Mythorelics

Taoist mythology, Lanna history, mythology, the nature of time and other considered ramblings

My Photo
Name:
Location: Chiangrai, Chiangrai, Thailand

Author of many self-published books, including several about Thailand and Chiang Rai, Joel Barlow lived in Bangkok 1964-65, attending 6th grade with the International School of Bangkok's only Thai teacher. He first visited ChiangRai in 1988, and moved there in 1998.

Saturday, December 30, 2023

Entropic Differentiation

Antoine Laurent Lavoisier changed the focus of chemistry from qualitative to quantitative; his findings equal in stature those of Isaac Newton. His new understanding of the constituent parts of air and of the combustion process laid the groundwork for creation of the periodic table. Perhaps his greatest and most lasting achievement was to impose order on the language and symbolism that have shaped the thoughts of chemists. His beginner’s guide to chemistry included a table that recognized 55 elements, including both old and new names. Metals were shown to be compounds of metals with oxygen: hence “Vitriol of Venus” became “copper sulphate”. He also showed that gasses expand evenly, to fill available space.
In The Narration of Alvar Nunez Cabeza de Vaca, various tribes seem reminiscent to the 1960’s Philip K. Dick classic, Clans of the Alphane Moon. Dick’s science-fiction tale hinges on an associative tendency among varieties of mental patients, leading to kinds of empowerment. It suggests availability of unacknowledged avenues for survival in the face of great odds. There’s also suggestion that societies differentiate to cover all possibilities of psychic space.

From my novel “Dignity, Too”:

Was, Geo wanted to know, tribalism based on a preference for individualized preference, distinction for distinction’s sake, as much as on physical and historical happenstance? Perhaps it was a natural tendency to develop a specialty? Personality types interact in predictable patterns, perhaps map-able in their tendencies, like ‘The Laws of the Motion of Gasses’ by the 16th century Frenchman Lavoisier (beheaded by the revolution for wealth).
“OK, it’s about how much of our behavior might really be made understandable. Sure, and, indeed, really, how much of our history has to do with things way beyond the ken of even most special, shamanistic individuals? Look at it from the example I like: a gas will spread evenly to fill available space. OK?”
“OK – if you’re not confusing people and things.”
“Things are what we can look at, more than personalities. But people of a similar mien, isolated, will diverge like gasses, spreading out, though in people’s case in variety, in character divergence, to fill each possible niche of the human range of character type, emotional proclivity, whatever. The gases don’t diversify, they just spread out, but people can spread out in emotional range. Suppose you take 50 seminarians…”
“Divinity students, right? Take ‘em where?”
“Yeah, right. 50 guys pretty much the same - put ‘em in some isolated place where they’re able to make do and survive. They’re gonna change. One will become more of a clown, another, the heavy or policeman. Some will do more work than others, some are gonna be more artsy. Some will act like bosses, some will be more sexual, some less; some popular, some rejected. Some will become overly assertive, some overly meek. Got the picture?”
“Like, get rid of the class cut-up, and another troublemaker pops right up to take his place? Barbara talks about that: the book Lord of the Flies.”
“Exactly! The way I figure it, among any race, once you’re familiar with them, faces suggest a similar range of personalities, of character varieties and habitual tendencies… the more some things change, the more others stay the same.”
“Gotcha! Ya know, though, the meekest of a really warlike group might still be more warlike than the most aggressive of a peaceful people.”
Clan rivalries, they decided, were a trying ground for the human condition - something most shamans might miss recognizing, for the sake of their necessary orientation to clan survival.
“This mathematician, Kurt Gödel, a friend of Einstein’s, showed how any method of organizing thought, any system, not only includes at least one internal contradiction, but also incidents which, though clearly part of the organizing, or system, can’t be really be accounted for, at least not mathematically. Human tools for grappling with reality are bent and inadequate; there’s more involved than we can possibly conceive. The spiritual aspect to this is, that directions people go in hardly involves just choice – we move along in syndromes. This is something I’m sure many Shaman understands, or understood, though, like me, in non-mathematical ways. They at least realized we have tendencies we can’t reverse.”

