, the anthropologist is able to ‘verify’ a pre-conceived notion, seeing what he or she wants to see and disregarding the rest). Chagnon followed “Lost World of the Kalahari” (by Laurens van der Post, 1958, tough guy stuff á la Hemmingway. Sir Laurence notes cartilage in !San Bushman dicks, but I don’t think anyone else ever did) and Colin Turnbull’s engaging and charming “The Forest People” (1961). Farley Mowat’s “People of the Deer” (about some inland Inuit, right but long considered wrong) came out in 1952 but didn’t gain acceptance until its re-release in ’75. Marcel Griaule’s Dogon myths (they claimed to have come to Mali from a planet orbiting the Dark Star B Sirius, clearly yanking Griavle’s chain as some Hopi did to Frank Waters, as any knowing eye can see from his enjoyable 1963 “Book of the Hopi”) appeared in French well before that, but still aren’t well known by monolingual English-speakers. Castaneda’s “Yaqui Way of Knowledge” (pure fantasy far too widely accepted as having anthropological value) appeared in 1968, Turnbull’s distressing and depressing (and misguided) “Mountain People” in 1972; “The Education of Little Tree” started charming people in 1976 and the New Age “Mutant Message Down Under” came out in 1990 (in it a White woman is taught by Aborigines to clean herself by standing in a swarm of flies. This book was soon followed by a barrage of other fun nonsense). “People of the Whistling Waters” by Mardi Oakley Medawar (1993) and a slew of other idealistic depictions of tribal life in the form of novels, almost always involving horses, followed. “The Years of Rice and Salt” by Kim Stanley Robinson (2002 ‘sci-fi’) has a Rönin Samurai walk halfway across a huge continent, get a wife chosen for him and then elected tribal chief. Coulda happened…
In 1964 sci-fi king Philip K. Dick gave us “Clans of the Alphane Moon”… from it I got an idea of differentiation of the tribes along lines of psychological inclinations, with all psychological types represented by tribes. Andre the Giant and Michael Clarke Duncan are representative of early Patagonians. Or something. I still see mountain people and beach people as widely separate, psychologically.
Going a surreal step beyond all this, check out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenneth_Good_(anthropologist)

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, October 24, 2017

Cultural art sensitivity

Having spent five very active years in the ethnographic arts trade, and another decade dabbling in it part-time, I’d like to share some of the fun, here. It would have been grand to have learned more of Native Canadian and Maori carvers, Australian Aboriginal art, Sami and Siberian ornamentation, and carvings found around Altai, but I haven’t been able to. And even about things I dealt in, I’m not expert. But about the Hopi, Dogon and Tarahumara I did learn some, as I did also of Balinese art, Burmese Nats, Yao Ceremonial paintings and bits about weaving, basketry and cross-stitch. I retain a deep admiration for what I’ve seen and learned of these things. Here I’ll focus mostly on the first three. Way back in time, these tribes, ethnic groups, communities or cultures all chose to live in inaccessible places to avoid marauders. As a result they haven’t suffered nearly as much from European interference as so many other “native’ peoples. Their religious observances involve dancing (shudder), masks (horror!) and aspects they’re careful about disclosing to meddlesome outsiders. Sometimes, in response to obnoxious persistence, they’ll give false info, maybe even within an elaborate put-on. Good clean fun on a two-way street that goes both up and down but where all is not equal. Visitors aren’t likely to open up about their longings or addictions, their cravings for status symbols, reliance on overkill, poisons and euphemism or unsupportable energy and resource consumption, are they? No more do Hopis, Dogons or Tarahumara wish to expose their vulnerabilities or failings. When “exotic” cultures became the object of academic study, “artifacts” became monetarily desirable collector items, sometimes quite valuable. Soon similar items were made to supply the demand, then clever entrepreneurs delineated the real (i.e. stolen) from the fake (not so imbued with taboo magic, mystery and titillation). Grave-robbing was part of this, and alcoholic longings proved useful too. I doubt any esoteric knowledge was gained. The fashion for appropriating artifacts died after abut a century, and a few “valuable” items have been returned. Some of the craftspeople are not professional: jewelers, painters, even clothiers. Some tourists still visit and look for souvenirs. At Hopi, they aren’t allowed to take photos, record sound, or even draw what they’re observing there. Dogon folk are often friendly; Tarahumara often aren’t. What’s most significant about these people, to me, isn’t their art but their preference for a simple life where others won’t be tempted to bother taking what little they have. It’s not about being “at one with nature” (maybe some jungle folk are that, or good custodians of nature or at least not very disruptive of it, but in dry places that’s extremely difficult to similarly accomplish). It’s that they’ve been able to exist in their way a long, long time – while in about a century we’ve insured that our culture won’t last another one. Their beliefs are more tenable, effective, practical, and sustainable. Also, traditionally they don’t make a big deal out of who is the better “artist”! Some have more than others, sure, in talent, knowledge, wealth, family or whatever, sure, but the jealous frictions rending apart our society aren’t as obvious. Among the Hopi, I can attest, they DO exist, but the extremes just aren’t there. Nor the injustices, extremes of punitive folly, mean-spiritedness… well, you get the picture. I find that some of the simple artifacts, even if made for sale, can act as a valuable reminder of this. cultural art sensitivity

