Mythorelics

Taoist mythology, Lanna history, mythology, the nature of time and other considered ramblings

My Photo
Name:
Location: Chiangrai, Chiangrai, Thailand

Author of many self-published books, including several about Thailand and Chiang Rai, Joel Barlow lived in Bangkok 1964-65, attending 6th grade with the International School of Bangkok's only Thai teacher. He first visited ChiangRai in 1988, and moved there in 1998.

Wednesday, April 28, 2021

Various Noble Savages

Maybe there are actual places which support only limited variation among resident humans: gambling cities (Macao, Vegas, Monaco), DC, LA, Guantanamo, Diego Garcia, Vatican, Mecca… maybe. Maybe personality doesn’t parallel among Inuit and Maasai. Maybe. There’s reason to believe the character of northern, wheat-eating Han Chinese differs from that of southern, rice- eating Han Chinese, but I don’t expect one could measure the difference.
Once “dementia praecox” was considered a known condition, covering catatonia, hebephrenia, and paranoid schizophrenia. Then understandings evolved. Perceptions of national, or regional, character have made for many jokes. Blondes were stereotyped, as were professors.
The impact of the circumstances of observation on observations became misunderstood. It was widely accepted that observation changed that which was observed - as if widely viewed lunar-eclipses leave us with a changed moon. Lots of nonsense was, and is, presented as true and even important, regularly, in the hallowed halls of academia. Poseurs in anthropology, psychology, economics, history, physics and literature remain abundant, and at Yale they still sing, “We're poor little lambs who have lost our way. Baa, baa, baa.” The BS is so rampant and pervasive as to undermine confidence even in test-verifiable sciences, like biology – after all, our understanding of genetics was recently turned on its head through epigenetics. Everything changes.
Given choice between Space Aliens and Noble Savages I’ll go with the noble savage myth and hope that proximity to nature might provide the kind of revitalization we’re going to need to survive. Plus, I’ve found the literature invigorating.
Just a few years after it came out my mother started reading to me from Margaret Mead’s book for kids, “People and Places” (1959). I enjoyed it, and “Trappers and Traders of the Old West” (out of print and mostly forgotten). Mead’s 1928 “Coming of Age in Samoa” – wrong but considered right – was the most widely read anthropology book until Napoleon Chagnon’s “Yanamamo: The Fierce People” (1967 – like with Mead’s first book, the anthropologist is able to ‘verify’ a pre-conceived notion, seeing what he or she wants to see and disregarding the rest). Chagnon followed “Lost World of the Kalahari” (by Laurens van der Post, 1958, tough guy stuff á la Hemmingway. Sir Laurence notes cartilage in !San Bushman dicks, but I don’t think anyone else ever did) and Colin Turnbull’s engaging and charming “The Forest People” (1961). Farley Mowat’s “People of the Deer” (about some inland Inuit, right but long considered wrong) came out in 1952 but didn’t gain acceptance until its re-release in ’75. Marcel Griaule’s Dogon myths (they claimed to have come to Mali from a planet orbiting the Dark Star B Sirius, clearly yanking Griavle’s chain as some Hopi did to Frank Waters, as any knowing eye can see from his enjoyable 1963 “Book of the Hopi”) appeared in French well before that, but still aren’t well known by monolingual English-speakers. Castaneda’s “Yaqui Way of Knowledge” (pure fantasy far too widely accepted as having anthropological value) appeared in 1968, Turnbull’s distressing and depressing (and misguided) “Mountain People” in 1972; “The Education of Little Tree” started charming people in 1976 and the New Age “Mutant Message Down Under” came out in 1990 (in it a White woman is taught by Aborigines to clean herself by standing in a swarm of flies. This book was soon followed by a barrage of other fun nonsense). “People of the Whistling Waters” by Mardi Oakley Medawar (1993) and a slew of other idealistic depictions of tribal life in the form of novels, almost always involving horses, followed. “The Years of Rice and Salt” by Kim Stanley Robinson (2002 ‘sci-fi’) has a Rönin Samurai walk halfway across a huge continent, get a wife chosen for him and then elected tribal chief. Coulda happened…
In 1964 sci-fi king Philip K. Dick gave us “Clans of the Alphane Moon”… from it I got an idea of differentiation of the tribes along lines of psychological inclinations, with all psychological types represented by tribes. Andre the Giant and Michael Clarke Duncan are representative of early Patagonians. Or something. I still see mountain people and beach people as widely separate, psychologically.
Going a surreal step beyond all this, check out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenneth_Good_(anthropologist)