________________
On Philip Dick’s imaginary moon Alpha III M2, psychiatric diagnostic groups differentiated themselves into caste-like pseudo-ethnicities. The inhabitants have formed seven clans:
The Pares, paranoiacs, function as the statesman class. Their settlement is called Adolfville (named after Adolf Hitler). It is located within the northern sector of Alpha III M2, and is heavily fortified. This is where the supreme council building is, a stone, six-story-high building, the largest one in Adolfville. They correspond to MegaCorp CEOs.
The Manses are inventive people with mania. They are the most active class, the warrior, Kshatriya, class. They live at Da Vinci Heights, characterized as diverse but disordered, without aesthetic unity, "a hodgepodge of incomplete projects, started out but never finished." This is where Alpha III M2's television transmitter is. Tension between them and the Pares is constant, with the Manses ever trying to stage a coup d'état; they correspond to politicians, “journalists” and uniformed officers in current Earth society.
The Skitzes are schizophrenic. They correspond to the poet class, with some being religious visionaries. The Skitz town is named Joan d'Arc, “poor materially, but rich in eternal values.” Many are musicians, some preachers; some sometimes foresee some things.
Heebs have hebephrenia (disorganized schizophrenia). They correspond to Sudras and/or Untouchables, with settlement called Gandhitown, "an inhabited garbage dump of cardboard dwellings."To the other clans, they are useful only for manual labor. Like the Skitzes, some Heebs are religious visionaries, but occasionally produce ascetic saints (the schizophrenic group produces dogmatists). Some sometimes enjoy putting on entertaining shows.
The Polys have polymorphic schizophrenia. Their settlement is Hamlet Hamlet. They’re the Vaisya caste creative members of society, who produce new ideas. The children from every clan on Alpha III M2 were born Polys, went to their common, central school as Polys, and became differentiated only in their 10th or 11th year., some do not actually have mental disorders at all. They sometimes work as merchants, builders, drivers, farmers or herders, but often avoid the other “tribes”.
The Ob-Coms are obsessive-compulsive. They are clerks and office holders, money-lenders, bureaucrats and ritualistic functionaries, sometimes medics but never with original ideas. Their conservatism balances the radical quality of the Polys and offers stability. The Deps have clinical depression. Their town is Cotton Mather Estates, where they live "in endless dark gloom." They may occasionally orate to crowds that mostly ignore them.
In addition to these groups in Dick’s novel novel, (which I have expanded upon a bit) one can imagine catatonics – teachers, shop-keepers, book-keepers, and sometimes animal breeders. The autistic are sometimes farmers, sometimes librarians, sometimes, temporary intermediaries between the other groups. Nymphomaniacs produce advertising for the Pares and Heebs with enough ambition to occasionally seek paying audiences. Inverts are often soldiers or guards. Masochists serve as maids and garbage collectors. There are of course others, as in POTUS 45, and “Moses” Mike Johnson.
One might also add neurotics, phobiacs, anorexics, pedophiles, hypochrondiacs, klepto- and pyro-maniacs, plus and hoarders, but perhaps sociopathic or psychopathic tribes or “clans” would be quite a stretch, going too far.

______________
In the eastern foothills of the Himalayan “snow” mountains, the concept of a country or socially segregated society remains as unrecognized as it was everywhere 500 years ago. Elizabethan Britain was a kind of a country, and Spain becoming one; the Aztecs had a definite domain and there were others (Ashanti, Mali/Timbucktoo, Ayutthaya, Japan) but within each were largely almost invisible sub-cultures (sexual, philosophical, religious, magical, musical familial and sometimes business). Borders were not delineated or demarked, and could be more related to altitude, vegetation, water (those who farmed on lakes and those who irrigated had very different concerns) than anything else. Who was obligated to who was what mattered; who could be used to fight who. Not geographical borders. Those with armies usually had slaves and those with freedom, ability to blend into shadows. Some worked stone, others didn’t.
In other places, dry Anatolia for instance, some went underground. Some Steppe herders built stone cities they inhabited only in winter. There were water nomads as well as land nomads. The borderland crises of today are artificial compared to the practical flexibility of yesteryear. We have forgotten as much as we have learned.

Adapted from https://laowaizu.wordpress.com/2011/04/02/review-of-edmund-leachs-political-systems-of-highland-burma/ :