Labels: , , , , , ,

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Infinite BS & Orders of Infinity

Something that bothers me is the blind, stupefied passivity with which people, and even academic institutions, have accepted blather about “orders of infinity” and even “crunched dimensions” - contradictions in terms axiomatically not to be posited. It is as if squaring the circle were still considered possible, and worse - but I have noticed on the Net claimants to status as bordering on succeeding on doing just that. It seems to relate to insanity, crossed mental circuits, some kind of semi-epileptic, amphetamine-like monomania. Infinite means just that – no limits, of extent beyond anything else, and an infinite number of elephants and an infinite number of ants are the same size, just as a ton of lead weighs exactly as much as a ton of feathers! And a dimension extends infinitely - you simply can’t hope to put one in your pocket, no matter what you might have encountered in the comics.
But as the concepts of zero and one have no actual, unequivocal analogue in the perceptible world (nature “abhorring” a vacuum, and everything interacting with everything and lacking pure boundaries or the hard edges we assume as a convenience), and fuzzy logic has given us great screen-picture resolution, among other things, I suppose there’ll be no stopping the blather.
It all reminds me of Yale linguists Benjamin Whorf and Edward Sapir claiming Hopi language has no word for time, and that Hopi time-sense is circular. I expect that the Sapir–Whorf hypothesis, that the structure of a language tends to condition the ways in which a speaker of that language thinks (and that the structures of different languages lead the speakers of those languages to view the world in different ways) is correct, but it wasn’t even either of them who originated the idea, and apparently they didn’t talk to any Hopis about it, or, if they did, the Hopi they met must have pulled their leg the way the Dogon did with some anthropologist, claiming they came from the dark star Sirius B, a prank long ago discredited but still reflected in Encyclopedia Britannica’s entry on the Dogon. The Hopi, and others, have done this kind of thing to get a laugh out of meddlesome interlopers not really willing to spend much time - I knew a young white man who some Tewa from the Hopi First Mesa had also known… he’d bragged to me about his initiation into the Chakwaina Society. The Chakwaina Katchina was modeled on the first Black man Pueblo people encountered (so he’d been made a kind of honorary nigger).
It can be so good to feel important, have something interesting to say, to pose as an achiever… I worry about falling into the same pit here.

At any rate, there’s a curious notion that one ‘infinity’ can be bigger than another (My Infinity’s bigger than your infinity, always has been and always will be). Perhaps it comes from a misguided notion that infinity is a real, instead of imaginary, number.

Recently, a now ex friend told me that I shouldn’t challenge notions I don’t understand; that some people know more than me, especially about math. Now, I’m fine to admit that some people know more about the commodities market than I do (I know scarce little about it), but somehow I think that doesn’t apply to commodities futures, or ability to think one’s way out of a paper box. I’ve learned how to think. Most people, including most academics, haven’t.

Tired from 45 days of hosting a tiresome guest (that now ex-friend), it took me a few hours to think out a word problem attributed to Frank Morgan (“The Math Chat Book”, Math Association of America 2000), which I found in John D. Barrow’s “The Infinity Book (Vintage, Random House, Great Britain, 2005). “Three guys to into a hotel, each with $10 in his pocket. They book one room at $30 a night. A short while later a fax from headquarters directs the hotel to charge $25 a night. So the receptionist gives the bellhop $5 to take to the three guys sharing a room. Since the bellhop never got a tip from them and because he can’t split $5 three ways, he decides to pocket $2 and give them each one dollar back. So each of the three guys has not spent $9 and the bellhop has $2, for a total of $29 Where’s the extra dollar?”