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, October 17, 2013

History as alabai

European history as begun by Herodotus is often but an Arabian Nights gross exaggeration of reality, filled with misdirection and deceit. Herodotus may not have realized his own complicity in deception, although it is doubtful that even he himself would have denied a tendency to slant fact in favor of the in-group of writer and intended reader. The inspirational story of Thermopolae, where he reports a few thousand Greeks fought off over a thousand times as many Persians, is a fine example. The Persians could not have fed so many, and the topology of the battle site is not as Herodotus depicted it. We can accept that there was an important battle there at the time claimed, but what seems miraculous would have been, had it been. Similarly, it's claimed that Alexander of Macedon conquored the known world, 'though he didn't conquor Rome, the Scythians, the Illyrians or all that much on the African continent. That he didn't even touch most of the Indian subcontinent is excused as it wasn't part of the "known world", but that's like saying Columbus discovered America. At any rate, to suggest that he didn't know of Rome is absurd. These narrations are glorifications. All that matters to much of "history" is to make palatable that which is not true, usually a sense of one's own personal superiority, significance and importance above others. Amazing, really, how easily we tend to fall for that illusion, and how cheap the conceit.
Two later examples of accepted gross exaggeration are Sir Richard Burton and T.E. Lawrence ("of Arabia"), British intelligence agency spies who lied as part of their job, but are honored as heroes. Both had problems keeping any sense of proportion, and both were made suspect by their secrets. With both, truth (as so often happens in history) fell before a perceived need for enhanced image. For them, a "native guide" was in no way important, a leader or even significant to success - but rather, simply disposable. Burton didn't need to study falconry to write about it, he merely needed to transcribe what he was told by "natives". That wouldn't have worked in the USA, where he traveled gathering information on the impending split between the states, for use by British intelligence, but if he could have, he'd likely have written like Karl May, the German who wrote adventure stories of Red Indians he had no real personal experience of.
That T.E. Lawrence adjusted his self-presentation to suit his advantage is hardly strange; he'd have succeeded at nothing had he not done so. Yet it takes little to see through the self-glorification, as he occasionally contradicted himself in his writings, as about never sleeping on the way to attack Aqaba, or about receiving a prayer rug as a gift rather than having participated in the looting of a railroad train. Arabs have given little indication of ever actually falling for his posture of working at least as much for their advantage as for his own. They would never have accepted that as even possible, as, indeed, it wasn't. The book title, "The Seven Pillars of Wisdom", doesn't have anything to do with it's contents, and its presentation was only found acceptable through a perceived need for heroes.
Burton is said to have attained fluency in about 30 languages, a preposterous claim as it would mean learning most of them at a rate of about one per year. Margaret Mead claimed to know 40, and also to have attained understanding of Samoan culture in a matter of a couple months. To accept these claims is either to simply not know what it takes to truly learn something, or to be entirely gullible. The claims are exaggerations, useful towards attaining credibility in regards to other claims of whatever merit, some, perhaps, deserved. If something seems amazing and unlikely, there's reason for it. There may be reason for patting oneself on the back, looking for praise and asserting oneself, but egotism has a tendency to not only alienate others, but blind one to one's own failings, making for pitfalls and pratfalls which can prove quite costly, much as the creation of "empire" has always been costly to all concerned.

Labels: , ,