Edmund Leach's “Political Systems of Highland Burma” (1954) challenged theories of social structure and cultural change. Leach was "fiercely critical of generalizations from one society to a narrative about 'politics' in so-called 'primitive societies'". This book about the Kachin and Shan of Northeast Burma, a region of hills and valleys which the author refers to as the “Kachin Hills”, is classic of anthropology and special because rather than a history of an “ethnic group” or “tribe” it is a history of a region. The people who live in the hills speak different languages, wear different kinds of clothes, and live in different kinds of houses, but understand one another’s ritual. Leach explains his idiosyncratic definition of “ritual acts” as ways of ‘saying things’ about social status. He claims that since the ‘language’ in which these things are said is common to the whole Kachin Hills Area, we are justified in treating the entire region as a unit. He states, “the Kachin seem to value political independence more highly than economic advantage. …in [some area where 94 out of 143 villages contained less than 10 households] it would certainly have been to the economic advantage of this population if it had lived in larger communities in more accessible situations, but the preference was evidently for independence above all else”.
Leach provides a lot of evidence against treating linguistic, ethnic, cultural or kin groups as clearly-defined, exclusive and internally consistent. Though the book is about “the Kachin and Shan”, he does not see them as different in any essential way. Instead, he sees valley and hill societies as economically inextricable and culturally symbiotic. The book begins with an account of an old man who for 70 years had been both Kachin and Shan. His argument isn’t based on viewing social systems as stable through time, but, quite the opposite: social systems are unstable and “what can be observed now is just a momentary configuration of a totality existing in a state of flux.” He provides documented examples of groups who change their language, ethnic identity or political structures over time.
Social scientists require unambiguous terminology for description and analysis, but since all the words we commonly use have various connotations and implications, one “adopts the normal scientific procedure of inventing a language of special terms which have no meaning at all other than that with which the scientist endows them. Such expressions as exogamy, patrilineage, status, role, etc., which are used by anthropologists to describe a system of structural relationships mean just what the anthropologist says they mean, neither more nor less. Consequently structural systems as described by anthropologists are always static systems.”
“Kachin” was originally a classifier like “Hu” or “Man” in Chinese, i.e. vaguely referring to “barbarians” of a certain geographical area. The Kachin are actually an ethnic affinity of several distinct tribal groups, including Rawang, Lisu, Jingpo, Zaiwa, Lishi and Maru, perhaps also Nu and Derung - each known for their disciplined fighting skills, complex clan inter-relations, craftsmanship, herbal healing, jungle survival skills, and fierce independence. There is no more a Kachin tribe than there is a Sioux tribe..Originally the term was a cultural and geographic referent, not a linguistic or ethnic one. However, Leach notes that from 1900 onwards the name began to be increasingly interpreted in linguistic and ethnic terms. The Kachin region contains 4 major linguistic groups, Jinghpaw, Maru, Nung, Lisu. Tai (the language of the Shans) and Jinghpaw speakers have always held power disproportionately in the region; language has political and economic implications. Leach describes the Kachin highlands as politically and socially always in flux, floating between two “ideal social models”, Gumlao and Gumsa. The greater part of this book is consumed in the articulation and analysis of these two social models. For the moment they can be encapsulated as follows:
Gumlao: essentially anarchistic, equalitarian, does not believe in social stratification by lineage, chiefdom, etc., while Gumsa is a “compromise between Gumlao (democratic) and Shan (autocratic) ideals” and assimilates Shan ideals more and more until they feel they “have become Shan”; with complicated hierarchical relations between clans/lineages, and chiefs, etc. The Shan are loyal to a place, not a kin group; the Lisu are opposite to that.
Few, if any, societies are purely Gumsa or purely Gumlao, but rather somewhere between the two. Gumlao areas are especially linguistically diverse. Leach mentions a village cluster called Hpalang with no less than six different dialects spoken as “mother tongue” in a community of 130 households!
Kachins trace descent patrilineally, with one or multiple surnames from fathers. Everyone in village with a common surname is considered close patrilineal kin, of one ‘household’ (htinggaw). Relationships between individuals are determined by the relationship between their respective lineages. Lineages are ordered hierarchically, and each lineage has long-term on-going structured relations with at least two other lineages, which are denoted by the relative terms mayu and dama. Men may not marry into their dama, women may not marry into their mayu. (If the Johnson family is mayu to the Roberts family, then the Roberts family is dama to the Johnson family. Johnson men may not marry Roberts women, but Johnson women are expected to marry Roberts men. To not do so would be an insult unless a symbolic price is paid beforehand. Johnson men are expected to marry Smith women, the Smith family being mayu to the Johnson family, etc.). The highest ranking lineage in a village will most likely have their mayu lineage in another village so as to maintain their position of superiority. Therefore, the top ranking linage accepts women from lower lineages, and sends their women outside the village to another lineage which ranks higher. Sometimes (esp. in Gumlao society), there’s a circle, where A is mayu to B, B is Mayu to C, C is Mayu to A etc.