It’s misdirection, misapplied association, and basically the same thing used in the next chapter to “prove” (a la Georg Cantor) that some infinities are “bigger” (or “stronger”) than others. Now, Barrow does quote Galileo: “we cannot speak of infinite quantities as being the one greater or less than or equal to another”, and narrate some about Cantor’s problems with mental illness (not uncommon among those who’ve wrestled with problems resultant from assuming there can be “orders of infinity”). Cantor’s sleight of hand involves distinguishing “countable” and “uncountable” infinities, then proclaiming that, since a one-to-one correspondence of irrational numbers and rational numbers cannot be made (and there are even problems ordering irrational, and most certainly imaginary, numbers), the sets cannot be equal (the set of irrational numbers is “infinitely bigger than the natural numbers or the fractions.”).
One problem with this had already been addressed in Barrow’s book: in the 14th century, Albert of Saxony showed that an infinite amount of something bigger does not represent more than an infinite amount of something smaller. “Take an infinitely long beam of wood, with a square cross-section of size 1 unit by 1 unit. Now saw it up into cubes of equal size. You will have an infinite number of these cubes which you can now use as building blocks.” With these blocks, you could “fill the whole of an infinite three-dimensional space!” The infinite has strange properties, including not becoming smaller when something is subtracted from it… and not needing a one-to-one correspondence with another infinity.
One of Barrow’s chapters is titled, “Infinity Comes in Three Flavours”. They are mathematical infinities, physical infinities (!) and absolute infinity (!!!). Interestingly, in George Gamow’s “One Two Three… Infinity” (© 1947, 1961), there are reputed to be only three orders of infinity: the number of all integers, the number of all geometrical points, and the number of all curves. These are supposedly “enough to count anything we can think of” – except imaginary numbers. And, to give them credit, mathematicians have certainly shown some imagination. But, then again, much of modern math simply doesn’t apply to the world we can experience.

Not yet half-way through Barrow’s book, I was impressed with his discussion of “string theory”. He describes Roger Penrose’s proposal that there’s “a principle of ‘cosmic censorship’ in nature, so that all singularities, or physical infinities, where the laws of Nature break down, are hidden from the outside universe by horizon surfaces.” I’ll leave it to the reader to interpret that, or not. After a bit, he goes on, “Up until 1974, black holes were believed to be inescapable matter traps. Once you passed in through the horizon there was no escape. Then Stephen Hawking predicted that black holes should not be completely black. Their strong gravitational fields will gradually produce pairs of particles close to the horizon at the expense of the mass and energy of the black hole. Gradually the mass of the hole will evaporate away.” Then, “Physical infinities will be nuanced by the laws of Nature.” Barrow claims that string theorists (well, “particle physicists”) don’t believe in physical infinities (which is fine by me). “Since the 1980s, string theory has shown how these infinities can be avoided by changing our conception of what the most elementary pieces of the Universe look like.” Well, of course, they don’t “look” like anything – you can’t see them. But it can be postulated that they have shape… well, sort of, anyway. Instead of things imploding into a crunch of infinite density, a ‘bounce’ at finite density and temperature results “from a previous state of contraction, or by a non-expanding state that suddenly bursts into motion.”
Reminding me of word games like Noam Chomsky trying to use words to explain words (it can’t be done, anymore than my infinity can be truly shown to be larger than yours, see Gödel's Theorem). But Chomsky the political critic makes some interesting points, including that, if the Nuremberg laws were applied, then “every post-war American president would have been hanged.” At a news conference in 1977, President Jimmy Carter said about the Vietnam War, “We have no need to apologize or castigate ourselves or assume the status of culpability. We do not owe a debt. Our intentions were to defend the freedoms of the South Vietnamese, and the destruction was mutual.” Never-mind that the Vietnamese saw themselves as defending their homes. Word-tricksters have been at it for thousands of years, calling the opposition, pre-emptively, what they know they are themselves, or God “That than which no greater can be conceived”, or telling you that you have no right to criticize “authority” as you simply do not know enough.
Some try to justify "orders of infinity" through a trick of mis-direction whereinwhich it's shown that some sets have no one-to-one relationship with others, and therefor must be larger. This is spurious. The concepts of infinity and one-to-one relationships have no direct, or logical, connection. To compare one infinite series to another establishes nothing, but perhaps the fact that so many have believed that it does establish establish something, itself establishes something. People will believe anything they find reason to want to believe.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,