Political and religious office:
Leach presents very strong, objective evidence that the ways we intuitively think of the identity and cohesion of ethnic groups (and in fact social groups in general), is wrong. The intuitive way of viewing ethnic groups is as a coherent group, with clear boundaries delineated by language, culture, heredity, or some other “objectively observable characteristic”; ethnicity is “primordial”. As with “nationalism”, authors have tried to provide a single concise definition that encapsulates the idea of ethnicity, while simultaneously distinguishing it from all other units of social organization. This may be a fool’s errand as no social grouping (national, cultural etc.) is distinct in essence, but merely in the ways they pretentiously manifest. Ethnic identity (and for that matter national identity, subcultural identity, gender identity, etc.) is socially constructed, a matter of self-ascription, and ascription by others in social interaction. In this way, symbols like language, accent, hair style etc. are hardly the essence of a group, but rather symbols used to distinguish membership. Counter-intuitive though it may seem, there is no such thing as an “ethnic group”, simply because no group is ever defined on just one symbol. Ideas of kinship or common descent are only one aspect of the group’s identity, and there’s no reason to privilege one above all others, even if group members themselves believe it to be a most important or even the only distinguishing characteristic.
Unlike previous anthropologists, Leach doesn’t a priori assume that Kachin and Shan society are two separate social systems. Instead, he argues “in any geographical area which lacks fundamental natural frontiers, the human beings in adjacent areas of the map are likely to have relations with one another – at least to some extent – no matter what their cultural attributes may be…… cultural attributes such as language, dress and ritual procedure are merely symbolic labels denoting the different sectors of a single extensive structural system.”
The lowlands and the hills are a single, codependent economic system. Hill agriculture consistently does not produce enough staple crops, and this shortage must be made up for with trade with the lowland paddy states. The paddy states rely on a rich variety of goods collected from the hills, especially elites, who rely on prestige goods from the hills which serve as symbols of their elite status (this seems similar to the agriculture-pastoralism relationship). Thus, “it seems to me axiomatic that where neighboring communities have demonstrable economic, political and military relations with each other, then the field of any useful sociological analysis must override cultural boundaries”.
Leach insists that language groups cannot be taken to be hereditarily established or stable through time, and provides several examples of specific communities whose language changed over the course of a century. Some villages seem to be very conservative and stubborn in using one language when groups all around them use another language, while others are almost “as willing to change their language as a man might change a suit of clothes”. Leach’s explanation for this is couched in terms of his view that the choice of language is an active, meaningful social choice. He sees social behavior as primarily used to determine, negotiate, or affirm positions in society. “(it is) necessary and justifiable to assume that a conscious or unconscious wish to gain power is a very general motive in human affairs… Individuals faced with a choice of action will commonly use such choice so as to gain power.” But how ‘commonly’ is commonly? What defines a “choice of action”? To assume, as Leach seems to do, that all behavior is both purposeful and calculated not only precludes the possibility of altruism, it also ignores the large element of randomness in human behavior. It also begs question of heredity vs. environment and even of free will. Chemical “imbalances” DO exist, so does madness, but we all like to believe in the possibility of at least some self-control.

_______________
So. River dwelling mahouts differ in personality from nomadic hunters who easily carry all they need when they move away from a soiled mountaintop haven to a new, unsoiled one. Valley rice farmers cultivate with a different degree of co-operation than mountain terrace dry-rice farmers. When a Jamaican flees the beach for safety in high hills, how does that impact on personality? Do we sometimes form personality aspects mostly to stand out from others? Might one day there arise a pre-cog tribe? People more able to anticipate responses than others? Shape-shifters able to make themselves appropriately attractive, or ugly, to whom they wish? Mind influencers who easily convince those near them to whatever is clever by them? And can influence the perceptions and even active personality of any near enough? Telepaths? Weather influencers?
The sea-shore differs from the desert and the wily from the strong. Some live in cities, some of us despise cities. One ability serves sometimes, another ability serves better other times. Homogeneity is weakness.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, April 28, 2021

Various Noble Savages

Maybe there are actual places which support only limited variation among resident humans: gambling cities (Macao, Vegas, Monaco), DC, LA, Guantanamo, Diego Garcia, Vatican, Mecca… maybe. Maybe personality doesn’t parallel among Inuit and Maasai. Maybe. There’s reason to believe the character of northern, wheat-eating Han Chinese differs from that of southern, rice- eating Han Chinese, but I don’t expect one could measure the difference.
Once “dementia praecox” was considered a known condition, covering catatonia, hebephrenia, and paranoid schizophrenia. Then understandings evolved. Perceptions of national, or regional, character have made for many jokes. Blondes were stereotyped, as were professors.
The impact of the circumstances of observation on observations became misunderstood. It was widely accepted that observation changed that which was observed - as if widely viewed lunar-eclipses leave us with a changed moon. Lots of nonsense was, and is, presented as true and even important, regularly, in the hallowed halls of academia. Poseurs in anthropology, psychology, economics, history, physics and literature remain abundant, and at Yale they still sing, “We're poor little lambs who have lost our way. Baa, baa, baa.” The BS is so rampant and pervasive as to undermine confidence even in test-verifiable sciences, like biology – after all, our understanding of genetics was recently turned on its head through epigenetics. Everything changes.
Given choice between Space Aliens and Noble Savages I’ll go with the noble savage myth and hope that proximity to nature might provide the kind of revitalization we’re going to need to survive. Plus, I’ve found the literature invigorating.
Just a few years after it came out my mother started reading to me from Margaret Mead’s book for kids, “People and Places” (1959). I enjoyed it, and “Trappers and Traders of the Old West” (out of print and mostly forgotten). Mead’s 1928 “Coming of Age in Samoa” – wrong but considered right – was the most widely read anthropology book until Napoleon Chagnon’s “Yanamamo: The Fierce People” (1967 – like with Mead’s first book, the anthropologist is able to ‘verify’ a pre-conceived notion, seeing what he or she wants to see and disregarding the rest). Chagnon followed “Lost World of the Kalahari” (by Laurens van der Post, 1958, tough guy stuff á la Hemmingway. Sir Laurence notes cartilage in !San Bushman dicks, but I don’t think anyone else ever did) and Colin Turnbull’s engaging and charming “The Forest People” (1961). Farley Mowat’s “People of the Deer” (about some inland Inuit, right but long considered wrong) came out in 1952 but didn’t gain acceptance until its re-release in ’75. Marcel Griaule’s Dogon myths (they claimed to have come to Mali from a planet orbiting the Dark Star B Sirius, clearly yanking Griavle’s chain as some Hopi did to Frank Waters, as any knowing eye can see from his enjoyable 1963 “Book of the Hopi”) appeared in French well before that, but still aren’t well known by monolingual English-speakers. Castaneda’s “Yaqui Way of Knowledge” (pure fantasy far too widely accepted as having anthropological value) appeared in 1968, Turnbull’s distressing and depressing (and misguided) “Mountain People” in 1972; “The Education of Little Tree” started charming people in 1976 and the New Age “Mutant Message Down Under” came out in 1990 (in it a White woman is taught by Aborigines to clean herself by standing in a swarm of flies. This book was soon followed by a barrage of other fun nonsense). “People of the Whistling Waters” by Mardi Oakley Medawar (1993) and a slew of other idealistic depictions of tribal life in the form of novels, almost always involving horses, followed. “The Years of Rice and Salt” by Kim Stanley Robinson (2002 ‘sci-fi’) has a Rönin Samurai walk halfway across a huge continent, get a wife chosen for him and then elected tribal chief. Coulda happened…
In 1964 sci-fi king Philip K. Dick gave us “Clans of the Alphane Moon”… from it I got an idea of differentiation of the tribes along lines of psychological inclinations, with all psychological types represented by tribes. Andre the Giant and Michael Clarke Duncan are representative of early Patagonians. Or something. I still see mountain people and beach people as widely separate, psychologically.
Going a surreal step beyond all this, check out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenneth_Good_(anthropologist)

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Saturday, March 26, 2016

Personality Differentiation and Emotional Weather

Alvar Nuñez Cabeza de Vaca (~1490–~1557), author of La Relación (1542; translated variously as "The Relation", “The Narration”, ”The Account" or “Shipwrecks” - from later editions re-titled as Naufragios), was a proto-anthropologist who recorded details of many North American indigenous tribes. A chief officer and treasurer to the 1527 Pánfilo de Narváez expedition of 600 men to Florida, which arrived in April, 1528, he was one of only 242 who escaped Florida in boats made from their horses, and of only four who remained alive to reach Mexico, in 1532. Another was rescued about a decade later, but less than 20 survived the first winter, and it was nothing short of miraculous that any survived at all. No more than a handful disappeared to go native until death; Cabeza de Vaca reported one or two doing so.
Most famous for his report for King Charles V of Spain (La Relación), a classic of colonial literature, Cabeza de Vaca was later posted to South America, but his work there isn’t much remembered, except maybe for the tragedy involved. After living among nomadic (sometimes moving camp every few days) foragers with incomparable understanding of their environment and consummate knowledge of seasonal patterns (but also susceptibility to illnesses introduced through Europeans), for a couple of years, he worked alone for over three, as a trader between mutually hostile tribes. Having thus gained some limited freedom, with his last three expedition companions he gained notoriety among indigenees as a healer – and eventually gathered a large following of natives who regarded them as “children of the sun”, endowed with the power to both heal and destroy. Able then to travel on unthreatened, the group walked away from their goal on the eastern coast of Mexico, when less than 100 miles north of it, to travel far west as explorers. Soon they were fed and protected by a large following, often of thousands. Having met coastal peoples and Mississippian tribes, he now saw nomads of the Plains, then Pueblo farmers and merchants and what they called “people of the cows”. After 8 years and “going native,” his group reached Mexico City, having explored much of Texas and the five northernmost mainland Mexican states (Tamaulipas, Nuevo Leon, Coahuila, Chihuahua and Sonora - largely along the Rio Grande).
When he finally met other Spaniards, near Mexico’s west coast, these "friends" wanted to enslave his followers. But, having developed strong sympathies for the indigenous population, he got the Spaniards so lost in the desert they had to agree to release the Indians in return for being led back to safety.
Later on, in 1540 he was appointed governor of Rio do la Plata (now Paraguay, Argentina and surroundings); as in North America, he was unusually sensitive and benevolent towards the Natives. He was the first European to behold the Iguazú Falls, among the most spectacular in the world. But political intrigue and resentment against him led to his arrest and return to Spain in chains. He was eventually exonerated, then wrote an extensive report on South America, which, bound with his La Relación was published under the title Comentarios (Commentary).
Shown in Cabeza de Vaca’s “Narration” is a spectrum of tribal personalities indicative of something interesting in the human condition: Take 20 similar people (or even 10, 50 or 100, seminarians, priests, ballerinas, accounting geeks or soccer players) and isolate them. Previously unobserved facets of personality will emerge while the various personalities differentiate, separating further and further. Over time, one will exhibit more leadership traits, another become the most noticeable care-giver; one will be more of a clown, yet another the leadership's main enforcer. Sexuality will differentiate also, so that all various possible roles be more fully represented.
This may take place as specialization can increase personal value to others. Less ego- or anthro-centrically, it involves a natural tendency to leave no space (niche, physical or character type, involving tendencies, proclivities, orientations) unfilled, unused.
One individual will tend to ruffle feathers, another to soothe. One will be more aesthetically inclined, one more of a bum (maybe the same one, maybe not). Similarly, one tribe will be more friendly to outsiders, another more suspicious, reserved, willing to take offense. Some will prefer the seashore or at least proximity to water, while others prefer mountains, desert or high plains. Some will give more importance to vowel sounds, while a competing group may prefer to use guttural consonants.
We like our distinctions, but use similarities to bond. The distribution phenomena is not without contradiction, and hardly explains everything, but that is the case with much science. Cabeza de Vaca was at least observing, instead of just asserting, as was so sadly the case with so many other “explorers”.
This kind of differentiation was also depicted by William Golding in “Lord of the Flies”; something similar is shown through the development of new powers and capacities by groups with this or that mental illness, in Philip K. Dick’s “Clans of the Alphane Moon”. On the other hand, some character traits seem locked-in and predictable in some folk; even though patterns can change, old proclivities are likely to creep back into opinions expressed in conversation, mood tendencies, activity choices. Habitual behavioral tendencies can be a cultural thing, sometimes similar in cultures extensively separated geographically, while extremely dissimilar in groups living close by in quite similar ecological territory. The meekest of a really warlike group might be more warlike than the most aggressive of a peaceful people, but one of a group of thieves will be more trustworthy than the others. We have a tendency to differentiate, but even this differentiation is differentiated – the spectrum shown in Asia is hardly the same as the spectrum shown in Africa. That Asia and Africa have not experienced the isolation of the desert tribes encountered by Cabeza de Vaca was surely an element involved in that.
For a long time his work was regarded with skepticism, until archaeologists found heavily trampled ground, as would occur from hundreds if not a thousand or more people dancing and jumping around all night if not for days, as narrated and in places within accord with the narration.

In his unintended description of social variety, Cabeza de Vaca described tribes of the early 1530s in the area we now know as Texas. With one tribe, “When one takes a woman for his wife, from the day he marries her, whatever he may hunt or fish, she has to fetch it to the home of her father, without daring to touch or eat of it, and from the home of the father-in-law they bring the food to the husband. All the while neither the wife's father nor her mother enter his abode, nor is he allowed to go to theirs, or to the homes of his brothers-in-law, and should they happen to meet they go out of each other's way a crossbow's shot or so, with bowed heads and eyes cast to the ground, holding it to be an evil thing to look at each other or speak. The women are free to communicate with their parents-in-law or relatives and speak to them. This custom prevails from that island as far as about fifty leagues inland.”
In another, “It is a custom of theirs to kill even their own children for the sake of dreams, and the girls when newly born they throw away to be eaten by dogs. The reason why they do it is (as they say) that all the others of that country are their enemies with whom they are always at war, and should they marry their daughters they might multiply so much as to be able to overcome them and reduce them to slavery. Hence they prefer to kill the girls rather than see them give birth to children who would become their foes.
“We asked them why they did not wed the girls among themselves. They replied it was bad to marry them to their own kin and much better to do away with their daughters than to leave them to relatives or to enemies. This custom they have in common with their neighbors, the Iguaces, and no other tribe of that country has it. When they want to get married they buy their wives from their enemies. The price paid for a woman is a bow, the best to be had with two arrows, and if he has no bow he gives a net as much as a fathom in width and one in length. They kill their own children and buy those of strangers. Marriage only lasts as long as they please. For a mere nothing they break up wedlock.”
In a third, “The men do not carry burdens or loads, the women and old men have to do it, for those are the people they least esteem. They have not as much love for their children as those spoken of before. Some among them are given to unnatural vices. The women are compelled to do very hard work and in a great many ways, for out of 24 hours of day and night they get only 6 hours’ rest. They spend most of the night in stirring the fire to dry those roots which they eat, and at daybreak they begin to dig and carry firewood and water to their houses and attend to other necessary matters. Most of these Indians are great thieves, for, although very liberal towards each other, as soon as one turns his head, his own son or the father grabs what he can. They are great liars and drunkards and take something in order to become intoxicated. They are so accustomed to running that, without resting or getting tired, they run from morning till night in pursuit of a deer, and kill a great many, because they follow until the game is worn out, sometimes catching it alive. Their huts are of matting placed over four arches. They carry them on their back and move every 2 or 3 days in quest of food; they plant nothing that would be of any use.
“They are a very merry people, and even when famished do not cease to dance and celebrate their feasts and ceremonials. Their best times are when ‘tunas’ (prickly pears) are ripe, because then they have plenty to eat and spend the time in dancing and eating day and night.”
A bit later in his narration he says, “In this whole country they make themselves drunk by a certain smoke for which they give all they have. They also drink something which they extract from leaves of trees, like unto water-oak, toasting them on the fire in a vessel like a low-necked bottle. When the leaves are toasted they fill the vessel with water and hold it over the fire until it has thrice boiled; then they pour the liquid into a bowl made of a gourd cut in twain. As soon as there is much foam on it they drink it as hot as they can stand, and from the time they take it out of the first vessel until they drink they shout, "Who wants to drink?" When the women hear this they stand still at once, and although they carry a very heavy load do not dare to move. Should one of them stir, she is dishonored and beaten. In a great rage they spill the liquid they have prepared and spit out what they drank, easily and without pain. The reason for this custom, they say, is that when they want to drink that water and the women stir from the spot where they first hear the shouts, an evil substance gets into the liquid that penetrates their bodies, causing them to die before long. All the time the water boils the vessel must be kept covered. Should it be uncovered while a woman comes along they pour it out and do not drink of it. It is yellow and they drink it for three days without partaking of any food, each consuming an arroba and a half every day.
“When the women are ill they only seek food for themselves, because nobody else eats of what they bring.
“During the time I was among them I saw something very repulsive, namely, a man married to another. Such are impotent and womanish beings, who dress like women and perform the office of women, but use the bow and carry big loads. Among these Indians we saw many of them; they are more robust than the other men, taller, and can bear heavy burdens.”

Philip K.Dick posits psychiatric diagnostic groups differentiated themselves into seven clans: The Pares are paranoids who function as the statesman class and live in a heavily fortified settlement. Some have developed "psionic powers". The Manses suffer from mania; they are an active class, warrior class. They live amidst “a hodgepodge of incomplete projects, started out but never finished.” They operate a television transmitter constantly try to stage a coup d’état. The Skitzes are schizophrenic poets and religious visionaries. The Heebs suffer hebephrenia (disorganized schizophrenia) and live in Gandhitown, “an inhabited garbage dump of cardboard dwellings.” To the other clans, their only use is for manual labor, but some are religious visionaries, mostly ascetic saints (as opposed to the dogmatists among the schizophrenics), with "visionary powers". The Polys suffer from polymorphic schizophrenia; they’re the creative members of society, producing new ideas. Children from all clans are born Polys, then become differentiated in their tenth or eleventh year. Some never became differentiated, though, perhaps having no mental disorder at all. Ob-Coms have obsessive-compulsive disorder (some might once have been called anal-retentive). They are the clerks and office holders of the society, ritualistic functionaries lacking original ideas. Their conservatism balances the radical quality of the Polys, providing social stability. Lastly, the Deps are sufferers of clinical depression. They live in Cotton Mather Estates “in endless dark gloom.”
Dick himself could be said to have suffered from any or all of the psychiatric disorders referred to there, and they are hardly representative of anything but his imagination, but the novel does show the concept of the value of differentiation even with accompanying weaknesses. Unity is not the only form of strength.

There are various ways of intentionally manipulating personality. Widely known is behavior modification or operant conditioning (an academic-obfuscatory term from Latin ‘that works,’ present participle of operari ‘to work’ - coined in 1937 by behavioral psychologist B.F. (“Fred”) Skinner to indicate “involving behavior modification”… operant also means effective, a person or thing that operates, functioning or tending to produce effects, of or relating to the observable or measurable, or even behavior (as bar pressing by a rat to obtain food) that operates on the environment to produce rewarding and reinforcing effects. Or too, relating to, or being a response that occurs spontaneously and is identified by its reinforcing or inhibiting effects. Thus, something with measurable results; as, for instance, a fairly scientific method of evaluating personality change or achieved learning.
Skinner noted that the best way to understand behavior is to look at the causes of an action and its consequences, set out to identify the processes which made certain behaviors more or less likely to occur, especially in terms of responses, internal or external, as in stimuli from the environment that increase probability of a behavior being repeated. Behaviors have consequences, and living organisms tend to learn from them. Changes in behavior are the result of an individual’s response to events (stimuli) that occur in the environment.
Reinforcement, anything that strengthens a response (desired or not), can be negative or positive (as in the carrot or stick analogy). One learns to behave so as to obtain rewards and avoid punishments, and behavioral psychologists examine how this works, especially in terms of effective reinforcement schedules. Behavior modification can reduce a variety of behavior problems. It can also be called ‘brain-washing’ and involve more than just overtones of Orwellian manipulative techniques, an also the effects of ‘soma’ as described in Huxley’s “Brave New World”. The methods of behaviorism can have positive effects even on severe autism, but problems can come from inappropriate application or intent, poor assessment, and/or poor design and/or implementation. Much of this goes back to early animal-training, but, for instance, unlike obedience training that gets and animal to perform specific actions when requested, there is an ideal in behavior modification of manipulating a total change in reaction - producing not simply compliance, but change in attitude (thinking or feeling) and thus action also. This can be particularly significant in terms of uniformed services training, keeping zoo animals from boredom to the extent of severe depression, and could conceivably help with rehabilitation of penitentiary convicts, although to date that might remain controversial if not outright objectionable. Unfortunately, along with lowered interest in education and learning over the decades of improved “information technology” (and simultaneous increases in financial concerns), interest in techniques of behavioral conditioning have decreased also.
Behavioral modification techniques which condition voluntary behaviors that are maintained over time by the consequences that follow those behaviors, can be for a moral good or, equally, for something questionable! Whether conditioned behavior is always perfectly voluntary, remains a debatable issue.
Training affects personality, as does affection, animosity, activity, luck and especially genetics and epigenitics. Personality can and perhaps should take a lead in directing enquiry and thought, and thus education, but stifled personalities often do not do that. Trauma will produce personality change quickest; positive reinforcement is slow, except when done with love, which tends to reinforce what is already there.

Operant conditioning my not make one more creative, more vain, or more flexible, although is certainly can change one, as shown in Kubrick’s “A Clockwork Orange”.
Some people are going to be more materialistic, others more hedonistic, some more punitive, others more hospitable. Some will be more ego-driven, vain and acquisitive, others will be more niche-adapted and stable. This may apply to groups as well as individuals, as seems to be shown by the Amish, Masai, Australian Aborigines and other relatively extreme groups.

Barometric pressure, ions and wind affect human moods. As also the kind of events reported as news. Sometimes also, there seems to be an inexplicable increase in hilarity in a region, or adventuresomeness. People in a specific area might, for a time, be more melancholic than usual, or show tendencies to irrational optimism. There might be a general increase in irritability, anger, suspicion &/or self-doubting. Similarly, might be a decrease in bad moods, either from an increase in negative ions or a decrease in bad news, or perhaps from reasons we’ve yet to discern. The individual is affected by much that he or she cannot even be aware of. Moods are contagious, as with yawning, and occasionally crowd hysteria, but sometimes walls separate people similarly affected by emotional weather, and not just the weather of barometric pressure and ions. It could relate to other physical events; it could relate to “collective unconscious” polities. It might even be spiritual, but it happens. It might sometimes be an aftereffect of a popular fashion.
But we should not pretend that there is no group dynamic, or even that we know of each grouping that we participate in. We are social, we are dependent, and one can not only not decide everything, one cannot even be aware of everything. To pretend otherwise is self-defeat (the popularity of which might well depend on emotional weather).
Not only our emotions are dependent on a wide variety of factors, but our rational thinking also. We can be presented with too much data. Perhaps sensory deprivation produces dysfunction from too little data, as can isolation. Our verbal, and rational, processes are affected by a variety of subconscious cues. What goes on in our lower digestional guts certainly affects how we feel and think, and muscular activity also has its affects.
Some attribute much to the stars – perhaps they have reason to not want to look closer to home. It is important to recognize that strengths usually have corresponding weaknesses, vice versa, and that our strengths and weaknesses aren't "reflections" of the society we live in, but rather, components of it. And when you enter someone else's psychological territory you pay a fee. When folk from different physical territory but similar psychological position meet, there may be what feels as if an inexplicable sense of recognition. Mostly, we know where it is safe to go, and stay to it; outside of those boundaries internal changes must begin,threatening possibility of return. And no-ne is safe outside of their niche, and by it we define, and delineate, our world.

Whether it’s stormy weather, totally enraging politics, the season of beatniks out to make it rich, the summer of waiting to find out who shot JR Ewing of Dallas TV show, the day after the atomic bombing of Nagasaki or the one after Mighty Casey struck out, there might be at least as good a legal defense in the emotional weather that contributed to one’s legal delinquency as ever was affluenza.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,